News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:03PM (#5069944)
At the very least I hope they at least define it in terms of things that actually matter, not cosmetics.

Most of the criticism I hear about "assault weapon" bans, aside from the standard criticism of gun laws in general, are that the things used to define "assault weapon" are largely irrelevant to functionality and that the definition amounts to "guns that look frightening".

It seems to me this is a valid criticism that should be taken seriously by both sides of the aisle.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:18PM (#5070007)
Yeah. I'd like to see guns categorized into three main functional categories.

General (bolt, rimfire of all types, shotguns, probably lever -- and suppressors)

High rate of fire (semiautomatic, particularly semi with detachable magazine -- semi with 5-10rd integral magazine might be general or general+). Fully automatic or burst might be considered HRF+. (there is honestly not a huge difference in performance in most plausible civilian shooting scenarios between a semiautomatic rifle and a fully automatic rifle. Outside suppression for movement, I've never wanted fully auto, including when the weapon I had was fully auto -- except for fun, or if it was mounted on a vehicle). This should include both imported auto and post-1986 auto. 922(r) should also be removed.

Concealable (centerfire handgun, SBR, SBS, AOW)

Have a licensing scheme for purchase and possession, but not registry of individual weapons within that class. If you have a HRF license you can buy any number of HRF or General or General+ all at the same time without reporting anything other than "HRF or lower" during the purchase. It's unclear how HRF and Concealable interact (maybe revolvers or fixed-small-magazines only if you only have a concealable license).

It's unclear what level of training, background checks, etc. would be needed for each. I'd be inclined to raise the purchase/possession requirements for handguns and HRF weapons to the same as concealed carry permits are today in many states, with an actual course of fire, 1-2 days of training, etc., but there would need to be a requirement that such training be reasonably accessible and straightforward.

It's acceptable to me if it takes 3-6 months and ~$500 to get a license to purchase HRF weapons and concealable weapons, provided basic rimfire weapons, shotguns, and bolt-action rifles are available with essentially an NCIC and <$25 fee on top of sale price.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by nthj on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:49PM (#5070167)
> Have a licensing scheme for purchase and possession, but not registry of individual weapons within that class.

I wouldn't care nearly as much about Obama's background check talk if we just exempted anyone with a state-issued CHL license. Maybe add a new class of license, which is optional: run the background check once + training + pay $200, receive a "here's your buy a gun card", or you can just run the background check every time like we do now.

I don't mind that the government does a sanity check on whether a given citizen should own a gun; but if they've decided I'm responsible enough to own a gun I don't really think it's any of their business if I own 2 guns or 12, any more than it's any of their business knowing I own a MacBook, read /. over morning coffee, or bought Star Wars on blu-ray from Amazon 3 weeks ago.

Just like we have state-issued licenses for driving cars, but we don't run federal background checks every time I go test-drive a new ride at the Chevy dealership.

It's trivial to run a SQL query to the effect of "how many times did citizen #12784728 request a background check and when", so if you hear somebody complaining about background checks in the coming weeks, it's probably not because they think crazy people should buy guns, it's because they just want the government to leave them the hell alone.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:02PM (#5070215)
I think there should be an online check for the validity of the gun owner license at time of purchase/sale, but it should be done in a way which shields the identity of the buyer from the government. That's a technical problem more than anything else.

If it's not an online check, it at least should be easy for the FFL or private party individual (with direct sales) to know with high certainty that the person is the correct person matched to the credential, and to know that the credential hasn't been revoked in a certain window of time (daily CRL or something).

I'd have more faith in private industry putting something like this together than government developing it internally or contracting development out.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by Cushman on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:05PM (#5070229)
> I don't mind that the government does a sanity check on whether a given citizen should own a gun; but if they've decided I'm responsible enough to own a gun I don't really think it's any of their business if I own 2 guns or 12, any more than it's any of their business knowing I own a MacBook, read /. over morning coffee, or bought Star Wars on blu-ray from Amazon 3 weeks ago.

How about in the context of having recovered a gun from a crime, and wanting to trace it to the supplier? My understanding is that most illegal guns were first purchased legally.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:23PM (#5070312)
One idea someone proposed was putting the name of the buyer encrypted with a (key physically recorded on the gun) into storage each time, so if the gun is recovered, and the secret exposed, government could trace the chain from manufacturer to last known legal transfer buyer.

I don't think there's a problem with people knowing who owns a specific gun; the problem is knowing what guns a specific person owns.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by nthj on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:55PM (#5070672)
I wouldn't trust the government to not intercept gun shipments from the warehouse with an NSA-style gag order & read in all the secrets ahead of time.

You'd have to be able to stamp the secret at purchase time in the presence of the buyer, which is both doable, and works retroactively on guns manufactured prior to the legislation.

> I don't think there's a problem with people knowing who owns a specific gun; the problem is knowing what guns a specific person owns.

Exactly. Well put.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:16PM (#5070531)
Errr, what are you trying to accomplish here?

Most traces dead end at the point the gun was stolen, the whole registration and trace thing is pretty much never useful in solving a crime.

Now there is some merit in discouraging straw purchases, which are a more than tiny but not "large" source of guns used in crimes, but that's not likely to prevent many criminals from procuring weapons, which in theory is what we're most interested in.

Whereas gun confiscations are always preceded by registration unless they're done during a revolution, so there's a lot of resistance to anything that smacks of registration.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:30PM (#5070582)
I can't find the stats to cite, but straw purchases are a major source of handguns for gangs. They're not the majority of weapons IIRC, but the majority of weapons-actually-used. (this was ~8 years ago that I heard it, and it was being used as an example about something else, so it may be correct, but it came from an LAPD guy)
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:14PM (#5070724)
And these gangs, would they by any chance be involved in drug distribution? Drugs which are imported by the ton?

I.e. I think its a mistake to say "if we can stop this source we'll stop them from getting them altogether". Great Britain, which has the great advantage of being an island, doesn't provide a encouraging example after their total bans.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:31PM (#5070089)
I would have both a Concealable permit and a HRF permit both include a General permit, but not include each other. If a gun fits into both categories, then you would need both permits. So in other words you would have 5 states; None, General, Concealable-General, HRF-General, All.

That all seems very reasonable to me.. which sadly probably means it will never happen.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:45PM (#5070157)
One way it's not reasonable is that pure collectors should be able to own weapons without necessarily being competent in their use, provided they're stored safely. (I mean, I'd love to own antique Japanese swords, but my knife/sword fighting knowledge is essentially prison style -- just get in close and stab-stab-stab as long as you can. There are presumably people who are the same way with guns.)
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:49PM (#5070166)
Seems like enough of an edge-case to make exceptions for. Antique cars have different rules for safety too, so that seems reasonable.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:12PM (#5070258)
Considering that probably a significant majority of firearms are semiautomatic, it seems like you could simplify it a lot by just having one class of permit and requiring it for everything.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:19PM (#5070290)
There are a lot of rimfires (.22lr especially), especially used by minors, competitive shooters, etc. Most shotguns are actually not semiautomatic. Revolvers are a substantial number of handguns, if not a majority, especially for women, first time gun owners, etc.

Part of the point of a progressive licensing system (which I think we should also have for cars, and if we legalize vs. decriminalize drugs, for drugs), is that you can get into the early levels first, build up experience, and then go for the more advanced stuff. It's undeniable that guns have safety-to-others implications, like cars, unlike things like video games, books, etc., so there's a compelling case to regulate them.

I think there are also cases of imminent threat where someone has a reasonable home defense argument for a gun, and allowing a 12ga or 20ga shotgun purchase by any 18+ non-felon fairly quickly solves that. People can disagree about whether CCW or home ownership of guns help or hurt, but it's pretty clear that home defense is a stronger case than concealed carry on the street. If you're unskilled, a home defense shotgun is a great choice; I could probably teach someone with zero familiarity with guns to become a credible home defense gun owner with a shotgun (including legal concepts, etc.) in 15 minutes on a range and an hour or two in a classroom. Couldn't do that in less than 2-3 days with a handgun for street carry from the same starting point.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:18PM (#5070537)
How much of that 15 minutes at the range and an hour or two in a classroom for shotgun teaching is devoted to weapons retention?
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:28PM (#5070579)
That's a problem if you move with the weapon to try to clear something. I don't think I'd feel comfortable even bringing that up (except to say it is a horribly bad idea, and demonstrate how hard it is)

Most CCW holders shouldn't even be moving around with a handgun (which is generally much easier for weapon retention) in a home defense environment. That's more like 3-4 days of range time and 2 days of classroom.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:59PM (#5070684)
So what is a homeowner going to do when they hear a sound in the night? They're not sure enough that it's a intruder to call the police, but they'd like to get back to sleep, make sure the children aren't getting molested, etc.

And WRT to the latter, while of course no one is recommending they clear a building with any weapon, if they have to rescue a child, if there are multiple intruders, if they'd like to make a phone call (e.g. 911) while having the weapon fully ready, there are power/flash and sound issues, over/vs. under-penetration (OK, there are no great solutions there) ... I think shotguns are a terrible idea. Not my insight BTW, picked it up from Massad Ayoob in his The Truth About Self-Protection.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by strlen on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:17PM (#5070534)
> Considering that probably a significant majority of firearms are semiautomatic

Probably the case for pistols, but a rarity for shotguns. Likely split evenly between semi-auto, bolt, and lever-action for rifles, but definitely trending to semi-auto as plurality (if already not the case).

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:24PM (#5070316)
I don't have any sources for it, but the way I imagine most gun owners in the US (guns owners, not vocal gun owners) is just a regular bloke who only remembers that he has an unloaded shotgun in his attic once or twice a year.

Hell, that describes many of the vocal gun owners I know too.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jack-r-abbit on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:16PM (#5069997)
One of the conditions in the original ban was being able to attach a bayonet. Which just seems ridiculous. So you have an otherwise legal rifle... but holy crap you mounted a knife on it... bad bad bad. WTF?
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by MartinCron on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:21PM (#5070036)
Here's an illustration I saw in my local newspaper. Other than the collapsible stock (which makes the weapon easier to conceal) and the (separately regulated) high capacity magazine, pretty much everything is purely cosmetic.

http://seattletimes.com/ABPub/2013/01/08/2020087609.jpg

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:23PM (#5070559)
Important detail: the collapsible stock cannot make an AR-15 pattern rifle "short" beyond a very small amount because the recoil spring is inside it.

It's mostly to allow issuing one variety of weapon that will fit anybody, and fit when wearing serious body armor or not.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by MartinCron on Thursday January 17, 2013 @01:27AM (#5071362)
Did not know that. Thanks for pointing that out. I seem to remember this as a design feature of other weapons, but I am not an expert.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Thursday January 17, 2013 @08:57AM (#5072637)
It's all part of AR-10/15 design, which has one very big issue, gas is injected directly into the receiver (not where you want cruft), but also some big virtues: fewer moving parts and potentially lighter in weight overall, inherently the most accurate semi-auto design (much less is moving before the bullet exits the barrel, and it's all behind the barrel, not parallel with it), and the front is lightweight since the center of gravity is moved backwards compared to piston designs.

I'm told AR-15 pattern rifles rule in 3 gun competitions (pistol, shotgun, and rifle/carbine) because of the weight distribution, which of course also is a virtue in close quarters combat/battle (CQB).

I can't remember this feature in any other designs, but there are very possibly some ones that I'm not interested in and haven't learned the details of. Almost every other design puts a piston forward, which naturally incorporates the recoil spring. There's also the roller locking recoil designs, the ones that I'm familiar with (G3/HK 91, StG 57) have their piston forward as well, although that's not strictly required by the mechanism.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by hga on Thursday January 17, 2013 @02:15PM (#5074547)
Typo: There's also the roller locking recoil designs, the ones that I'm familiar with (G3/HK 91, StG 57) have their spring forward as well, although that's not strictly required by the mechanism.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jack-r-abbit on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:32PM (#5070102)
Exactly. And even the collapsible stock is partially cosmetic and partially functional... but only for ease of use. It does nothing to make that weapon any more deadly than any other.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by MartinCron on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:41PM (#5070140)
I can kind of see the collapsible stock as a functional thing, as it makes a rifle (more powerful and accurate than a handgun) easier to carry in a concealed way, but if that's the case, you could regulate collapsible stocks separately, as well.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:45PM (#5070154)
Seems like a better rule than "has a collapsible stock" would just be "is shorter than [whatever a reasonable length is]", since the problem is less what the stock can and cannot do, and more how long or short the gun can be.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:22PM (#5070037)
Or for that matter, for pistols, "Magazine that attaches outside the pistol grip". That seems to be entirely design preference. What extra danger does one style present over another? It's like they looked at a TEC-9 and said "now, how can we ban this particular gun?".

Or "A semi-automatic version of a fully automatic firearm". Is that to ban guns that are easily modified I guess? Is that necessarily an easy thing to do? Seems you could be more to the point and ban guns that can trivially be modified in such a way.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by efnx on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:19PM (#5070022)
Are there guns that <i>don't</i> look frightening? It really just depends on what side of the gun you happen to be standing.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by jlgreco on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:36PM (#5070122)
It's a matter of degree. Matte black guns with pistol grips look "scarier" than the same gun with a traditional stained-wood stock and grip. People look at one and think "weapon of war" while the other says "hunting rifle". (Obviously both deserve and require the same amount of respect and caution.)

Look at the old Federal Assault Weapons Ban and it should become pretty apparent what I mean.

(PS: you can use italics like this:

  *foo bar baz*
)
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by efnx on Saturday January 19, 2013 @01:52AM (#5082842)
Ah nice, thanks.