If our society allocated wealth differently we could afford to fund 1 million projects like that cancer drug instead of spending that money on Anthropic
Ant IPO just seeded a huge amount of multimillionaires many of which will likely fund cancer research.
> If society allocated capital based on what felt good
I have emphasized the important part, lest you still remain confused.
And that was a rebuttal in response to that. In response to you: anthropic going public is simply because the bond market is leveraged to the gills, and investors are looking for returns (of which there are none). Acquiring capital becomes increasingly expensive, thus the time to cash out is now; after having posted as decent of a financial report as they ever could. It's not going to the moon from here.
-meaning generally wholesome and caring humane feeling,
- was being expressed in sarcasm by the other guy, as 'feeling good' was prurient, low, selfishly indulgent.
this is the problem with the philosophy of moral relativity...what is 'good' cannot be agreed in general, and so no matter which 'goodness' an authority, government, parent, or neighbor might hold in _his_ mind/heart, it does not necessarily align with those others in the broad community...
in fact, their very concepts of 'good' may be in opposition.
I never proposed a system to take people’s money and put it elsewhere.
I just responded in a comment chain pointing out the difference between a 2 million and 2 trillion. The person I responded to said the 2 million investment might not pay off and I pointed out you could make a million of those investments for 2 trillion.
I don’t think I’m a particularly greedy dude. It would be nice if we could cure more cancers though. I think most people would like that.
Anthropic has a product that can potentially help develop countless cancer drugs.
> If our society allocated wealth differently
Other societies tried allocating wealth differently. I lived in one, here in Eastern Europe. It couldn't even feed its citizens, let alone develop cancer drugs. Turns out central planning is a much much much worse way of allocating wealth.
For the umpteenth time, the bottleneck in drug discovery is not the design-part, but the trials. Can claude code help with that? Will it breed willing and able adults into existence through its API as participants in drug trials?
You said the above to dismiss that Claude models could help with progress on cancer. My point is that if trials are the scarce thing, making sure the trials are on the right candidates is clearly important. I don't have an opinion on whether Claude can help now, but do believe at some point it can help.
If we allowed compensation for participating in drug trials, then this (putting massive numbers of people out of jobs and in search of income at any cost) seems like something Anthropic is perfectly set up to do, yes.
The bottleneck isn't in-silico screening. "Anyone" can do high throughout docking studies to identify leads, and engage in further lead optimization. At best, Claude can automate some of that... But the bottleneck is lab testing and ultimately clinical trials. It isn't a statistical model of docking, synthetic accessibility, or ADMET.
The only thing computation really gets you is better candidates for testing
> Turns out central planning is a much much much worse way of allocating wealth.
It can be done in such a way that economic hardship isn't common, if China is any example
That said, China has some other very obvious problems the Soviet bloc had too, most prominently suppression of political dissidents.
But the economic idea of central planning itself demonstrably can work
No. Central planning cannot work because it ignores basic human psychology. The fact that it inevitably degenerates into dictatorships is its natural evolution, not an accident.
Coercion is required to override normal human needs and wants. Communism needed "the new man", social democracy needs "the actualized man", socialism needs "woke", etc. But those don't exist - humans tend to react violently to this kind of ideological brain washing.
There is rightfully a lot of skepticism about whether Anthropic can maintain their business in the face of competition, especially from open weights models. But it's undeniable that they do have a product that does work at doing useful things, right now.
Presumably that cancer drug, important as it would be if it succeeds, is not currently guaranteed to produce any useful result at all (even with enough funding).
Meanwhile, the ultra-wealthy are dumping upwards of $2 trillion in capital purely for the sake of speculatively betting on it increasing their capital.
In our society, that capital translates to labor, time, research facilities, technology. Which effectively means that our current system of governance and wealth distribution prioritizes growing capital 200x (40 x 5 years) more than solving a fundamental human disease that has plagued us since we first crawled out of the ocean.
I don't think it's wrong to say 'hey maybe our priorities are a bit mixed and just getting more capital for the sake of it maybe defeats the purpose'.
[0] https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanonc/article/PIIS1470-2...
$2T in capital isn't being dumped here, this comparison isn't comparable at all. Investors have dumped ~200B in Anthropic since 2021 (including today's IPO). The other 1.8T of capital is capital that has been "created". At best you can argue, in comparison to ANT, that it's been valued 4x.
The system is fundamentally flawed and has been for a long time.
I get your point, but only like 5% of Anthropic is up for sale
Plus we're not even counting the subsidized buildouts of datacenters + the energy grid, the bulk of which will be funded by taxpayers by way of increased rates and lowered-to-no corporate taxes.
Also, frankly, a private company trying to make a profit off of a cancer drug is ALSO an abomination.
Sure, I'd love it if governments around the world threw money at cancer research, but claiming that private pharma companies are "more moral" than AI is a losing battle, in my book.
I’m not suggesting we invest all our money as a society into cancer research.
But I think that we could find a lot of important projects that could benefit from a million dollars and that we’d be better off as a society prioritizing hundreds of thousands of those smaller projects over AI a single AI company.