News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by fleitz on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:10PM (#5126322)
Excellent, hopefully she can fully sully the reputation of the USDOJ to the point where the Senate has to step in.

A horrible case like this is exactly the kind of case to bring to trial before the people to set precedent. The more egregious the violation the more restrictive the regulation will be. The harder you push the pendulum the harder it swings back.

Sounds like she's vindictive enough to dig two graves.

Does anyone know how much traction she's getting amongst the AM radio crowd? Sounds like something that audience would eat up, especially in light of Kelo.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by imjk on Sunday January 27, 2013 @09:51PM (#5126840)
There's nothing scarier to me than people of power who are so drunk in their own arrogance that they refuse to ever accept that they could be in the wrong. I too hope that this come back to bite her.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by cheez on Sunday January 27, 2013 @10:00PM (#5126857)
I believe the nature of the job and ascendancy to the job requires a lack of empathy.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by electic on Sunday January 27, 2013 @06:32PM (#5126185)
This just reeks of being vindictive, evil, stubborn, revengeful, and down right dumb. This woman has no place in any elected office.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by cobrabyte on Sunday January 27, 2013 @06:13PM (#5126100)
Sigh. This woman just doesn't get it, does she? You'd think that the public taking to pitchforks for her job would have led to some serious introspection on her part.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by emkemp on Sunday January 27, 2013 @06:24PM (#5126158)
Or maybe, just maybe, she thinks she's doing the right thing?
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by mpyne on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:01PM (#5126290)
I think it's the Marines that have the saying: "Anything worth shooting, is worth shooting twice." Unless the judge points out some obvious mis-application of the prosecutor's legal logic then it shouldn't be unusual to "weigh an appeal" as the logic was supposed to have been sound enough to warrant the case in the first place.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:15PM (#5126335)
>I think it's the Marines that have the saying: "Anything worth shooting, is worth shooting twice."

The war on drugs is not a war between nation states. This hotel owner is a civilian and a citizen of the United States, not an enemy soldier.

>Unless the judge points out some obvious mis-application of the prosecutor's legal logic ...

Isn't that what the judge just did in throwing out the case?

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by mpyne on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:28PM (#5126384)
I didn't mention anything about the war on drugs. I'll spell out the analogy though: Anything worth trying once for, is worth trying twice for.

> Isn't that what the judge just did in throwing out the case?

Judges throw out cases on non-obvious reasoning all the time. E.g. "the prosecutor failed to consider the test used in this Circuit since U.S. v. Foo (2004) and therefore the charges are moot".

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by jerf on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:58PM (#5126664)
"Anything worth trying once for, is worth trying twice for."

I can give you a far more specific principle. The only solution a government bureaucrat knows for when the first thing they tried didn't work is do the same thing, only harder.

The logic is simple: Any other proposed second solution by the bureaucrat is ipso facto proof that their first idea was bad and wrong. Therefore, this is not an acceptable proposal, since it implies they should be removed from office or should have less power. Clearly, the problem will not be solved by doing less, and it wasn't solved by doing the amount we tried the first time, so therefore, the only thing we can propose is to do the same thing, but harder.

War on drugs? Education reform? Significant swathes of foreign policy? This pattern is everywhere in government, and companies large and secure enough to be dominated by politics rather than market realities. Personally I consider it one of the root problems facing society today.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:53PM (#5126465)
>I didn't mention anything about the war on drugs. I'll spell out the analogy though: Anything worth trying once for, is worth trying twice for.

The context of the case is the war on drugs. That's the pretense for the government trying to steal his hotel, and I get the analogy. The problem is the premise. Even if everything worth trying once is worth trying twice, that doesn't do anything to prove you were right the first time, without which trying again is just compounding the error.

>Judges throw out cases on non-obvious reasoning all the time.

And is that what happened in this case? Because it seems like in this case it was "obvious" that the government was trying to take this man's hotel because it had no mortgage, they expected him to have insufficient liquid assets to successfully contest a seizure and when law enforcement seizes assets they get the resale value added to their budgets.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by mpyne on Sunday January 27, 2013 @09:09PM (#5126703)
>>Judges throw out cases on non-obvious reasoning all the time. > And is that what happened in this case?

I don't know, I haven't checked the details of the ruling.

> Because it seems like in this case it was "obvious" that the government was trying to take this man's hotel because it had no mortgage, they expected him to have insufficient liquid assets to successfully contest a seizure and when law enforcement seizes assets they get the resale value added to their budgets.

Oh sure, real obvious. I'm sure all $1 they'd be able to get for that property would really help boost their training budget...

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 28, 2013 @12:15AM (#5127259)
>I'm sure all $1 they'd be able to get for that property would really help boost their training budget...

From the article: "his mortgage-free property is worth more than $1 million."

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by stfu on Sunday January 27, 2013 @06:38PM (#5126211)
Exactly. Some people see it as confirmation of their "mission" when they face criticism.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by darkarmani on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:38PM (#5126595)
I don't think she is concerned with the right thing unless the right thing furthers her career. That's how prosecutors are measured.

She knows the owner isn't connected with the drug trade at all. She is playing up that angle, so she can put the $1.5M seizure on her resume.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by betterunix on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:29PM (#5126572)
Then she has a pretty warped sense of what "the right thing" is. Not that that should come as a surprise to anyone who has been following the actions of the DOJ...
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by tokenizer on Sunday January 27, 2013 @06:16PM (#5126113)
If she keeps it up, she'll definitely lose any political future, as we usually don't forget things here on the web.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by tedunangst on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:12PM (#5126325)
I've heard rumors that Massachusetts is considering allowing people who don't read HN to vote...
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by dredmorbius on Monday January 28, 2013 @04:33AM (#5127811)
Snark aside, Aron Swartz, and in his shadow, Carmen Ortiz, have had substantial mainstream media play.

The geeks are pretty connected, and while we're not the ruling oligarchy, we (to the extent this herd of cats can be labeled "we") are a significant and growing power bloc.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by manicdee on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:21PM (#5126363)
This will actually solidify her political future, showing that she is willing to make "the hard decisions" and pursue "what is right" in the face of harsh opposition from people demonising her and attempting to sully her name in public.

Remember that most of the people who have any voice in these matters make decisions by reputation, not merit.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by lysol on Sunday January 27, 2013 @07:54PM (#5126468)
When civil cases are used instead of criminal cases it seems particularly disgusting that the government can even appeal a decision in favor of a private citizen.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by jMyles on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:07PM (#5126508)
This is not off-topic. This is about the use of "discretion" on the part of a prosecutor to stifle entrepreneurship. This is squarely and centrally within the mainstream of HN.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by tedunangst on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:46PM (#5126622)
Say what? You think the motive for seizing the hotel was "I'm tired of all these pesky entrepreneurs"?
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by eliben on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:06PM (#5126505)
Please, stop this. This is off topic on HN. A prosecutor's legal battles with some drug-infested motel is not what I come here to read about. Stop turning HN into a tabloid where people read about loved and hated celebrities.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by thesis on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:23PM (#5126555)
I'm not sure about you, but I am not forced to read every article on the first page. Skip over them if they don't interest you. Sheesh.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by eliben on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:41PM (#5126604)
But there's only a limited amount of articles on the first page... I would much rather see something programming/startup/technology-related up there. The threads about Aaron were important. The follow-up threads about his legal case vs. Ortiz were perhaps less interesting to some, but still very much relevant.

_This_ is blatantly off topic. Journalists and bloggers are sensationalist and know how to keep milking a good story when they see it. I do not expect this to overflow to HN.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by shardling on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:49PM (#5126628)
>_This_ is blatantly off topic.

It's worse than that -- it's simply not interesting.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by betterunix on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:27PM (#5126569)
You can downvote articles. Or you could ignore them. For some of us, the state of the US legal system, and the actions of a prosecutor with a fetish for attacking hackers, is something worth paying attention to.
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by benatkin on Sunday January 27, 2013 @08:38PM (#5126591)
> You can downvote articles.

Not on HN, only on reddit. You can flag them.

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by betterunix on Monday January 28, 2013 @11:04AM (#5129008)
Takeaway: don't post things when you are drowsy.

(Thanks for the correction)

Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by frere on Sunday January 27, 2013 @09:20PM (#5126733)
Actually, you're wrong.... ok, glad we cleared that up!
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit by socrates1998 on Sunday January 27, 2013 @06:39PM (#5126215)
Wow, speechless.