News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by thrill on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:14PM (#5070723)
I think the musings of Philip Greenspun at http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2013/01/16/aaron-swartz-f... that we need to make copyright violation a purely civil matter would be a proper step.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by mpyne on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @11:01PM (#5070865)
That would be a great step. It wouldn't have completely helped Aaron (who was also saddled with wire fraud and computer fraud charges), except that it may have reduced the "loss" calculation enough to not trigger the CFAA provisions.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:01AM (#5071271)
Wouldn't that mean people without assets could do whatever they liked with copyrighted materials?
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by dredmorbius on Thursday January 17, 2013 @03:17AM (#5071617)
One thing they couldn't do is profit from the materials -- as they'd then have seizable assets.

But, yeah, a bunch of broke-ass teenagers sharing music amonst themselves? I'm down with that.

Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by jychang on Thursday January 17, 2013 @06:47AM (#5072137)
What about profiting at a lower price?

Playing devil's advocate here: I agree with "teens sharing music", but what if I sold them for, say, half iTunes price, and made $500. I would deprive an artist while profiting for enough money, and if I spend it, the money is gone. Seems broken.

Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by Peaker on Thursday January 17, 2013 @09:09AM (#5072689)
Why would someone buy them from you at half price, when they can illegally download them for free?
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:50PM (#5074779)
As long as they spent, gave away or hid their ill gotten gains, it would still be out of reach of law suits.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by dredmorbius on Thursday January 17, 2013 @06:08PM (#5075859)
That produces a money trail which, at least in theory, could be tracked and recovered.

If it's an economic crime, chase the money. If it's a cultural crime[1], to quote some Liverpudlian, let it be.

1. In the sense of: propagating the popular culture.

Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @11:11PM (#5077049)
what produces a money trail? If its all cash, its elusive as drug money. All kinds of things are sold for cash and never reported. You've probably left tips that weren't unreported.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by betterunix on Thursday January 17, 2013 @09:00AM (#5072653)
"Wouldn't that mean people without assets could do whatever they liked with copyrighted materials?"

Would that be a bad thing? I can see it now: poor people would be allowed to sing "Happy Birthday to You" without becoming criminals!

Really though, why should we be afraid that poor people will violate copyrights with impunity? Copyright is far too complex and has far too many subtleties for anyone lacking a team of lawyers to work with. Would a judge consider this rendition of "Happy Birthday" to be fair use? If there are 6 people watching the Super Bowl, is that a public performance? Is it OK to let my neighbor listen to music I downloaded onto my computer if they are accessing my wireless network with my permission?

Large companies have the resources needed to reason about copyrights. For the rest of us, it is either "just play along like everyone else" or "you're a criminal and you'll need a team of lawyers to prove otherwise!"

Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:59PM (#5074835)
People can sing happy birthday to you without being arrested. I've done it many times, even when I was poor.

I'd rather see the copyright period shortened so that there is adequate incentive to produce without us having to pay forever. We should pay as much as we need to pay. And not pay more just because the industry has better representation in Washington than the people do.

We could, for example, make a song public domain after 5 years, unless it has not yet produced 10 million in revenue. That is more than enough incentive to write a song.

Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by betterunix on Thursday January 17, 2013 @04:12PM (#5075249)
"Happy Birthday to You" is copyrighted, and public performances of the song likely count as copyright infringement. That is the reason that most major chains have their own version of the birthday song. I am not claiming that Warner is going to send a paramilitary team into your home the moment you sing the song; it is, however, a commonly given example of how out-of-control the copyright system has become.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @11:12PM (#5077057)
People singing a song is not necessarily a public performance.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by gjm11 on Thursday January 17, 2013 @06:39AM (#5072112)
People without assets: that is, precisely those people for whom "I wouldn't have bought it anyway, so the rights-owners have lost anything" is demonstrably correct.

Seems OK to me.

Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @11:15PM (#5077066)
People without assets buy things all the time.