Selective enforcement is inherently unjust. I think people are right to demand either strict compliance, or the elimination of a rule entirely if it cannot be enforced consistently. Yes, that does break some existing compromises. I think it does us a disservice to pretend we can’t find alternative solutions.
Selective enforcement is a good thing because we can never think of all the exceptions. We need a way of admitting that we can't think of everything. "you broke the law for something that would have been an exception if we had thought of that situation in advance" is why selective enforcement should exist.
I don't want to downplay the abuse, but the alternative is worse.
“you broke the law for something that would have been an exception if we had thought of that situation in advance”
I agree this is something our system needs to be flexible enough to accommodate. This should be adjudicated by the courts though, not law enforcement.
Courts are too intrusive and painful. You have to spend days in a courtroom and talking to lawyers and such - instead of whatever you would normally do with your life.
So long as normal life does not incur being selected for enforcement attentions. Court is only expensive if you choose to defend yourself.
Porque no los dos?
I do not understand your point.
I shouldn't have to incur the expense of defending myself when it is obvious to everybody I did the right thing.
There is so much more "selective enforcement" than you think. A good illustrative example is cryptocurrency. How's "code is law" going for the smart contract people?
Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes
by s1artibartfast on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:42AM
(#50542667)
Strict compliance is also inherently unjust, just in a different failure mode. Legal professionals understand this very well, but programmers are about the least likely to grasp it
Generations of useful idiots screeching about low compliance and demand enforcement of rules or systems never meant for it at scale rather than examine what the desired outcome ought to be is a special sort of slow moving "just barely not bad enough to trigger pushback by everyone else" naive evil that underpins a lot of the misery and discontent in the west today IMO