News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by jlarocco on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:12PM (#5305476)
Gimp on Windows does this and it drives me nuts.

Going to File->Save As... and trying to save to .jpg brings up a dialog box telling me to exit the current Save As dialog and go back to File->Export to save as .jpg. Asinine.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by jordanthoms on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:44PM (#5305699)
Not only that, but it's a _new feature_.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by zanny on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:56PM (#5305778)
What I don't get is that you can open any image type and modify it in gimp on the fly. The reason they are separated is that xcf can maintain layers and any other image loses that information. But anyone who uses gimp for a few minutes will realize this, and then you don't need 3 dialogs. Hell, have a warning message in the save as box if you haven't saved a project in xcf.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by jberryman on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:41PM (#5306485)
I think the new behavior is great. First of all because it remembers both where I'm saving and where I've been exporting in my workflow, and second because frankly saving in GIMP's native format and creating a flat lossy JPEG that approximates the work you've been doing are really fucking different things, and I find it comforting that they choose to make that explicit. I can how if you open GIMP once a month to make a LOLCAT how this behavior could be annoying.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by Turing_Machine on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:07PM (#5306954)
What it should do is save the file in both XCF and the format the user actually wants. There could be a checkbox to turn off this behavior.

That way it would satisfy both the elitists and the people who just want to do their jobs.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by cbhl on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:25PM (#5307031)
You could submit a patch. :)
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by Turing_Machine on Friday March 01, 2013 @08:25PM (#5308026)
I seriously doubt that they'd accept any patch that altered the One True Way that they've decided on.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by sneak on Friday March 01, 2013 @06:49PM (#5307706)
You could stop being an apologist. Neither will happen, though.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by larrik on Friday March 01, 2013 @11:12PM (#5308425)
Yeah, except that you can open a jpg, crop it, and then try to re-save it over itself, and then: Oh, no you can't.

The work flow is really awkward then. You are exporting a jpg from a jpg? Oooookay....

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by hellerbarde on Saturday March 02, 2013 @07:22AM (#5309310)
You can just select "Overwrite foobar.jpg" in the menu. You can even have a keyboard shortcut for it. That should solve all you guys' troubles :)

cheers

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by anoncow on Saturday March 02, 2013 @12:01AM (#5308515)
Since you edited the jpeg, you might want to save the layer and other nfo in an xcf
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by anoncow on Friday March 01, 2013 @01:05PM (#5305847)
It used to do that. I hope somebody reverts this.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @01:26PM (#5305976)
The comments I've found seem to indicate that the Gimp developers have no intention of changing this back, and that anyone who wants it back to the Gimp 2.6 and earlier approach is not in their "target audience". In other words, they hold their most common users in the highest of contempt.

Edit: http://registry.gimp.org/node/26348

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by windsurfer on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:00PM (#5306194)
Contempt? What?

I think they value developers and people who use their software frequently. As a developer, I love the separation of save and export. They really are separate functions, and the XCF actually saves the export location relative to the original XCF location. It makes working on large projects so much easier.

If I wanted to just do a quick edit to something, Gimp isn't the ideal tool for that job anyways. If I wanted to make it so, selecting export instead of save is really fine, especially since it gives the option in the menu to overwrite whatever JPG you just opened.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by kristopolous on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:46PM (#5306515)
I've used gimp since 1997 exclusively and I hate every bit of 2.8s interface ... from the impossible to find dockable tabs that hide every which way, to the laborious change in workflows, to the new way they've decided to do ranges ... making it really simple to choose numbers like 15 bazillion versus 10 bazillion but making it impossibly difficult to easily go between 1 and 4.

And they STILL only have 8 bits per plane (people were whining about this in the 90s ... when Bill Clinton was president), STILL can't remember sub-pixel rendering steps ... other than improved PSD importing, I don't see why.

I'm sure they've put a lot of work into this; but not in the right areas.

Their target audience should be highly technical people that need to do image work and want a tool like vim/emacs/zsh etc but for images; learning curves are ok as long as you can combine simple steps in composable tasks to do amazing things.

I say the same things about all my good tools: "I've been using it for 10+ years, I totally suck at it still, and I would never use anything else". You can say that about paintbrushes, driving, violins, maybe even photoshop or excel; but not gimp.

They were going down that road for a while in the 2.2 or so days, but then they did a 180.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:30PM (#5306409)
I think they value developers and people who use their software frequently.

I use their software very frequently, and the biggest frustration with this is that it completely screws with my muscle memory for the Gimp and every other application. I continue using 2.6 because 2.8 is just too frustrating.

When working with images so much that you no longer think about the keyboard and mouse, but you think "Save" and it just happens, a change like this is like rewiring your hand so that all the fingers' nerves are reversed, and you have to get permission from your navel before you can lift your pinky.

If I wanted to just do a quick edit to something, Gimp isn't the ideal tool for that job anyways.

Gimp has always been the ideal tool to just do a quick edit to something, because it's the tool I know. I've been using it for more than a decade. I don't need some new developers to come along and think they know better than me how I use their software. That's Apple's billion dollar job, and even they get it wrong often enough.

If I wanted to make it so, selecting export instead of save is really fine, especially since it gives the option in the menu to overwrite whatever JPG you just opened.

Clearly you're not working fast enough for your fingers to be ahead of your brain. I don't need options, I need my tools not to talk back to me.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by JasonFruit on Friday March 01, 2013 @03:17PM (#5306699)
That's something Emacs has really gotten right: it doesn't force me to relearn keybindings that are so deep in my fingers they'll come out my elbows someday.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by windsurfer on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:42PM (#5306494)
it completely screws with my muscle memory

I think this is very relevant: http://xkcd.com/1172/

Clearly you're not working fast enough for your fingers to be ahead of your brain. I don't need options, I need my tools not to talk back to me.

If you have any constructive feedback - or better yet, _code_ - make a polite post on their forum or mailing list. No one here cares about your specific workflow.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @03:56PM (#5306893)
No one here cares about your specific workflow.

Actually, you're the only one here vehemently defending the Gimp's new behavior. The other comments seem to prefer Gimp 2.6's Save behavior. But this is getting unnecessarily petty and personal; it's obvious we disagree, and I'll just stick to 2.6 and stop recommending Gimp to people who would otherwise be happy pirating something more expensive.

Edit:

Contempt? What?

Exactly.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by Turing_Machine on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:03PM (#5306934)
I hate it when software changes the workflow.

Don't take it upon yourself to speak for everyone.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by Karunamon on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:20PM (#5306336)
>I think they value developers and people who use their software frequently.

I think people who use their software frequently would take offense to the software telling you to fuck off and go do it a different way.

The intent is obvious, both to the user and the developer. Why make people's lives more difficult for such questionable benefit? MS Paint doesn't have this problem. Photoshop doesn't have this problem. The user knows what they want to do, and they could do it before the change. Why are you getting in their way?

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by bashinator on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:29PM (#5307057)
This very much reminds me of the attitude amongst the GNOME core developers that basically killed the project, per De Icaza's blog post a while back.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by Turing_Machine on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:54PM (#5307178)
Yep. Also of the cavalier attitude toward breaking changes that the Firefox team developed. I switched to Chrome and so did many others.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by Turing_Machine on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:52PM (#5307167)
Wow, the hubris in that thread is unbelievable.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @05:08PM (#5307261)
It's as if everyone in the Gnome/Gtk/Gimp world wants to be a demanding dictator like Steve Jobs, but doing that and getting it right requires an insane budget, and even after all their effort, I still don't like Apple's stuff.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by anoncow on Friday March 01, 2013 @01:50PM (#5306116)
fork gimp! :-) They could still prompt users to save a xcf copy .
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:36PM (#5306448)
There have been multiple forks, but they all end up dying. The ideal solution would be an automated fork that applies the UI patch to the latest official sources, but obviously the Gimp developers aren't going to care if they break your patch.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by windsurfer on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:32PM (#5306419)
Why? The new workflow is better for everything except for quick edits of files. And the GIMP isn't the right tool for that job. Use a smaller, simpler program for a quick edit.

If you really want to destroy your layers and history (which GIMP saves into XCFs) there is a menu option for that. But you almost certainly don't want to do that.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by katbyte on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:26PM (#5307038)
Simpler program? I usually just end up using Photoshop instead :)

When you save a layered file in a unlayered format photoshop just forces the "Save Aa a Copy" option to be checked and then saves a flattened version while preserving the open one, thus if you then decide to quit without saving a layered version you get a "Are you sure you wish to quit without saving document x?"

The way Photoshop handles it is far superior imho. With gimp iirc even if the file is not layered you still have to do export?

And for many edits, i simply don't want to save layers or history. there's just no point if i'm cropping, converting, re-sizing, or quickly fixing something. If i do then i'll save it as a layered file and layered is by far in the minority. I know what i'm doing i don't need the app to 2nd guess me, and it seems the new workflow is better for people who don't understand the difference between layered and un-layered files.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by gknoy on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:48PM (#5307153)
From what I recall, wasn't that the behavior that Gimp used to have? It's how I remember it, and I have used only Gimp for the past decade. I was frankly surprised and confused when the new behavior presented itself.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by zanny on Friday March 01, 2013 @07:09PM (#5307772)
Back in the 2.6 era yes, this was the behavior. It was changed because in my opinion it seems the Gnome Developers since around Gnome 3 jumped the shark. People make suggestions, they argue some divine vision of how computers work, and a year later they are still hemorrhaging users and have little adoption because of their iron clad positions.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:39PM (#5306469)
Use a smaller, simpler program for a quick edit.

So what smaller, simpler program (other than Gimp 2.6) has all of Gimp's features, but is suitable for a quick edit? Say I have a .png image stored in a version control system, with no need for layers or history, and I want to do a quick perspective clone to paint over something?

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by cbhl on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:26PM (#5307034)
Gwenview, Microsoft Paint, among others.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by nitrogen on Friday March 01, 2013 @04:50PM (#5307160)
So, neither Gwenview nor Microsoft Paint support the perspective clone operation. Krita does, but Krita crashes every time I try to use it.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by anoncow on Saturday March 02, 2013 @12:03AM (#5308520)
Is there something like paint.net for ubuntu?
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by iso-8859-1 on Saturday March 02, 2013 @12:24PM (#5310200)
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by emilis_info on Saturday March 02, 2013 @06:24AM (#5309231)
This little Gimp plugin will get you the old shortcuts back:

http://www.shallowsky.com/software/gimp-save/

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by RyanMcGreal on Friday March 01, 2013 @02:42PM (#5306491)
Arrgh, that drives me nuts! I just upgraded from 2.6 to 2.8 and that bites me every. Single. Time I go to save a file.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by epidemian on Friday March 01, 2013 @03:37PM (#5306804)
Only today did i stumble upon this behaviour for the first time (i was used to Gimp 2.6). But i understood the distinction between "save" and "export" and got used to the ctrl+E shortcut immediately. I think it's good that these are two separate functions actually.
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by adam-f on Friday March 01, 2013 @08:58PM (#5308125)
This is pretty the sole reason I don't use gimp anymore and have no plans to go back, ever. I used it on OSX under X11 and had no problems with the mental gymnastics using control instead of command because, well, it wasn't GIMPs fault.

I was so excited when they made it a native app, too.

If Command-E actually brought the window up in front of the rest of the windows instead of hiding it behind the main window, it might have been a different story.

Just my two cents.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by reustle on Friday March 01, 2013 @12:43PM (#5305694)
Gimp on every platform does this. Combine the two already!
Re:Heroku Fucking Console by jiggy2011 on Friday March 01, 2013 @08:22PM (#5308009)
Gimp Save dialog has always sucked in one way or another.

For example, I open a jpg and go to save it as a PNG. I select PNG from the drop down list of available types and type the filename, but unless I also add .PNG to the filename it makes a jpg again.

Re:Heroku Fucking Console by opminion on Friday March 01, 2013 @10:39PM (#5308359)
Gimp's latest user interface is harder to use than Xfig.