News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by abstractbill on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @12:49PM (#5245777)
Having lived in the uk for the first 27 years of my life, and then in California for the past 10, I have only one word to describe the way American healthcare feels to me: barbaric.

Long live the NHS, and yay for Obamacare - it seems like a step in the right direction at least.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by Aaronontheweb on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:09PM (#5245913)
Speaking as someone who's had multiple relatives die at the hands of NHS rationing, I completely disagree.

In a system where you can't sue your healthcare provider for egregious malpractice because they're a governmental body and are thus subject to the same citizen-sues-state rules as law enforcement or any other public service, I fear for the quality of our healthcare.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by elemeno on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:26PM (#5246034)
> In a system where you can't sue your healthcare provider for egregious malpractice because they're a governmental body and are thus subject to the same citizen-sues-state rules as law enforcement or any other public service, I fear for the quality of our healthcare.

That's nonsense, hospitals and NHS Trusts are routinely sued for malpractice, along with the doctors involved. There's nothing special about any part of the NHS that makes it impossible for them to be sued - they're not part of the state, they're just state funded. Hell, you can sue most government bodies in the UK since there's no restrictions on suing the state, only against suing the Crown.

It makes your 'multiple relatives' claim seem somewhat suspect.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by Aaronontheweb on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:38PM (#5246121)
Sorry if my comment doesn't please the autistic bias of HN community and greater internet justice. See my response to your sibling comment below.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by elemeno on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @03:12PM (#5246753)
It's not about autistic biases for me, at least not when the topic is the NHS. All of my father, uncle, aunt and other-half are doctors all of whom work for, at least in part, the NHS and are respectively an oncologist, dermatologist, GP and ob/gyn. As you might imagine, I spend quite a lot of time listening to them talk about the NHS, their particular trusts and their hospitals and the failings of all the above. All of them would much rather live here where you'll be looked after by the NHS, and can also have private care if you're willing to pay for it (though often the only difference is that you get a nicer room and shorter waits for non-emergency operations), than in the US where the patient is merely the mechanism through which you bill the insurance company.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by bengillies on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:20PM (#5245990)
Can you explain this please, as I'm pretty sure you can totally sue the NHS if you want to.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by Aaronontheweb on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:37PM (#5246114)
Sure

In one instance in the 1970s I had a great uncle who came into a local clinic complaining about crushing chest-pain, and was told to come back the following day because the attending physician was out for the day. He died on the street of a heart attack while walking home. Why he wasn't immediately rushed to a hospital is beyond me.

More recently, my grandmother, who died in 2004, was wait listed for over a year to get medical imaging and biopsy performed on what she (correctly) assumed was a tumor on her neck. By the time the scan was performed it was determined that she had metastasized lymphoma and the tumor was plainly visible to anyone who could fog a mirror. She died in hospice within a couple of months of being diagnosed.

So what are we to sue for there? Clearly both instances of complete and utter NHS incompetence (and sadly, complacency on the part of my UK relatives) but it's incompetence by omission and rationing, not a doctor embedding a scalpel into someone's tibia.

Had either of my relatives lived in the US, they would have had a much better fighting chance at living than they did at the hands of the NHS.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by elemeno on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @04:11PM (#5247059)
Both of your examples are tragic and clearly represent failings of the system - some of which have since been fixed, and at least one of which would likely have happened in the US as well.

I hope you'll forgive me if I sound callous in this post - I certainly don't mean to, but I also recognise that this is a touchy subject when talking about someone's own family.

In the case of your great-uncle the problem is likely that it was the 70s and fourty years ago there was nowhere near the same awareness of the symptoms of cardiac arrest amongst non-physicians. If the doctor wasn't there, chances are it wouldn't have been picked up on. Even had he been rushed to hospital, his chance of survival would have been pretty low - heart attacks are still a major killer in the 2010s where even in London, which has the highest survival rate in the UK for heart attacks that occur outside a hospital, the survival rate is only 30%. Keep in mind though that survival rates have increased significantly over the last fourty years with advances in diagnostics and treatment as well as improved defibrillators etc.

Your grandmother's case is a more clear cut case of failure. Waiting times have long been a problem in the NHS, but it's a matter of resource contention, and it's a problem which they're trying to improve with the guarantee that patients should start treatment within 18 weeks of their first appointment and that tests should be done within six weeks. The only, very rough, numbers I can find for the US suggests that scans and tests are normally done within seven to twenty weeks when cancer is suspected. Even in the US, the problem of resources exists - there's only so many hospitals that can perform certain types of scans, and only so many doctors who are capable of properly interpreting the results. The thing I can't comment on is whether or not the physician who saw your grandmother should have treated it as a higher priority or if, given the symptoms that were presented, it would be reasonable to assume that there was a benign cause and it being cancer was pretty remote possibility. If it's the case that his prognosis was obviously wrong given the symptoms, then there's a case to be made for malpractice, or at least a complaint to the GMC and/or NHS trust.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by lotsofcows on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @03:29PM (#5246857)
First one sounds odd. What sort of "clinic"? That's not really a word I associate with medicine.

Second clearly sounds like a fuck up. Current "wait to first treatment" target is 2 weeks. What happened when you tried to sue?

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by marknutter on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:01PM (#5245858)
Why does it seem like a step in the right direction, specifically?
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by GiraffeNecktie on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:06PM (#5245890)
One reason is that it represents the first acknowledgement that health care is something that every man, woman and child should have.

That's not to say there aren't horrible things about Obamacare (i.e. terrible business model) but yes, it's a start.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by JackFr on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:37PM (#5246115)
Everyone requires food, clothing and shelter, and yet we use other mechanisms to insure that our citizens don't go hungry. While not necessary for survival, education is guaranteed by the states, and we use a different model for its delivery.

Neither of those is to say that necessarily Obamacare is the wrong solution but its certainly not the only path.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by NateDad on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:48PM (#5246206)
6.7 million households went hungry in 2012. How are those "other mechanisms" working out? Source: http://www.worldhunger.org/articles/Learn/us_hunger_facts.ht...
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by JackFr on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @08:25PM (#5248387)
Food insecurity is not the same thing as going hungry. Changing your food buying patterns, ie foregoing a purchase you might have otherwise made, to buy food is not pleasant, but it is not hunger.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by abstractbill on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @01:14PM (#5245947)
For me there's a very specific, personal, reason. At the end of 2011 I got randomly unlucky and suffered from pneumonia, a stomach ulcer, and a norovirus all in the space of three months. I was hospitalized for the norovirus. After that I was told by more than one insurance agent that I wouldn't be able to purchase insurance at any price, for about 18 months. Obamacare does at least stop that from happening to people. I'd prefer single-payer, but like I said, it's a step.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by marknutter on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @02:55PM (#5246640)
Well, buying insurance to treat a pre-existing condition would be a little like trying to get a car accident covered by insurance after the fact, wouldn't it?
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by potatolicious on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @03:26PM (#5246838)
Yes, but health insurance is not insurance at all. It's really a gross misnomer, and outside of a niche market, no one seriously sells health insurance.

Insurance is designed to protect the policy holder from an unlikely, catastrophic event they cannot afford otherwise - coverage of everyday costs is not insurance. Notice your insurance company doesn't pay to rotate your tires or change your oil.

Health care, no matter which country you go to, is more of the latter than the former. They aren't primarily insuring against unlikely catastrophic events - that's only a small part of their purpose - they are very obvious ways to spread costs around.

You can't treat health insurance like real insurance, even if they share a name.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by marknutter on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @04:16PM (#5247083)
Well then what's wrong with people simply paying out of pocket for basic services? Insurance would be there to cover the truly catastrophic health issues, but otherwise we would all pay for the level of basic service (maintenance) we prefer to pay for.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by potatolicious on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @04:40PM (#5247230)
We have this - this is what one normally finds in the form of health indemnity. They cover (up to some maximum) only emergency/catastrophic costs, and have no everyday coverage.

They are extremely unpopular for many reasons, which center primarily around paying out of pocket for normal services:

For the purposes of this argument I'm going to use "health plan" to refer to what most people call "insurance" - to avoid confusing the two concepts.

- The out of pocket costs for a no-plan person is extremely inflated. Where your insurance company might pay $60 for a doctor's visit, the cost for someone not on a health plan may be $200-300. This makes the notion of paying out of pocket for routine services unrealistic for the majority of the population.

- These out of pocket costs are expensive because the status quo is for everyone to be on an employer-sponsored health plan. Those who can afford to pay, are on a health plan - the bulk of those who aren't on a plan are financially compromised and likely to default on their debts. This encourages a wild inflation of quoted cost to compensate.

- This further drives people to health plans. Barring the ultra-rich, no one is able to afford health care at "free market" prices, making health plans the only reasonable route forward.

In short, what's wrong with people paying out of pocket for basic services is that "basic services" at market rates will set you back $300 for sore throat.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by lotharbot on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @05:11PM (#5247407)
I've been without a traditional health plan for quite a while. There's actually been a lot of innovation in this space recently.

For example, in some locales you can subscribe to a "direct primary care" practice for a family of four (2 adults, 2 kids) for around $150 per month, and visit your primary care provider as much as you need, paying only for supplies or possibly a token per-visit amount. This, combined with a legitimate "insurance" plan with a high deductible, might set a family back less than half as much as a traditional all-inclusive health plan. (This is what I had in Seattle, with Qliance as my direct primary care provider.)

My son recently needed a physical to start school. As a self-pay patient now located in Denver, I called around to independent clinics in my area and was able to get a fairly good price ($110 total out of pocket, paid up front.) My wife was recently able to be treated for an ear infection for around $80.

If you're actually paying out of pocket it can be a little bit of work, but there are ways to get your costs down to close to "free market" levels.

Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by marknutter on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @06:08PM (#5247760)
I recently had my brakes repaired for around $300. $300 for maintenance on my own body seems pretty fair. And perhaps people shouldn't be visiting the doctor every time they get a sore throat.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by abstractbill on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @03:35PM (#5246890)
What pre-existing condition? This was after I fully recovered from the pneumonia, the stomach ulcer, and the norovirus.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by marknutter on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @04:18PM (#5247098)
Sorry, I read your post wrong. At any rate, the analogy still applies - it becomes much more expensive to buy auto insurance after you've gotten into an accident. If you are prone to sickness, I can see why health insurance would also be harder to obtain.
Re:This is how you healthcare: American Death in London by bitcartel on Tuesday February 19, 2013 @02:32PM (#5246501)
Isn't the NHS in the process of being gutted? In fact, the current health secretary believes the NHS is irrelevant and wants it dismantled completely.

http://www.bengoldacre.net/?p=45