News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by tlb on Thursday February 07, 2013 @01:35PM (#5183713)
I disagree with the premise that the FAA might understand modern aircraft design better than Boeing. Or that Boeing doesn't have plenty of incentive to make the aircraft very safe.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by alexqgb on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:53PM (#5184147)
This is wrong. And that's because safety deals with probabilities, not absolutes. In the absence of absolutes, people who are also responding to contrary pressures (time, money, etc.) can find themselves shifting the lines between likely, unlikely, highly unlikely, and statistically impossible. This is especially true when dealing with complex systems that defy attempts to model interacting forces perfectly.

[EDIT] The 787 is conspicuously (and very expensively) behind schedule. It also represents an especially large investment of ego on the part of senior management, who were basically at war with their unions, and developed the globally distributed production line for the 787 in response to their conflicts with workers in Seattle. This included the construction of a fleet of supersized jets that could move fuselage size parts-in-progress around the world, meaning parts of the 787 assembly line are, quite literally, airborne. In other words, Boeing is no longer operating in the realm of tried-and-true. To the contrary, they're pushing aircraft manufacturing into uncharted territory.

The premise that this was an intelligent response to labor issues has already come under serious fire, in that the distributed assembly line has been credited with an inordinate number of the delays they're suffering from (relying on sub-contracted manufacturers in Italy, for instance, proved especially costly). So there's already a bit of a siege mentality happening at the highest levels of Boeing HQ, and a lot of pressure to pull off what is, in retrospect, looking like a major miscalculation.

Put simply, if they were going to err on the side of caution, they wouldn't have pioneered outsourcing on this scale using their flagship product in the first place. When the "appetite for risk" comes from the top down, it's much harder for subordinates to draw the right lines.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by SeanDav on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:02PM (#5183881)
To think that a company will police itself adequately in the face of losing money if rules are enforced correctly is naive in the extreme.

Since when has big business ever cared more about safety than the bottom line?

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by larrik on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:09PM (#5183921)
Normally this would be totally true, but given that every airliner crash is worldwide headlines, safety IS their bottom line.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by SeanDav on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:17PM (#5183950)
Safety is always a compromise. The more you spend on safety, the less money you will make. Having the company itself decide when something is "safe enough" is a recipe for disaster, quite literally.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by MichaelApproved on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:38PM (#5184070)
You'd think that would make sense but when deadlines, profit margins and bonuses are on the line, people tend to take shortcuts and sacrifice safty.

Easy example is BP oil spill. You'd think it would be in their best interest to double up on safty because a spill would cost massively more than the safty precautions to prevent it. You'd think. But we see that they take risks and cut corners to meet their deadline while disregarding safty.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by acdha on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:55PM (#5184170)
What about Challenger? Thiokol engineers wanted to scrub the launch but were overridden by their management over business concerns:

http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/02/06/146490064/rem...

It's not exactly the same situation but I think it illustrates the need to have independent oversight from someone outside the same management hierarchy – otherwise it's just too easy to cut corners, particularly since the feedback usually isn't immediate.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by neurotech1 on Thursday February 07, 2013 @04:21PM (#5184558)
It's worse than Challenger. NASA isn't a publicly traded corporation, airlines didn't buy shuttles and people didn't buy tickets on the shuttle. If a 787 crashes due to a design or manufacturing flaw, Boeing stock price will fall significantly, and customer airlines will be very hesitant to order them.

A closer analogy would be the fallout to both McDonnell-Douglas and the FAA after a series of DC-10 crashes. These crashes doomed the company, and they were sold off to Boeing.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by acdha on Friday February 08, 2013 @11:42AM (#5188695)
NASA isn't a public corporation – although it seems rather unlikely that a disaster getting Congressional attention would be much easier – but Thiokol was a private business and would thus theoretically have a strong incentive not to lose a key contract due to failures in their components.

The problem was that they perceived the risk of perceived flaws as high enough that they chose not to act. Market incentives aren't always as simple as they might seem at first glance.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by anigbrowl on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:33PM (#5184335)
...after you've eliminated other possibilities like pilot error, poor maintenance, extreme weather, sabotage and so on. When I hear of an aircraft crash, my first instinct is not to suspect the manufacturer.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by goostavos on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:39PM (#5184359)
The same thing could be said about pharmaceutics, but lo, the FDA now exists for a reason.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by TylerE on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:43PM (#5184383)
Key difference: If a drug is found to be dangerous 10 years down the line, all the people who took it have had exposure to whatever risk, long term effects, etc.

If an airliner gets grounded, people who have already flown on it aren't retroactively at risk, so the worst case (other than the one that actually crashes, of course...) is that some airlines have some very large, very expensive, paperweights.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by mikeash on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:41PM (#5184371)
But not their only bottom line.

To Boeing, a 787 with a safety record so terrible that nobody buys it is equivalent to a 787 that ships so late that nobody buys it.

When presented with a choice between risking a terrible safety record and the certainty of shipping late, which do they choose? In a case like this, from a purely financial standpoint, a company would choose to risk safety, and would be completely rational to do so.

The public would prefer a 787 that was a certain failure to one that was a potential deathtrap, but Boeing's incentives aren't necessarily aligned with the public's desires. This is why we have regulation.

All else being equal, Boeing certainly does have an incentive to improve safety, as you point out. But it's far from their only motive, and in many cases it won't be the strongest one.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by protomyth on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:15PM (#5184255)
I actually know a few "big companies" that will enforce safety (sometimes to the extreme - stand on chair = fired) because the consequences of a failure would destroy the bottom line.

The cost of failure in the USA with our courts is pretty extreme. Look at Arthur Andersen LLP (who won its court battle on May 31, 2005) and the effect that had on accounting firms with a consulting arm.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by 1123581321 on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:41PM (#5184369)
The thing is that Boeing essentially created the FAA and wrote its rules, because nobody else could. And since then they have continued to lead the FAA because Boeing actually makes airplanes. The FAA will never become independent of Boeing unless it becomes an airplane manufacturer itself so it has an independent source of expertise.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday February 07, 2013 @01:44PM (#5183780)
But you can't disagree that this is a classic example of conflicting interests, and exactly the sort of thing that should be avoided when so many lives are at stake.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by tlb on Thursday February 07, 2013 @01:49PM (#5183817)
Whose interest do you think was served by inadequate battery testing?

I'm pretty sure Boeing isn't laughing all the way to the bank right now.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by pfortuny on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:07PM (#5183904)
Short-term PR and benefits: these are much more important than they may seem to be. And also do not forget "keeping my job for these last two years". After all, "we know we do the battery thing right at Boeing, so there can be nothing wrong with them."

Imagine employee A delaying the trials of the "most modern aircraft in the world" because some batteries are "malfunctioning", HE SAYS SO AND IS STILL WORKING FOR US?

It is not just Boeing having a conflict of interests, it is its employees as well.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by ceejayoz on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:04PM (#5183893)
Maybe they thought they could get away with it, and the magnitude of the problem comes as a surprise?
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by justinsteele on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:03PM (#5183889)
Boeing's calculation of a battery reliability threshold would be related to cost of manufacturing vs cost of potential lawsuits related to failures. If they are highly unlikely to fail, and the cost of manufacturing them to an even higher spec is more than the accepted risk, they will not do it. Since the FAA cares less about Boeing's profits and more about the public's safety (hopefully), they would likely have a higher threshold.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday February 07, 2013 @04:02PM (#5184480)
Safety (ability to cause harm) and reliability (potential to not meet requirements) thresholds are different animals.

I work in a regulated industry (medical) and I can assure you that I have never seen a Safety threshold that was in any way related to manufacturing or any other cost. The thresholds are always set according to how much harm can be caused and the likelihood of a harmful event.

Reliability, on the other hand, has tradeoffs relating to costs. However, in this case, an unreliable subsystem can have a clear safety impact, so its reliability directly feeds into the Hazard calculations. In other words, Safety concerns would dominate.

I hope that actually conveys what I'm trying to say. A bit rushed right now :-)

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:14PM (#5183941)
I haven't accused them of malice, though there may have been malice at some level. But, malice isn't needed for Boeing to have something like this occur. Hubris and a lack of objectivity on the engineering team's part can do it. So can merely getting into too big of a rush.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by Uchikoma on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:18PM (#5183955)
So you disagree that this is a classical example of conflicting interests?
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by EliRivers on Thursday February 07, 2013 @03:00PM (#5184188)
Is there, however, an individual or small group inside Boeing who got a nice bonus, a pay rise and/or promotions from it?
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by archangel_one on Thursday February 07, 2013 @01:45PM (#5183791)
But it rather defeats the point of having a regulatory body performing safety checks if the manufacturer does those itself, no?
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by rayiner on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:15PM (#5183946)
It doesn't defeat the point necessarily, it's just a design point for an allocation of labor that involves various trade-offs. Boeing doesn't just give the FAA a single sheet of paper saying "we've signed off on it, it's all good!" At the same time, the FAA doesn't take delivery of a 787 and do all the tests from scratch by itself. Instead, the FAA specifies process, and Boeing does tests and gives the results to the FAA, and the two sides iterate until the FAA is happy.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by protomyth on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:57PM (#5184175)
It actually happens quite a lot in many industries in the US. Not that the government inspectors have a much better track record than the companies themselves. The penalty for screwing it up is particularly high in some areas. I know of one case (food) where the penalties (government onsite workers & other measures) to the operation of a facility applied even after it is was sold to a competitor.
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by tjr on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:37PM (#5184065)
In theory, no, because the Boeing employees should be performing the reviews in accordance with FAA guidelines.

If they aren't, that's a problem. But there are so many checks and balances in reviewing aviation engineering work that it seems unlikely that FAA guidelines would get blown off, even if someone at Boeing wanted to.

Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by CamperBob2 on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:06PM (#5183902)
Simple. Airbus gets to do the design reviews at Boeing, and vice versa. The FAA is just the referee. :-P
Re:FAA faulted for outsourcing 787 safety checks to Boeing by SilasX on Thursday February 07, 2013 @02:35PM (#5184055)
Hey, that's a good idea! We could have a system where two interested parties that want opposite outcomes could present their evidence to a neutral committee, with a government agent determine which arguments can be admitted!

We shall call it "the adversarial system" and test-run it in the legal world!