I have seen people ruined with medical bills.
There are many reasons why the system is dysfunctional, and I'm aware of nearly all of them.
Did you know that a round of cancer treatment in the US can cost over $500,000, and even if you are fully insured with a good policy you can have a 20% copay required, meaning that with insurance you still personally have to pay $100,000 or more? That sort of thing is what is bankrupting people and is why most medical bankruptcies involved people who were fully insured.
That's assuming your insurance policy wasn't subject to "recission", which is legal retroactive cancellation of the policy as soon as you have any condition like cancer that would cost a lot to treat.
We have a for-profit medical industry, and a for-profit insurance industry and both are motivated to increase profits, and reducing care is often a way to do it. Even non-profit hospitals will price gouge. Non-profit status does not mean that the executives working there aren't paid large salaries, it doesn't mean that things are delivered at cost, or with minimal mark up.
The "reform" is mandating people buy insurance from for-profit insurance companies, with no cost controls. Thus we end up with policies that can cost a family $20,000 a year in premiums, while still having large co-pays that can bankrupt you. The parts of the law that would have provided socialized care for the poor were gutted by the Supreme Court review, and by the executive office rule directives interpreting the law.
The answer to the problem is single-payer. The reform system is a further bailout for industry and is already driving up costs and reducing the number of insured.
Your posts presents those of us who support a reasonable working solution of single-payer as a position of hypocrisy, inconsistency, and/or ignorance, because we don't accept a non-working solution that retains and increases out of control costs and profits for industry.
Not supporting a specific, bad solution does not mean one does not see there is a serious problem and reform is necessary.
I would briefly point out that the $20,000 a year plans you refer to was an example number that the IRS used to illustrate how the law works and not a projection of the cost of healthcare plans in the exchange.
Single-payer seems from scan of Wikipedia to be "government pays the bills" - in other words an NHS like solution.
Which seems to me a position the others in the thread are advocating (ie our current system is barbaric, bankrupts people we must fix it)
So I am a little confused why your post seems to be defending itself from posts that as an outsider I would see as firmly in your camp?
Single-payer means that health care institutions remain private, government does not run or employ any doctors directly, and everything works much like it does today, except pricing is unified and the government pays all bills.
This is different from nationalized health care, especially on paper, where it can preserve market-style competitive pressure that a wholly nationalized system would not. Doctors and hospitals would still be on the hook for attracting customers.
Beyond all that, single-payer fixes prices for an industry that represents a huge chunk of the total economy.
No question at all that we badly need a new system of health insurance in the US (I'm hoping that Obamacare, carefully and aggressively executed, will be it), but single-payer health care is a radical change.
Long live the NHS, and yay for Obamacare - it seems like a step in the right direction at least.
In a system where you can't sue your healthcare provider for egregious malpractice because they're a governmental body and are thus subject to the same citizen-sues-state rules as law enforcement or any other public service, I fear for the quality of our healthcare.
That's nonsense, hospitals and NHS Trusts are routinely sued for malpractice, along with the doctors involved. There's nothing special about any part of the NHS that makes it impossible for them to be sued - they're not part of the state, they're just state funded. Hell, you can sue most government bodies in the UK since there's no restrictions on suing the state, only against suing the Crown.
It makes your 'multiple relatives' claim seem somewhat suspect.
In one instance in the 1970s I had a great uncle who came into a local clinic complaining about crushing chest-pain, and was told to come back the following day because the attending physician was out for the day. He died on the street of a heart attack while walking home. Why he wasn't immediately rushed to a hospital is beyond me.
More recently, my grandmother, who died in 2004, was wait listed for over a year to get medical imaging and biopsy performed on what she (correctly) assumed was a tumor on her neck. By the time the scan was performed it was determined that she had metastasized lymphoma and the tumor was plainly visible to anyone who could fog a mirror. She died in hospice within a couple of months of being diagnosed.
So what are we to sue for there? Clearly both instances of complete and utter NHS incompetence (and sadly, complacency on the part of my UK relatives) but it's incompetence by omission and rationing, not a doctor embedding a scalpel into someone's tibia.
Had either of my relatives lived in the US, they would have had a much better fighting chance at living than they did at the hands of the NHS.
I hope you'll forgive me if I sound callous in this post - I certainly don't mean to, but I also recognise that this is a touchy subject when talking about someone's own family.
In the case of your great-uncle the problem is likely that it was the 70s and fourty years ago there was nowhere near the same awareness of the symptoms of cardiac arrest amongst non-physicians. If the doctor wasn't there, chances are it wouldn't have been picked up on. Even had he been rushed to hospital, his chance of survival would have been pretty low - heart attacks are still a major killer in the 2010s where even in London, which has the highest survival rate in the UK for heart attacks that occur outside a hospital, the survival rate is only 30%. Keep in mind though that survival rates have increased significantly over the last fourty years with advances in diagnostics and treatment as well as improved defibrillators etc.
Your grandmother's case is a more clear cut case of failure. Waiting times have long been a problem in the NHS, but it's a matter of resource contention, and it's a problem which they're trying to improve with the guarantee that patients should start treatment within 18 weeks of their first appointment and that tests should be done within six weeks. The only, very rough, numbers I can find for the US suggests that scans and tests are normally done within seven to twenty weeks when cancer is suspected. Even in the US, the problem of resources exists - there's only so many hospitals that can perform certain types of scans, and only so many doctors who are capable of properly interpreting the results. The thing I can't comment on is whether or not the physician who saw your grandmother should have treated it as a higher priority or if, given the symptoms that were presented, it would be reasonable to assume that there was a benign cause and it being cancer was pretty remote possibility. If it's the case that his prognosis was obviously wrong given the symptoms, then there's a case to be made for malpractice, or at least a complaint to the GMC and/or NHS trust.
Second clearly sounds like a fuck up. Current "wait to first treatment" target is 2 weeks. What happened when you tried to sue?
That's not to say there aren't horrible things about Obamacare (i.e. terrible business model) but yes, it's a start.
Neither of those is to say that necessarily Obamacare is the wrong solution but its certainly not the only path.
Insurance is designed to protect the policy holder from an unlikely, catastrophic event they cannot afford otherwise - coverage of everyday costs is not insurance. Notice your insurance company doesn't pay to rotate your tires or change your oil.
Health care, no matter which country you go to, is more of the latter than the former. They aren't primarily insuring against unlikely catastrophic events - that's only a small part of their purpose - they are very obvious ways to spread costs around.
You can't treat health insurance like real insurance, even if they share a name.
They are extremely unpopular for many reasons, which center primarily around paying out of pocket for normal services:
For the purposes of this argument I'm going to use "health plan" to refer to what most people call "insurance" - to avoid confusing the two concepts.
- The out of pocket costs for a no-plan person is extremely inflated. Where your insurance company might pay $60 for a doctor's visit, the cost for someone not on a health plan may be $200-300. This makes the notion of paying out of pocket for routine services unrealistic for the majority of the population.
- These out of pocket costs are expensive because the status quo is for everyone to be on an employer-sponsored health plan. Those who can afford to pay, are on a health plan - the bulk of those who aren't on a plan are financially compromised and likely to default on their debts. This encourages a wild inflation of quoted cost to compensate.
- This further drives people to health plans. Barring the ultra-rich, no one is able to afford health care at "free market" prices, making health plans the only reasonable route forward.
In short, what's wrong with people paying out of pocket for basic services is that "basic services" at market rates will set you back $300 for sore throat.
For example, in some locales you can subscribe to a "direct primary care" practice for a family of four (2 adults, 2 kids) for around $150 per month, and visit your primary care provider as much as you need, paying only for supplies or possibly a token per-visit amount. This, combined with a legitimate "insurance" plan with a high deductible, might set a family back less than half as much as a traditional all-inclusive health plan. (This is what I had in Seattle, with Qliance as my direct primary care provider.)
My son recently needed a physical to start school. As a self-pay patient now located in Denver, I called around to independent clinics in my area and was able to get a fairly good price ($110 total out of pocket, paid up front.) My wife was recently able to be treated for an ear infection for around $80.
If you're actually paying out of pocket it can be a little bit of work, but there are ways to get your costs down to close to "free market" levels.
Give it 50 years and they'll never go back. The Tories in the UK were opposed to the NHS (AFAIK).
I find it curious and odd that you can't understand another philosophy on the role of government and the individual.
I guess I understand the philosophical argument, from a purely logical perspective, that an individual must stand or fall on their own. But I don't get how people can seriously hold that opinion without living in a cabin in the woods, or in a bubble.
Such matters - often literally of life and death - are not something that ever could be trumped by philosophies about 'roles'.
Yes the market works well in most other spheres, yes economic freedoms are important, but no, economic freedoms (or justice) do not trump human life and death, where avoidable (in a civilized society). Economic freedom is just one of the many things people need for happyness. Health and healthcare are another, that is at least as important. And thus the value of economic freedom needs to be balanced out against healthcare.
The government just is the mediator. Taxing one sphere of life (economic activity) to ensure justice and security in another that fares better if guided by other principles than profit extracted from individual patients.
(individual GPs do profit in the UK system. They, for example, get a bonus if they can make a patient stop smoking, etc. ...speaking of preventative healthcare. They just have less incentive to exploit individual patients (by having them come back later with lung cancer for example) and then charge them to their limit)
What this means is that in the USA it's common for people to have to allow earlier-stage, less expensive to treat problems develop into serious problems before finally going into the ED to seek treatment. Which increases all of our health care costs overall. Not only does the problem that eventually gets treated end up being more expensive than it needed to be, but the place where the care is provided is also the most expensive option. And since they don't pay, health care providers are forced to raise everyone else's rates to cover the cost of this unnecessarily expensive care that they had to provide.
Long story short, the range of things that health care providers have to treat is much wider in countries with more socialized systems than it is in the USA. And that is yet another reason why the USA has such enormously high health care costs despite providing poorer quality of care.
This isn't actually accurate at all. Hospitals with emergency departments must stabilize patients in an emergency. Thats it. The emergency room has no responsibility to treat the underlying cause. It isn't a loophole that people take advantage of because you still don't get treatment. I suppose you could show up to multiple emergency rooms and hope one treats you but that isn't something you do if you are chronically hurt.
People who can't afford to get treatment or aren't on medicaid or charity care don't get treated period. You can test this by just comparing the emergency room rates in Massachusetts before and after coverage expansion. More people went to the emergency room once they had coverage than previously.
There's a hospital in the town where I grew up which managed to shave millions off of the cost of operating their emergency department in a rather instructive way: They identified their most expensive repeat patients, and started just paying to send them in for regular medical care for whatever health problems it was they had. Yeah it meant that they were giving out free health care to these folks, but that turned out to be nothing compared to the cost of having them show up in an ambulance every other week.
Let's not play with words like that. People in the US get treatment—you even say so later, despite your ominous lead sentence. They just get it later, via the ED, after prevention goes un-performed. That's abominable enough, and that's what we should talk about, not the (false) specter of non-treatment.
You two aren't disagreeing.
You say we should talk about the epidemic of people unable to afford primary care, pushing treatment later and later, eventually into the ER where they may not even be able to be saved - and even if they do, suffer long-term health effects due to the delay in treatment.
And he's saying that this is because the system does refuse to treat people - especially at the primary care level.
These two topics seem to line up just fine.
My primary point was that while most things can be debated, it's absurd to claim that people don't get treated in the US.
I have a friend (Canadian) who had an internship in the US. He got a major (and quite serious) bout of the flu, and although he was insured (by a Canadian company) absolutely refused to see him until he coughed up a hefty (multi-hundred) deposit - evidently they didn't find the Canadian firm trustworthy enough.
This is a pretty core issue in US healthcare - early-stage care is routinely denied to people, either economically before they walk through the door, or at the door itself. This pushes a lot of health issues to ERs where costs are high and effectiveness reduced.
The thing that gets me is the attitude is that some people don't deserve free(-at-point-of-use) healthcare. For whatever reason; they haven't paid their taxes, or they've made mistakes in life. It seems unspeakably sad to me. Surely a civilised society should help everyone, regardless? It's the humane thing to do. It's as simple as that.
I agree that a civilized society should help everyone, but don't agree that the USA is a civilized society. There is definitely an attitude that poor people don't "deserve" stuff. That's been an American notion since the first settlers arrived and won't change anytime in the near future.
True, but what if it's something less serious? Some people would rather be ill than bankrupt. And then what if it gets worse, and then it's too late? People shouldn't have to make that choice, especially because most people--not being doctors--are going to make bad decisions about when something is serious enough to get checked out.
A major issue with the american health care system is there is a severe shortage of front line care outside of the ER. This is a side effect of the way doctors are compensated. There is no financial incentive to be a GP, so there aren't enough GPs.
Yes there is. It's called a "primary care provider", and many of them have their offices right there in the hospital. Though the ones who operate out of separate clinics can often be less expensive, if not more conveniently located.
If you don't already have one, you really should. The emergency department really hates it when people clog up their waiting rooms by going there with non-emergency issues instead of seeing a PCP. And your health insurance (assuming you have it) really hates it when you drive up their costs by going to the ED instead of seeing a PCP. And, if there were any price transparency in the American system, then your fellow citizens would also really hate it when you force the health insurance company to drive up their costs by going to the ED instead of seeing a PCP.
If you do not have effective access to care until all they can do is give you a bunch of pain killers, they are effectively "refusing to treat people".
The one thing I noticed, and it was a rule that didn't have a single exception, was that everyone I talked to could give at least one example of a time when either they or somebody they personally knew had been faced with a ruinous bill for healthcare. People who'd been bankrupted, people who'd fled to another state or even left the country to get away from a hospital bill.
And yet even after seeing whole families' lives literally torn apart, first-hand, they still were against any healthcare reform.
I tried then, and I've tried in the years since, but I simply cannot understand where they're coming from. How anyone can support a healthcare system in this day & age that can, and does, bankrupt or refuse to treat people.. I just can't understand it.