So I've heard.
Most folks don't really care to own media. I'll "buy" a movie on YouTube or whatever if I know I'll watch it multiple times. If the company decides to revoke my license for whatever reason, well they're bastards for doing so, but then I'll resort to acquiring a DRM free version by whatever means necessary.
I mean, blockbuster was a rental service because, after all, I am taking up the DVD. I have 7 days to bring it back because someone wants to rent that same physical copy after me. They charge me a price that allows them to overcome the cost of renting the location, paying the employee, periodically replacing the DVD when customers scratch it up, and make a little money sure on top of that.
Why is my amazon rental the same price as blockbuster I mean really? One of the most profitable companies owned by one of the richest men in the world. I'm sure the overhead on me pulling this file off their servers is in the thousandths of a cents range at their scale, compared to dollars range for blockbuster. So right there that's stupid. 7 day rental also just so stupid too I mean come on, that's greed at that point.
It is just a disgusting business when you consider the costs. I don't feel comfortable paying my limited money into that sort of racket. I'd rather pirate everything.
I draw the line where it makes sense for me. All I'm saying is, every now and then when you're sitting down to watch a movie, consider renting it. ESPECIALLY if it's independent or newer or something like that. Or at least see what they're asking for it.
And hey, sometimes, if you rent it, don't quite finish it in the window or want to re-watch, the torrents will always be there.
I'm genuinely curious why you think $5 or so is acceptable to own something in perpetuity just because it was released more than a certain time ago? What about a decade or two of time makes the movie less valuable to the rights holders?
Gabe Newell is correct - "Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem." Even if I wanted to spend $200/month for all the streaming services, juggling all the apps is going to be more of a pain than going to Plex, where I can have everything I want to watch.
For $200 a month you could rent a lot of movies. Like realistically, how many movies are you actually watching a month?
This does mean anyone without a built up streaming audience struggles to do it, of course.
You also haven't had to wait for a video file to finish downloading for awhile. Even if it's poorly seeded, you can still request and recieve sequential loading. You may, with a rare file, encounter buffering when dealing with just a few peers, but the file is at least available at all as opposed to not available in any way when limitting yourself to streaming (as the vast majority of movies are actually not available via the modern netflix et al)
Waiting on plex scanning is a personal preference, not a technical limitation. "Stream it beginning when I click it" is also a personal preference rather than a technical limitation.
How many silent films can you find on streaming? Bollywood films from the 70s? Japanese films never licensed for western markets? Unpopluar bootlegs that you grew up on? That one particular fan dub of a foreign film that the studios never recognized and therefore never licensed? What if you wanted to watch a rip of a TV show with period and locale accurate commercials (these, admittedly, are not exactly well covered by trackers, but aren't covered at all by streaming services)?
Netflix et al feel like the library of babel because they are designed to feel that way, but the vast majority of movies are only available (digitally) via torrent and usenet, and you can play them immediately if you download ahead of time by curating a list of movies you'd like to watch rather than submitting yourself to hours and days of scrolling through relatively small curated lists created to maximize shareholder profit rather than user enjoyment.
Agree with you on waiting for Plex scanning. You can stream from any device to any other device on your network using VLC.
Also agree on the obscure films. Around 2013 I spent months trying to track down a copy of a movie popular in West Africa, never distributed in North America. I ended up tracking down the director in France, who wanted €400 plus shipping to burn me a North American library-rights DVD copy of a movie I wanted to see once. I declined, and in 2019 he passed away, so I assumed I would simply never see this movie. Now it's streaming on the Criterion Channel, and someone uploaded it to the Internet Archive.
If you've never suffered the indignity of calling all morning to see when someone returns a new release to the rental store, only to get there and someone in line in front of you grabbed the one copy fist, then you'll never understand how spoiled for choice we are in this time. Even original DVDs in the mail Netflix took days to get the movie to you.
Buying physical copies of VHS tapes used to run around $50 in 2026 dollars. Not to mention if you wanted to watch something hard to find. Physical copies of obscure or out of print media were sometimes impossible to get unless you lived in a large city with a specialty rental store, or had mail order catalogues. Maybe you might get lucky and know someone that would record you a poor quality bootleg of their bootleg copy and sell it to you for $10.
Today I can check JustWatch and either be watching it in minutes if it's not some right-locked platform, or just find it "somewhere" and be watching it in less than an hour. Even famously obscure stuff is easy to find now.
Piracy, I have to at least spend some time finding the torrent and getting it on my plex box. Then I have to wait for it to download and for Plex to scan.
I am more often using the legit channels these days because it's pretty convenient and I don't mind supporting those who made the content.