News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by akudha on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:22AM (#50518547)
I've mentally tuned out of words like sale, discount, deal etc when I see them while shopping. It seems most things are on sale most of the time - how is that even possible? As much as I think Apple is arrogant, at least they don't do this crappy "sale" thing. Right now there is a whole page of "deals" on Microsoft https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/store/b/sale

Walk into any store (JC Penny etc) half the items are on sale. Even groceries - go to Safeway, there is a newspaper style coupons - multiple pages. This whole thing is just bizarre and tiring.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by muvlon on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:25AM (#50518585)
In the EU, there is now legislation that requires vendors to show the lowest price they offered for an item in the 30 days before the "sale". So you'll see something like

20% Off! 8€ instead of 10€ (lowest price in the last 30 days: 5€)

and you know it's a junk sale.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by loloquwowndueo on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:37AM (#50518723)
That’s awesome, what baffles the mind is they still do it because some people still fall for it
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by moi2388 on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:38AM (#50518742)
Should be A year.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by marginalien on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:18AM (#50519279)
This is a brilliant piece of legislation. Great example of EU delivering on its promise of consumer protection.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by nicce on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:46PM (#50520438)
It has failed, because 30 days is too short, and now companies use it to provide false sense of credibility. They bump up prices before that 30 day marker, and they give "massive" sale which has credibility check, and hides the truth. 1 year might make this more difficult.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by Schiendelman on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:50AM (#50519696)
Amazon has done this for a while - there's a button next to the price to see "price history". It's excellent.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by GrinningFool on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:44PM (#50520415)
If they didn't hide it behind a button and just showed the 30-day low, it would be better for customers. Worse for their bottom line though, so they won't.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by tygon on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:00PM (#50520639)
> Worse for their bottom line though, so they won't

Given the number of directly competing products, I wonder if this is true. Often, you are not buying "a thing from Amazon." Amazon is the fullfillment. Amazon is acting as a warehouse and logistics machine. In theory, as Amazon is simply acting as a storefront for many companies, at some breakpoint the higher volume of sales at a lower price and increased consumer confidence that they are getting the best deal possible (and thus likely to buy more in the future) would offset the lower price paid by the consumer on each individual sale.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by rootusrootus on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:06PM (#50520718)
> Often, you are not buying "a thing from Amazon." Amazon is the fullfillment.

For a while now I have been sticking to the rule that I buy nothing from Amazon that is not ships from & sold by Amazon. It avoids most, but not all of the worst issues people have with Amazon purchases.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by tygon on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:31PM (#50521038)
To some extent, I am the same way. While I have not had many problems (I could count the number on one hand) with third party purchases from Amazon, I feel more confident buying something if it at least is fulfilled by them, if not outright sold direct by them. Maybe this is not fair to 3rd parties, but I like the piece of mind.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by thescriptkiddie on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:01PM (#50520647)
that doesn't work anymore, now it just pulls up a chatbot that tells you it doesn't have the information
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by rootusrootus on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:09PM (#50520756)
[delayed]
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by VLM on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:10PM (#50519962)
I'm old enough to remember the workaround for 1970s stagflation which was the model number becomes a serial number. This extended into computer hardware and software of the era.

Technically model 20261116 has never been sold before and is on sale for $10. Please ignore that model 20261109 regular list not on sale price was $9.

It dovetails well with shrinkflation, make the product 10% smaller and lower the price only 5%.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by drdexebtjl on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:27PM (#50520179)
[delayed]
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by nicce on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:45PM (#50520425)
> In the EU, there is now legislation that requires vendors to show the lowest price they offered for an item in the 30 days before the "sale". So you'll see something like > 20% Off! 8€ instead of 10€ (lowest price in the last 30 days: 5€) > and you know it's a junk sale.

Yeah, I think it made things even worse after companies learned how to play with this. Somebody managed to lobby such a short number of days? Should be year. Now it gives false sense of credibility that the sale is legit, while they just bumped the prices 2 months ago. Very easy to see in price comparison. e.g. close to Black Friday. They keep increasing prices so that they reach the highest price around 30 days before Black Friday and then give "credible" big sale.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by rootusrootus on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:04PM (#50520698)
Our federal laws are much weaker, they use terms like 'reasonably substantial length of time' for how long something must be priced at a regular price before being able to marked as a sale price. They never define what reasonably substantial means.

State laws are more specific. Oregon, for example, specifies 30 days, but they do not require notification of the lowest price in the previous 30 days.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by aardvarkr on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:27AM (#50518611)
I heard from a Whole Foods exec that their strategy is to have a “sea of yellow” when you walk in the store. Clearly it works, otherwise everyone wouldn’t do it. Folks love a good deal, even if that deal is the actual price, and will increase the frequency that they come to your store to see what is on sale next.

I just backed a tennis ball machine that was offered at 55% off intended retail price, only to find it was listed online immediately after the campaign for the exact same price, and I felt betrayed.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by al_borland on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:03AM (#50519097)
The problem with this is we end up with completely made-up original prices, that do nothing but serve as an anchor to manipulate people.

Watch start-ups are notorious for this. They'll post insane original prices to make the watches appear higher quality, and like they are playing in a different market... these are almost always cheap watches from China that should cost $50. No one ever pays the original price, and no one should. They shouldn't even pay the listed sale price.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by VLM on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:21PM (#50520089)
Kohls Department Stores (regional, midwest) did this strategy of endless eternal sales and it filtered out everyone who can't stand that behavior, anyone who hates that never shopped there. A small fraction of the population shopped there, recreational shoppers, mostly retired women. Then they tried getting rid of "Everything's eternally on sale" to lure regular customers back, which efficiently got rid of the subpopulation of customers they had, leaving them with no customers. So they brought back sales and coupons, which are strongly WWII-gen and boomer-gen coded.

I personally hated shopping there, because if I wanted a pair of shoes, its like a casino, roll the dice could be $159 this week could be $39 this week, who knows? This lured in another demographic subpopulation who really enjoy gambling, and bragging about their wins while not mentioning their losses ...

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by akudha on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:27PM (#50520169)
Clearly it works, otherwise everyone wouldn’t do it

I dunno, maybe everyone is doing it because they have no choice? If every store in the shopping mall is doing it, then what choice does a new store that just opened in the same mall have?

Or maybe nobody in management positions who make these calls want to even try something different? Afterall, we are in an age where most people in management don't think beyond the next quarter...

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by Anon1096 on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:37AM (#50518721)
Apple is one of the trailblazers of this strategy through the evergreen "student" discount that is very easy to get and saves you $100+ depending on what you're buying.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by wry_xy on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:46AM (#50518857)
They changed it recently. You now need to verify you're a student.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by al_borland on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:05AM (#50519123)
Apple doesn't generally advertise their ongoing student discount. Most people have no idea it even exists. I've told dozens of people over the years, no one had any clue.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by jerlam on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:38AM (#50518735)
JCPenny infamously tried to eliminate perpetual sales when they hired the leader of Apple's retail stores, Ron Johnson, as CEO, in 2011. It turned out poorly when the customer base of JCP was unlike Apple's and really enjoyed the thrill of getting a deal, and Johnson was fired in a few years after falling sales.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Johnson_(businessman)#JCPe...

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by TheBolivianNavy on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:53AM (#50518955)
It's a shame that straight-forward pricing didn't work out for JCP. I loved it.

I hate shopping. I just want to buy the same plain clothes every time and not worry about timing my purchases to sales or what combination of products qualify for a discount. As someone who needs tall clothing, it's usually a miracle to actually find things in stock and JCP actually had a good big and tall section.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by al_borland on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:55AM (#50518970)
I always thought they should have given him more time. It takes time to do a complete 180 on a brand image and find new customers. The existing JC Penny customers and previous CEO clearly weren't working for the business, otherwise they wouldn't have brought Johnson in to try and flip the business on its head.

I would be a customer of Johnson's version of JC Penny, but not of the one that is built on coupons and pricing games. But I don't shop as a hobby, so maybe I'm not the target market for any retailer.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by cwnyth on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:12AM (#50519219)
I'd bet that they didn't want to be another Sears. People like you and I, I think, are in minority when it comes to consumer behavior.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by ajcp on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:10AM (#50519194)
> Johnson's actual execution, however, was described as "one of the most aggressively unsuccessful tenures in retail history".

Big ouf of a quote.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by 10111001 on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:22AM (#50519333)
> JCPenny infamously tried to eliminate perpetual sales when they hired the leader of Apple's retail stores, Ron Johnson, as CEO, in 2011. It turned out poorly when the customer base of JCP was unlike Apple's and really enjoyed the thrill of getting a deal, and Johnson was fired in a few years after falling sales.

I wonder how much of that was conditioning customers to believe something that wasn't on sale was a bad deal.

People don't have an "actual price" database for many items in their heads, so we have to make decisions based on heuristics. One valid heuristic is: "everything at this store is marked up 2x, so if it's not at least 50% off, I'm getting ripped off." It's really hard to get people to change their heuristics, and it takes a long time (time which you may not have).

And I have an anecdotal experience: I went to a JCPenney for another reason, and on impulse grabbed some socks I needed. When I got rung up, the socks were unexpectedly expensive. The clerk said they weren't on sale this week so they were a bad deal. I abandoned the purchase.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by jerlam on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:50AM (#50519695)
> People don't have an "actual price" database for many items in their heads

Yes, JCP products are completely different than Apple products.

An iPhone is an iPhone regardless of you buy it at Apple, AT&T, Target, or Amazon. So people know exactly the actual product and price.

But clothes look all the same even if their quality is dramatically different. People struggle to tell the difference between name brands and store brands even when they can physically inspect the product, and most stores have their own unique sub-brand that cannot be compared to any other products. This is why fast fashion and eventually drop shippers like Temu have been successful.

This has also been happening for a long time in the mattress and TV markets, where no one can compare prices and "look and feels the same" becomes "basically the same".

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by curun1r on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:53AM (#50518943)
> As much as I think Apple is arrogant, at least they don't do this crappy "sale" thing

Apple has, for many years, done “back to school” promotions in late-Aug/early-Sep. These are legitimate deals with the student discount and a gift card or free item on top of it. However, these promotional periods very frequently happen less than a month before new product announcements and spec bumps in late-September, so they’ve effectively dumped soon-to-be-outdated inventory on students under the guise of a deal. It’s a different sort of scummy behavior.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by Terretta on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:11AM (#50519203)
There's a reason Apple resale values (and trade in values) sustain like they do.

It's hard to argue that maintaining that resale value is scummy for the students who bought on discount when they get a job and want to upgrade. (Recently Apple even raised trade in values within the same cycle, while the new price didn't go up.)

Perhaps this is a frame of reference short term versus long term thing.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by directevolve on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:53AM (#50519740)
Sales can give us permission to shop and exceed their budget, and make us feel smart for discovering a hidden opportunity.

Shopping and “deal”-hunting are fun activities for many people. It can be social (go with friends, or tell them about your favorite shop/product), self-expressive (show your discernment or imagination through what you buy), exciting (a treasure hunt), soothing (a familiar, structured process).

And why not? Shopping is how we discover the economy, one of the most mind-bending social structures there is.

Yet I, like you, find shopping tiring. Too many objects, it’s hard to find what I want, I get paralyzed trying to do price per unit weight conversions between ounces and grams, I get cynical about the “deals,” and everything starts to look the same to me. My hobbies are mostly centered on technology and information, and mostly require a few big deliberate occasional purchases. Books, gadgets, or subscriptions to data sources and digital tools are probably my biggest impulse purchases, and they can add up, but the shopping itself doesn’t take up much of my time.

My wife is the opposite. She’s a cook and loves to grocery shop to pick the best produce or find a new ingredient to try. She will spend 45 minutes searching for a new restaurant, and spends lots of time on instagram (half ads) or Facebook Marketplace. She loves going to farmstands because it feels like a discovery, and uses deal-finding apps not just as a way to feel like she’s saving but as a way to add a “side quest” (as we affectionately call them) to her day. She has various tangible hobbies (plants, crafts, pets) all of which require material inputs. I benefit from this because she adds a lot of beauty to our home and variety to our lives that I know from experience I won’t manage on my own. But it has also required communication to figure out how to get us to budget better and not turn everything into a shopping excursion.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by chrisnight on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:17PM (#50520031)
One thing that got me recently is that Micheal’s always has a 30%+ off coupon that you can find on their website with no login and no restrictions. The implication being that anyone who didn’t know about it just pays a 30% markup by default.

It’s really unfortunate the lack of good faith pricing nowadays.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by jerlam on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:28PM (#50520203)
I think Bed Bath and Beyond had the exact same situation with their 20% coupons.

I recently just went to one of their (resurrected) stores and the overhead banner was a blown-up copy of the coupon, so they know their target audience.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by hx8 on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:01PM (#50520646)
You're missing out on actual savings by tuning out the concept of a sale. Yes there are junk sales, items that are always on sale, and misleading sales.

There's also legitimate times when items are discounted for 1-2 weeks a year, or items that get discounted every quarter, or items that are routinely discounted at the end of a season. If you are willing to delay purchase until they are discounted then you can get additional savings. Often times these discounts are predictable, such as brands often offering Black Friday discounts.

It depends on what you buy, and where you buy it from, but there are legitimate deals out there. I probably save about $1000/yr total in these sales just by asking ChatGPT how frequently a brand has sales and then leaving the items in my shopping cart until the next sale.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by elxr on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:05PM (#50521518)
It's easier than ever to document what the "regular" price for something is, what its competitors cost, and when a discount is actually good.

There's only one number that actually matters at the end of the day: the price. And that number is very straightforward to reason about if you've paid attention to what something has cost (even in that Microsoft website example).

It's not like we're buying brand new categories of stuff all the time. Shady discount tricks on the internet have been around for 15+ years now.