Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by dmoy on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:03PM
(#5258907)
This doesn't make a lot of sense to me. I didn't know anybody who worked at Google before I joined, and a good chunk of my co-workers didn't either.
The author may be reading into the question "do you know anyone here?" too much. It could easily be that the recruiters are just trying to figure out if they can ask anyone inside for an internal reference. If not, no big deal. It would just be another signal to use.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by devrelm on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:31PM
(#5259112)
The article is just marketing. He mentions multiple times that he works for Bright.com, "a San Francisco-based company that is building algorithmic tools to match candidates and employers."
He is purposely reading into the "do you know anyone here?" question so that he can make a story out of it.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by jemfinch on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:18PM
(#5259012)
The author works for a company marketing a "a scientifically driven way to quantify the match between a job candidate and an open position" and is making claims derogating another mechanism for matching candidates and position. He's not exactly an unbiased observer.
For the record, I've been involved in hiring here, and I've never asked candidate who he knows at Google, I've never heard of a candidate being asked such a question, I've never seen anything related to such questions on interview feedback, and so on. If Hardtke's account is true (and that's extremely doubtful), his experience bears no relation whatsoever to mine on the either side of the interview table.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by Lewisham on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:34PM
(#5259138)
I've been helping other people through the Google hiring process, as I'm about to graduate from my PhD and head off to Google (I went via the intern conversion, so my experience is atypical). I know a couple of talented undergrads, and some have applied there.
The recruiters have always asked every one that I knew of "who do you know at Google?" I know this because they have come to me saying "The recruiter is asking who I know and you're the only person, can I say you?" They all seem to have a sense of urgency in the question, which indicates to me they've been told it's important.
I think that the OP made it to phone screen alone indicates that he was past the first cut. I would be surprised if referrals matter from that point on, as you say.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by erikpukinskis on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:22PM
(#5259046)
His affiliation is fully disclosed in the article. I don't understand why you're outing someone for "bias" when they describe it in the body of the article. Are you trying to suggest that bias somehow means you're not allowed to have opinions about things related to your work?
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by opinali on Thursday February 21, 2013 @02:55PM
(#5259837)
"Knowing somebody" is something that scores some points in your hiring game, but it's not a deal breaker. In my case I had a few referrers that I only knew online -- some good contacts, but nobody that I had worked together or even met in person. Rest assured you're good enough in the resume and interviews, you should get an offer. Of course, strong referrals can make the threshold for "good enough" a little lower; even Google's extensive recruiting process has limitations. The point of referrals is not nepotism, it's just providing important information about the quality of any candidate.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by chatmasta on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:43PM
(#5259196)
I'm applying to Google right now and was sent a form with an input box called "Do you know anyone at Google who is familiar with your technical abilities?"
edit: I'm an undergrad applying for an engineering internship and have an on campus interview.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by nbm on Thursday February 21, 2013 @03:19PM
(#5260056)
I suspect he may be conflating recruiters and interviewers to some degree, if one assumes he is being honest.
Recruiters know that an employee referral is more likely to yield a hire, so it makes sense they might use that to prioritise those people in terms of scheduling interviews.
It would probably only rarely affect the end result (and if so, only on really edge-case candidates), but it would affect the speed to getting to on-site.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by dfrey on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:58PM
(#5259305)
Hey, it's the person I know at Google!
I came here to say the same thing that you did. The article smells of someone promoting their own venture rather than really critiquing Google.
Both times I applied to Google, I was asked who I knew at Google. Having said that, I didn't get the feeling that saying "nobody" would have really been a deal breaker for them.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by diego on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:12PM
(#5258966)
If the author wants to work at Google and believes that knowing someone at Google is a prerequisite to get hired (doubtful) then he should try to connect with Google employees. It's not that hard, there are tens of thousands of them. Many of them participate in well known open source projects, and are active on mailing lists, social networks, etc.
In other words, the author created a limitation in his mind and didn't bother trying to overcome it. I'd call this anti-resourcefulness.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by mayank on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:34PM
(#5259136)
Go to any Mountain View bar? Use LinkedIn to find FoFs who work at Google? Attend a public Google event and talk to employees? Of those, I'd go with finding social connections to an employee. Google has over 30k employees -- if you're more than 1 or 2 degrees removed from a Google employee, you might be doing something wrong.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by tmhedberg on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:23PM
(#5259048)
I've interviewed at Google NY, and though I do seem to recall being asked if I knew anyone that worked there, I never got the impression that my answer influenced the outcome of the interview process. It was just a friendly, casual question asked as a way to break the ice.
Re:Why I can’t work at Google
by guyzero on Thursday February 21, 2013 @01:33PM
(#5259130)
Per other commenters, this is basically a hit piece on Google by claiming that Google does something that it doesn't do to promote the author's own company which seeks to improve hiring.
The author may be reading into the question "do you know anyone here?" too much. It could easily be that the recruiters are just trying to figure out if they can ask anyone inside for an internal reference. If not, no big deal. It would just be another signal to use.
He is purposely reading into the "do you know anyone here?" question so that he can make a story out of it.
For the record, I've been involved in hiring here, and I've never asked candidate who he knows at Google, I've never heard of a candidate being asked such a question, I've never seen anything related to such questions on interview feedback, and so on. If Hardtke's account is true (and that's extremely doubtful), his experience bears no relation whatsoever to mine on the either side of the interview table.
The recruiters have always asked every one that I knew of "who do you know at Google?" I know this because they have come to me saying "The recruiter is asking who I know and you're the only person, can I say you?" They all seem to have a sense of urgency in the question, which indicates to me they've been told it's important.
I think that the OP made it to phone screen alone indicates that he was past the first cut. I would be surprised if referrals matter from that point on, as you say.
edit: I'm an undergrad applying for an engineering internship and have an on campus interview.
Recruiters know that an employee referral is more likely to yield a hire, so it makes sense they might use that to prioritise those people in terms of scheduling interviews.
It would probably only rarely affect the end result (and if so, only on really edge-case candidates), but it would affect the speed to getting to on-site.
I came here to say the same thing that you did. The article smells of someone promoting their own venture rather than really critiquing Google.
Both times I applied to Google, I was asked who I knew at Google. Having said that, I didn't get the feeling that saying "nobody" would have really been a deal breaker for them.
Of the hundred or so interviews I've given since I've been at Google, I've never asked the question, "Who do you know here?"
In other words, the author created a limitation in his mind and didn't bother trying to overcome it. I'd call this anti-resourcefulness.
I'm genuinely curious.