Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit
by mpyne on Sunday January 27, 2013 @09:09PM
(#5126703)
>>Judges throw out cases on non-obvious reasoning all the time.
> And is that what happened in this case?
I don't know, I haven't checked the details of the ruling.
> Because it seems like in this case it was "obvious" that the government was trying to take this man's hotel because it had no mortgage, they expected him to have insufficient liquid assets to successfully contest a seizure and when law enforcement seizes assets they get the resale value added to their budgets.
Oh sure, real obvious. I'm sure all $1 they'd be able to get for that property would really help boost their training budget...
Re:Carmen Ortiz weighing appeal for motel owner forfeiture suit
by AnthonyMouse on Monday January 28, 2013 @12:15AM
(#5127259)
>I'm sure all $1 they'd be able to get for that property would really help boost their training budget...
From the article: "his mortgage-free property is worth more than $1 million."
The context of the case is the war on drugs. That's the pretense for the government trying to steal his hotel, and I get the analogy. The problem is the premise. Even if everything worth trying once is worth trying twice, that doesn't do anything to prove you were right the first time, without which trying again is just compounding the error.
>Judges throw out cases on non-obvious reasoning all the time.
And is that what happened in this case? Because it seems like in this case it was "obvious" that the government was trying to take this man's hotel because it had no mortgage, they expected him to have insufficient liquid assets to successfully contest a seizure and when law enforcement seizes assets they get the resale value added to their budgets.