News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by JSR_FDED on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:13PM (#50524935)
To those asking why this is still valuable in the age of AI?

If you learn the fundamentals properly, then AI will be a power tool for you. If you don’t, then it will replace you.

Sorry to be so blunt and I realize there’s nuance - but this is the version that fits on a T-shirt.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by keithnz on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:55PM (#50525358)
except, not really sure undergraduate comp sci is the fundamentals anymore. Lots of comp sci is now replaced by AI, and tricky to know what you need to know to be an effective software creator. Not that doing comp sci is bad and it will develop a deep understanding. There's also an actual track for doing actual computer science (research), but not sure it's the same track needed to create "engineers" (or whatever people want to call themselves now).
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by blobbers on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:08PM (#50526063)
Man, I understand this sentiment so much.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by bagacrap on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:39PM (#50526298)
Comp sci was never necessary to become a swe. It's just one path.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by myaccountonhn on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:07PM (#50526891)
Why is comp sci not the fundamentals anymore? I can agree that you should probably learn the basics of how LLMs work.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by spiderice on Monday November 16, 2026 @07:43PM (#50525842)
> If you learn the fundamentals properly, then AI will be a power tool for you. If you don’t, then it will replace you.

I don't get why people keep repeating this as if we have any idea. How do you know AI will be a power tool to those that know the fundamentals? How do you know it won't replace those people anyway? Why is knowing the fundamentals of computer science going to be the thing that keeps people from getting replaced by AI? You're just repeating something that sounds catchy, as if that somehow makes it more true.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by SugarReflex on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:01PM (#50526005)
I think it's very true. You can do so much more with a calculator if you understand maths, same with programming and AI.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by blobbers on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:11PM (#50526088)
And a computer can do way more than you with a calculator, because its a computer.

The same applies to CS fundamentals, and AI. You can be the best calculator jockey on the block and as mathy as you want, but a computer gonna out computer you.

AI is gonna outprogram you, l33tcode is dead.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by myaccountonhn on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:20PM (#50526983)
CS fundamentals is not leetcode.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by blobbers on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @12:41AM (#50527855)
Pretty sure for a lot of these leetcode hard problems you end up having to implement red black trees and weird graph algorithms. What other CS fundamentals are you talking about?
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by myaccountonhn on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @01:51AM (#50528271)
For me fundamentals include more than algorithms, for example how a computer/LLM works, history, HCI, networking, security just to mention a few things.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by seandoe on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:28PM (#50526218)
Yea I agree. It's not about the fundamentals. The only thing that will prevent you from being replaced is your ability to provide value. Does knowing the fundamentals make you more valuable right now? Probably. But it's not because you know the fundamentals, alone. It's that, chances are, if you know the fundamentals you can probably provide more value than someone who doesn't. You put in the effort to learn the fundamentals so with that you can probably learn other things faster. You probably have a better work ethic. Etc.

But not necessarily.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by blobbers on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:08PM (#50526056)
I think the problem is that in the age of AI, it's not very clear that a lot of these basics are going to be useful, and certainly not to the degree that they were. How many web programmers learn assembly?

I think what people aren't seeing is its more like "if you learn AI, then AI will be a power tool for you". Humans are no longer doing the research to speed up anything related to CS development. Telling the AI "oh you should size your chunks at the L2 cache size of the buffers and when you build your asic make sure it can fit 1024 skbufs so your tcp flow.." blah blah blah.

There might be a select few that work on the fundamentals and need to know how to improve things, but the rest of us those fundamentals will be as useful as assembly is to javascript kids of 2015.

That's all done. Now it's just you plug it in and it is going. Your job is to make sure the electricity and connectivity stay active. You monitor the system.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by username_slop12 on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:24PM (#50526198)
First, thanks to CMU for releasing these courses. That said, I feel this course might be a little late. AI has already gotten much better at math. This year alone, it has solved the ETH, Unique Games Conjecture, and several other problems in CS.

Many top institutions are already using AI to accelerate their own research. I don't know why, but I can't shake the feeling that I'm already becoming obsolete, just waiting to become completely irrelevant.

This is just my personal opinion, of course, and I could be wrong.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by no-reply on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:57PM (#50526431)
probably, but your comment doesn't address what gp said, which is very much true
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by abustamam on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:37PM (#50527500)
This! I don't have a formal education in CS but I taught myself how to make websites and apps and have been a SWE for over a decade.

I haven't touched a line of code in over a year but I still find myself reaching for fundamentals to guide LLMs. Just today I asked fable what the status of X was in my project and it shot out some nonsense, so I challenged it and said "did you git pull?" And it admitted it didn't and gave me an up to date answer. This is what frontier intelligence looks like folks.

And other things like knowing when to index or load balance or use canvas for perf... LLMs will always opt for the path of least resistance, you still need to guide it.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by fastball on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:40PM (#50527522)
[delayed]
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by system2 on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @12:46AM (#50527881)
We are all going to be ai product builders at some point.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by justauserid on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @01:15AM (#50528037)
This trope would end soon. There's a tiny fraction of computer science students who will have "value" in the age of LLMs and they're the ones who actually would work on LLMs/models and stuff very close to those aspects of AI. They have value even today. Rest will be fair game, as they are today.
Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by roncesvalles on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @02:23AM (#50528483)
I'm very open-minded about entertaining drastic societal changes but I just don't think the facts support this prediction.

1. LLM performance has more or less peaked. Since Fable 5 released in June, every Claude model has been a ~1-2% improvement over the last one (if you go by benchmarks). Fable 5.2 marketing verbiage has shifted to how it's "lower cost per task" compared to Opus 5.5. I would bet money this time next year we're not going to have a model that's obviously and significant better than Opus 5.5 or Fable 5.2. (Arguably we already peaked at around Opus 4.8).

2. If you hold that this is about as good as LLMs are gonna get, we haven't found ourselves at a point where we can completely remove the software engineer from the chair. A software engineer is still the best person to be using LLMs to create software.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by xdennis on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @01:25AM (#50528099)
I saw a video a decade ago (Computerphile I think) where an old CS professor was saying that it's useful to learn how to do simple math operations in hexadecimal. Maybe that was useful in the 50 or 60's, but it definitely hasn't been useful for decades.

I fear that learning data structures and algorithms become an equivalent dated advice.

Years for now, Business Insider will do a documentary on "The last programmer keeping an decades old tradition alive" like other videos they've done. E.g.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3Den05Q_D0 . I hope it's me.

Re:Carnegie Mellon is putting computer science courses on Yo... by 10111001 on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @01:37AM (#50528173)
> If you learn the fundamentals properly, then AI will be a power tool for you. If you don’t, then it will replace you.

Those aren't mutually elusive. You could still know the fundamentals and have AI be your power tool and get replaced.

The replacement part is an economics problem. Under basic capitalism: if AI is good enough to get the job done for most people at a cheaper price than you can support yourself, you're getting replaced, no matter how skilled you are.

There are a huge number of smart people currently employed writing software that are also no smart enough to work at the highest, most rarefied levels of it. And they (which is almost certainly you, the reader), have reason to fear.