Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:18PM
(#5070537)
How much of that 15 minutes at the range and an hour or two in a classroom for shotgun teaching is devoted to weapons retention?
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:28PM
(#5070579)
That's a problem if you move with the weapon to try to clear something. I don't think I'd feel comfortable even bringing that up (except to say it is a horribly bad idea, and demonstrate how hard it is)
Most CCW holders shouldn't even be moving around with a handgun (which is generally much easier for weapon retention) in a home defense environment. That's more like 3-4 days of range time and 2 days of classroom.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence
by hga on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:59PM
(#5070684)
So what is a homeowner going to do when they hear a sound in the night? They're not sure enough that it's a intruder to call the police, but they'd like to get back to sleep, make sure the children aren't getting molested, etc.
And WRT to the latter, while of course no one is recommending they clear a building with any weapon, if they have to rescue a child, if there are multiple intruders, if they'd like to make a phone call (e.g. 911) while having the weapon fully ready, there are power/flash and sound issues, over/vs. under-penetration (OK, there are no great solutions there) ... I think shotguns are a terrible idea. Not my insight BTW, picked it up from Massad Ayoob in his The Truth About Self-Protection.
Part of the point of a progressive licensing system (which I think we should also have for cars, and if we legalize vs. decriminalize drugs, for drugs), is that you can get into the early levels first, build up experience, and then go for the more advanced stuff. It's undeniable that guns have safety-to-others implications, like cars, unlike things like video games, books, etc., so there's a compelling case to regulate them.
I think there are also cases of imminent threat where someone has a reasonable home defense argument for a gun, and allowing a 12ga or 20ga shotgun purchase by any 18+ non-felon fairly quickly solves that. People can disagree about whether CCW or home ownership of guns help or hurt, but it's pretty clear that home defense is a stronger case than concealed carry on the street. If you're unskilled, a home defense shotgun is a great choice; I could probably teach someone with zero familiarity with guns to become a credible home defense gun owner with a shotgun (including legal concepts, etc.) in 15 minutes on a range and an hour or two in a classroom. Couldn't do that in less than 2-3 days with a handgun for street carry from the same starting point.