News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by jerlam on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:38AM (#50518735)
JCPenny infamously tried to eliminate perpetual sales when they hired the leader of Apple's retail stores, Ron Johnson, as CEO, in 2011. It turned out poorly when the customer base of JCP was unlike Apple's and really enjoyed the thrill of getting a deal, and Johnson was fired in a few years after falling sales.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Johnson_(businessman)#JCPe...

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by TheBolivianNavy on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:53AM (#50518955)
It's a shame that straight-forward pricing didn't work out for JCP. I loved it.

I hate shopping. I just want to buy the same plain clothes every time and not worry about timing my purchases to sales or what combination of products qualify for a discount. As someone who needs tall clothing, it's usually a miracle to actually find things in stock and JCP actually had a good big and tall section.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by al_borland on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:55AM (#50518970)
I always thought they should have given him more time. It takes time to do a complete 180 on a brand image and find new customers. The existing JC Penny customers and previous CEO clearly weren't working for the business, otherwise they wouldn't have brought Johnson in to try and flip the business on its head.

I would be a customer of Johnson's version of JC Penny, but not of the one that is built on coupons and pricing games. But I don't shop as a hobby, so maybe I'm not the target market for any retailer.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by cwnyth on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:12AM (#50519219)
I'd bet that they didn't want to be another Sears. People like you and I, I think, are in minority when it comes to consumer behavior.
Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by ajcp on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:10AM (#50519194)
> Johnson's actual execution, however, was described as "one of the most aggressively unsuccessful tenures in retail history".

Big ouf of a quote.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by 10111001 on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:22AM (#50519333)
> JCPenny infamously tried to eliminate perpetual sales when they hired the leader of Apple's retail stores, Ron Johnson, as CEO, in 2011. It turned out poorly when the customer base of JCP was unlike Apple's and really enjoyed the thrill of getting a deal, and Johnson was fired in a few years after falling sales.

I wonder how much of that was conditioning customers to believe something that wasn't on sale was a bad deal.

People don't have an "actual price" database for many items in their heads, so we have to make decisions based on heuristics. One valid heuristic is: "everything at this store is marked up 2x, so if it's not at least 50% off, I'm getting ripped off." It's really hard to get people to change their heuristics, and it takes a long time (time which you may not have).

And I have an anecdotal experience: I went to a JCPenney for another reason, and on impulse grabbed some socks I needed. When I got rung up, the socks were unexpectedly expensive. The clerk said they weren't on sale this week so they were a bad deal. I abandoned the purchase.

Re:Amazon's Discount Illusion: 1 in 3 "Deals" Offered No Sav... by jerlam on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:50AM (#50519695)
> People don't have an "actual price" database for many items in their heads

Yes, JCP products are completely different than Apple products.

An iPhone is an iPhone regardless of you buy it at Apple, AT&T, Target, or Amazon. So people know exactly the actual product and price.

But clothes look all the same even if their quality is dramatically different. People struggle to tell the difference between name brands and store brands even when they can physically inspect the product, and most stores have their own unique sub-brand that cannot be compared to any other products. This is why fast fashion and eventually drop shippers like Temu have been successful.

This has also been happening for a long time in the mattress and TV markets, where no one can compare prices and "look and feels the same" becomes "basically the same".