What about profiting at a lower price?
Playing devil's advocate here: I agree with "teens sharing music", but what if I sold them for, say, half iTunes price, and made $500. I would deprive an artist while profiting for enough money, and if I spend it, the money is gone. Seems broken.
Why would someone buy them from you at half price, when they can illegally download them for free?
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good
by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:50PM
(#5074779)
As long as they spent, gave away or hid their ill gotten gains, it would still be out of reach of law suits.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good
by dredmorbius on Thursday January 17, 2013 @06:08PM
(#5075859)
That produces a money trail which, at least in theory, could be tracked and recovered.
If it's an economic crime, chase the money. If it's a cultural crime[1], to quote some Liverpudlian, let it be.
1. In the sense of: propagating the popular culture.
Re:"Aaron's Law" Might Be Good
by stretchwithme on Thursday January 17, 2013 @11:11PM
(#5077049)
what produces a money trail? If its all cash, its elusive as drug money. All kinds of things are sold for cash and never reported. You've probably left tips that weren't unreported.
But, yeah, a bunch of broke-ass teenagers sharing music amonst themselves? I'm down with that.