News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:04AM (#5230710)
Really, then what exactly would you call it? You are essentially subject to all manner of ridiculous punishment for what would be considered minor or non-offenses in most free countries. Most of their elections are uncontested. You can dress it up because their streets are clean and safe, but it's still facism.
Re:Death in Singapore by agilord on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:31AM (#5230776)
I've visited Singapore just for a few days, but based on that experiment, the western media is overdoing this Singapore-bashing. I'd strongly suggest to visit the country, or at least get familiar with its history, its surrounding neighbors, theirs relationships, theirs relative cultural and economical differences. After that you will understand them better, and you will realize that its not that black-and-white as the media would like to suggest.

Heh, this gets downvoted for what? Oh well, feel free to stay in your bubble, and don't ask questions that will contradict your beliefs.

Re:Death in Singapore by 2muchcoffeeman on Saturday February 16, 2013 @07:01AM (#5231236)
I grew up in Singapore. I was there for almost 17 years. I'm in Sydney now.

Parent is right, a lot of the negative media attention is completely over blown. Things like "outdoor gatherings of five or more persons still require police permits" while I think is still technically true, is never enforced. Obviously, because then you would require a gathering permit for a small family and the police would be running around every day busting school children.

Some of the laws are strict, but you'll see people breaking minor laws everyday with no repercussions. Just like every other city, the police have to use their brains to determine how best to spend their time.

They definitely take some offenses very very seriously e.g drug trafficing and possession. And some things seem a bit crazy like banning chewing gum. But I was there when this law came into effect and the difference it made to the city's cleanliness was noticeable.

There are other good things too. Its quite modern. Smoking is banned almost everywhere. It's really safe. Even for women at night. Public transport is good. It's multicultural and you get all the major religious holidays even if they are not your own.

It's actually a pretty good place to live.

Re:Death in Singapore by philh on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:20AM (#5230869)
> I've visited Singapore just for a few days, but based on that experiment

I spent a couple of weeks in the US, and never ran afoul of bad cops or drug laws. I conclude very little from this, because even if things are as bad as reddit says, I would not expect to run afoul of those things in such a short time if I'm not breaking any major laws.

What bad things would you expect to see in just a few days, if the western media's Singapore bashing is not overblown?

Re:Death in Singapore by gurkendoktor on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:44AM (#5230909)
I'm not sure if the grandparent post really meant it that way. It's not that you don't see anything bad while you are in Singapore, it's that you get a feeling for Singapore's situation. I've only been in Singapore for a short bit and I've met ethnic Chinese who were plenty happy to live in safe Singapore now, and not in the neighboring countries anymore (e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_13_Incident)
Re:Death in Singapore by michaelgrafl on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:40AM (#5230902)
You start off by telling us that you've been to Singapore just a few days and go on claiming superior insight into the country's cultural and political landscape. Then you wind up with a trite statement that contains a bunch of vague terms, is free of any meaning, and condescending to boot.

You're free to stay in your bubble, too.

Re:Death in Singapore by agilord on Saturday February 16, 2013 @01:51PM (#5232506)
After visiting Singapore I've bought Lee Kuan Yew's books and it is really hard to describe his thoughts and point of view in just a few sentences, but at least I have a feel of what and why they did. Since then, I'm following the media coverage of Singapore in the western world, have friends living in Singapore, and based on various observation, I can make my judgment call about what to believe and what not to.

It is not perfect, but if you don't do any of these, and you just rely on the western media, how is it better? If you see the parent of my original post, I don't think it is better in any way.

Re:Death in Singapore by seanmcdirmid on Saturday February 16, 2013 @04:00AM (#5230945)
Come spend a few days in China and you will find that it is a modern country that values human rights with no corruption and lots of social harmony.

Of course, the truth is a bit more nuanced than that.

Re:Death in Singapore by venus on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:07AM (#5230715)
> You are essentially subject to all manner of ridiculous punishment for what would be considered minor or non-offenses in most free countries

Like vandalism and petty theft. And just look at how successful those "free countries" have been in addressing those categories of crime!

What you call "ridiculous" is simply what you have been conditioned to think, no more. Elsewhere in the world it might be called "effective".

Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:11AM (#5230726)
Fascism is very effective.

It's about values and freedom. If you don't care about that, safety is easy.

Re:Death in Singapore by venus on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:18AM (#5230737)
Corporal punishment of petty crimes == fascism. Is that your thesis?

I believe you to be quite misinformed in your understanding of fascism, freedom, and everything else. As far as I can see, the only "freedom" on offer in the society you hint at is the freedom to not be punished effectively for your crimes.

Please, Americans: if you have to mention the word "freedom" in your argument then you are probably talking shit. Think about it.

Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:31AM (#5230773)
I was hoping after editing this reply like 5 times, you were going to come up with something here...

So you only address the punishment issue, but you don't say a thing about the sham elections. And yes, I'd prefer to step in gum once a year than have some 20 year old kid get beaten because they didn't conform to my narrow societal goals.

This is the difference between the west and the east. It is a chasm in philosophy that will never be bridged.

Re:Death in Singapore by jasonlingx on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:20AM (#5230868)
> This is the difference between the west and the east. It is a chasm in philosophy that will never be bridged.

The US kills its own citizens without trial using hellfire missiles in drone strikes. So what's the difference?

Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:33AM (#5230888)
If you're looking for me to defend the U.S., you're going to be looking for a very, very, very long time. I'm as anti-drone, anti-police state as you will ever find a US citizen.

BUUUUUT, I will bite on one thing.

How many Americans have been killed by drones? A handful? How many of those were actively fighting for terrorist organizations? All of them.

Now I do think it's only a matter of time before the US turns that power inwards and starts flying drones over the US. The NYPD already has drones and no one is quite sure whether they're able/willing to equip them with "non-lethal" weapons very soon, but it hasn't happened yet.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_punishment_in_Singapore

This guy above me loves the fact that people are executed for marijuana possession, which is almost completely harmless physically, of negligible harm to society, and largely beneficial to health if not abused.

LOVES IT.

Re:Death in Singapore by jasonlingx on Saturday February 16, 2013 @04:07AM (#5230972)
> How many Americans have been killed by drones? A handful? How many of those were actively fighting for terrorist organizations? All of them.

How would you know? There were no trials.

Re:Death in Singapore by amvp on Saturday February 16, 2013 @04:03AM (#5230954)
> How many Americans have been killed by drones? A handful? How many of those were actively fighting for terrorist organizations? All of them.

(American born) Anwar al-Awlaki's 16-year old son was killed in a separate drone strike, 2 weeks after his father was killed. No suggestion was made that the son was guilty of anything, but that 'he should have had a more responsible father'.

Re:Death in Singapore by philh on Saturday February 16, 2013 @07:19AM (#5231271)
> This guy above me loves the fact that people are executed for marijuana possession

No, I'm pretty sure he never said that, and I'm almost as sure he doesn't.

Your political opponents are not evil.

Re:Death in Singapore by jlgreco on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:28AM (#5230879)
If the US is fucked up, that makes it okay for others to be fucked up as well?

Surely you don't mean that, so I don't understand what you are trying to say here.

Re:Death in Singapore by jasonlingx on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:58AM (#5230940)
I was responding to his statement "This is the difference between the west and the east. It is a chasm in philosophy that will never be bridged."
Re:Death in Singapore by venus on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:43AM (#5230801)
Sham elections? What are you talking about? Corporal punishment and sham elections go hand in hand?

And have it your way. I'd prefer to ride in clean, non-vandalised trains, and the 20 year old would-be vandal was beaten after their first indiscretion, and never did it again.

Seems to be it's less an unbridgeable chasm between east and west, and more a chasm between lazy Berkeley ideology and pragmatism.

Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:51AM (#5230816)
Since you're resorting to catty little twat comments, this discussion is over. Just so you know, I come from dirt farmer immigrants in the Midwest, but keep assuming stuff. It's cute when people like you try to claim some sort of superiority due to your VASTLY superior logic.

TL;DR: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pc0mxOXbWIU

[deleted]
Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:02AM (#5230840)
Such amazing, relevant points being driven home in this.

When is your book coming out? Can I write the foreword?

Also, nice homophobia, "foreigner." I lived for a year and a half in Taiwan, so I've maaaaaaaybe had more experience than you think.

P.S. Elitism is an ism too. You may learn that if you grow up at some point.

Re:Death in Singapore by anigbrowl on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:32AM (#5230777)
Petty crimes such as vandalism and littering are offenses against property. corporal punishment is an attack upon the person. Most people don't consider injury to property to justify injury to the person.
Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:41AM (#5230796)
Large parts of the East consider injury to property, especially "public" property the same as an injury to society. Like apparently the fellow I'm debating with up here.
Re:Death in Singapore by jlgreco on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:37AM (#5230795)
Are you familiar with Sinclair? I've long been a fan of his definition of the term.

As he puts it, fascism is one part capitalism and one part brutality (if I recall correctly I believe he specifies murder, but I think the relation and general sentiment is clear.)

Re:Death in Singapore by bluedanieru on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:05AM (#5230843)
Okay okay, we get it, you're an autocrat. You love power and the powerful. You wrap your lips around the cock of the state. Nice work.
Re:Death in Singapore by jleader on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:09AM (#5230851)
I don't know much about Singapore, but I think it's worth pointing out that while sometimes Facism can be effective, more commonly Facism claims to be very effective, and punishes those who publicly say otherwise.
Re:Death in Singapore by lostlogin on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:03PM (#5232555)
Like every political system. I suppose that the way I see it is that a fascist systems punishes in a way that is worse than the character assassination and innuendo that western democracy offers.
Re:Death in Singapore by jacques_chester on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:54AM (#5230931)
> And just look at how successful those "free countries" have been in addressing those categories of crime!

The crime rate in Western countries, including the US, has been falling steadily since the 90s. Given the differences in cultures and legal frameworks ... nobody is really certain why.

Re:Death in Singapore by vellum on Saturday February 16, 2013 @04:30AM (#5231005)
One theory that's been gaining some attention is less lead = less crime.

http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/01/lead-crime-li...

Re:Death in Singapore by jacques_chester on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:24AM (#5231086)
That's one I've seen. But there are quite a few -- long period of economic growth, the rise of video games, changing diets, changing weather, changing incarceration rates, changing police policy ...
Re:Death in Singapore by buster on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:22AM (#5230870)
I'd describe Singapore strict laws just as effective and strict but in exchange you get a very safe and clean country, no drugs, no garbage, no theft. That's ok with me if (and only if) those laws are not exploited by the government. i don't think this is really the case in Singapore, at least not more then in the U.S. or european countries.

Compared to the surrounding countries Singapore is like _the_ safe place and not the other way around.

Re:Death in Singapore by homosaur on Saturday February 16, 2013 @03:55AM (#5230932)
I don't think their laws are necessarily brutal, but their enforcement of those laws is. They view people who break the taboo of law as people who should be handled with the full force of the state.

And personally I like drugs.

Re:Death in Singapore by buster on Saturday February 16, 2013 @05:33AM (#5231100)
Ah well, just because you like the "freedom" of doing illegal things and the reassurance that if you're caught there will be virtually no consequences, doesn't make it right.

There are people out there that say "And personally i like to beat my wife and kids" and there are societies where this is accepted behaviour.

After being in Malaysia and Indonesia i felt very safe in Singapore and had not the impression of a state the oppresses its people.

In short words: Every country has its rules to live by. Singapore may have strict laws but gains a lot in terms of overall safety.

Re:Death in Singapore by white_devil on Saturday February 16, 2013 @07:35AM (#5231295)
> There are people out there that say "And personally i like to beat my wife and kids" and there are societies where this is accepted behaviour.

Don't equate smoking marijuana to beating another human being. I've never even tried it, for the record, but I don't see anything wrong with getting high if you want to, as long as you don't cause harm to others.

Re:Death in Singapore by buster on Saturday February 16, 2013 @09:35AM (#5231576)
I certainly don't equate marijuana to beating people (where did that word marijuana came from? It was about drugs. What about Krok? [1] Besides, you could count the victims of the drug scene, the mafia, gangs and everything that is behind drugs, bribe, weapons or prostitution. Buying drugs sponsors crime).

Anyway, back to topic. The point is that Singapore has one of the lowest crime rates in the world [2], that doesn't come ouf of nowhere and is bought with very strict laws. Actually i was trying to make a point to not equate your own understanding of legality with another. We are all bound by certain laws and what we take for granted may sound very strange to others. For example, i find it very, very strange that, in the U.S., people are allowed to carry guns. Can't get it in my head. But well...

[1] http://io9.com/5859291/krokodil-russias-designer-drug-that-w... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_Singapore

Re:Death in Singapore by dkersten on Saturday February 16, 2013 @02:46PM (#5232715)
Besides, you could count the victims of the drug scene, the mafia, gangs and everything that is behind drugs, bribe, weapons or prostitution. Buying drugs sponsors crime

That seems to be a side-effect of prohibition though, not the drugs themselves. It was the same when alcohol was illegal in the US. If the drugs weren't illegal, would this still be the case?

Re:Death in Singapore by VexXtreme on Saturday February 16, 2013 @09:11AM (#5231505)
You only need draconian laws like that to enforce the things you mentioned if the local population is naturally so uncivilized that they need to be intimated and/or treated like cattle in order to behave. I'm not saying that's what the Singaporeans are like, but it sure seems like their government thinks that's the case.

Seriously, if you need some crazy draconian law to make sure people aren't littering everywhere, then something is very wrong with your people's culture and level of civilization.

In Japan there aren't any laws like that, yet it's safe to say that it is the most civilized country on the planet. It's extremely safe, criminal violence is virtually unheard of, levels of cleanliness are superb and the people are generally very polite and pleasant in everyday situations.

It's a living proof that you don't need to intimidate people if their morals and sense of responsibility are in check and they know not to do "bad things" because they're wrong and harmful to the society, and not because they will get caned otherwise.

Re:Death in Singapore by buster on Saturday February 16, 2013 @10:27AM (#5231714)
I think it funny that you mention Japan, because only last week i was very surprised how hard you're fined for drinking and driving in Japan, even the passengers of a car where the driver drank alhohol. :)

Do not drive after drinking alcohol. Driving under the influence of alcohol is strictly prohibited and will result in a fine, imprisonment or penalty. When a driver is arrested for DUI, the driver and the person offering the car will be fined a maximum of 1,000,000 Yen, and all other passengers in the vehicle knowingly allowed the driver to drive will be fined a maximum of 500,000 Yen.

And what do you mean with "In Japan there aren't any laws like that"? Are you kidding me? Japan has very strong laws against drugs! So in the end you support my statement.. strong laws = lower crime rate (how surprising). What would it have to do with people. People are not a unique mass, there are drug dealers, psychopaths and what not in every society.

http://www.tofugu.com/2011/12/02/drug-laws-in-japan-youd-bet...

http://factsanddetails.com/japan.php?itemid=664

http://expatsguide.jp/ch6

Re:Death in Singapore by Muromec on Saturday February 16, 2013 @01:03PM (#5232339)
>Seriously, if you need some crazy draconian law to make sure people aren't littering everywhere, then something is very wrong with your people's culture and level of civilization.

And how you change people culture and "level of civilization", by magic?

>In Japan there aren't any laws like that, yet it's safe to say that it is the most civilized country on the planet

Beter to compare to Malaysia (which is way closer to Singapore). Just cross the border and you see the difference.