Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B...
by wtallis on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:44PM
(#5347238)
I said I was unfamiliar with the details. I certainly remember the general circumstances that were at issue, but I never read the ruling or a detailed analysis of it, so I don't know just how restrictive the wording is, which is what I'm now asking about. Your quotes seem to be very nearly on-topic, but it's not clear to me whether they imply that the school's powers would have been different had the speech been a more traditional and recognizable form of political protest. If Morse v Frederick indeed does not apply to the more coherent forms of protest, then I would certainly consider that to be significantly narrowing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B...
by dfc on Friday March 08, 2013 @10:49PM
(#5347252)
I don't know why you are taking my word or anyone else's word for it on HN. If you want to read a quick discussion of the court's ruling just look at 2.1.1-2.1.3 on the wikipedia page:
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morse_v._Frederick#Opinion_of...
Re:9th Circuit Appeals Court: 4th Amendment Applies At The B...
by wtallis on Friday March 08, 2013 @11:08PM
(#5347286)
You can stop pointing me at the Wikipedia article. I've read it, and it still doesn't answer the question. I'd give more weight to a HN comment that does answer the question than to the wiki article that doesn't, even if the comment is just secondhand recollections that somebody qualified clearly said the ruling doesn't affect the legal status of speech that is clearly political. Did Morse overturn Tinker with the help of anti-drug scaremongering, or was Morse actually a narrow ruling on something not covered by Tinker?
Edit: By searching SCOTUSBlog, it appears that the answer may be that the ruling itself is pretty unclear about how broad or narrow it is, though Kennedy and Alito's concurrence clearly states that it doesn't apply to political speech. I guess we can at least agree that Morse might be a pretty narrow ruling.