Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by p-e-w on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @04:38AM
(#50529337)
I find it very difficult to believe that Lovecraft had not at least seen a photograph or drawing of a penguin, having lived through the heroic age of polar exploration when popular culture was filled with stories set in Antarctica. Even a taxidermied specimen would have been easily available to him in the average natural history museum.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by TFNA on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @05:23AM
(#50529628)
Antarctica was still little known, but penguins were already familiar to the world because they are present in Argentina and Chile in regions already colonized and transited through.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by aa-jv on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @05:56AM
(#50529844)
The first zoo penguin, a king penguin from the Falkland Islands, arrived in England and was put on display in 1865. Lovecraft very much could've seen a live specimen.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by aa-jv on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @02:55AM
(#50543145)
The OP I responded to didn't seem to get it. Anyway, as someone who grew up near Penguin Island, I saw the opportunity to apply some keen facts and I took it.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by jhbadger on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:58AM
(#50530761)
This is also in part a reference to Poe, whom Lovecraft idolized. Poe's "The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket" included a voyage to Antarctica and featured monstrous penguins (and the call of "Tekeli-li", which Lovecraft also borrowed).
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by CGMthrowaway on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @09:34AM
(#50531926)
"Anything that comes out of the South is going to be called grotesque by the northern reader, unless it is grotesque, in which case it is going to be called realistic."
-Flannery O'Connor (on the American South, though it applies to the global south as well)
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by gwern on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @02:53AM
(#50528646)
You see a lot of this in older science fiction. They were writing "science fiction", but we read it as "science fiction".
There's tons of things like ESP or pheromones or giant red suns which a contemporary reader, who's not very familiar with the history of ideas or science, will read as colorful fantasy, and yet the original author was giving a speculation, or believed it was simple fact (https://gwern.net/dune-genetics#scientifiction).
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by WillAdams on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @08:45AM
(#50531287)
An example which arguably should be better known, and which dovetails neatly with the archaeological angle is H. Beam Piper's novella "Omnilingual", available in a lightly updated version at:
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by protocolture on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @05:13AM
(#50529571)
Lovecraft did this quite a lot. The Essential Lovecraft does a lot of "This happened to lovecraft, then he wrote this story" and a lot of it is either stuff he read or things that happened to him.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by api on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @06:57AM
(#50530259)
Same with the golden age of interplanetary fiction with biospheres on other planets. This was open scientific speculation until the space age showed us that they are not habitable, at least not to any life we might recognize.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by kbelder on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:34PM
(#50540308)
"Young, warm, wet Venus" was one common trope that was thought to be likely at one time.
The solar system was thought to have formed from the outside in. Mars is older, drier, colder, deader, with an attenuated atmosphere... Earth is in the sweet spot... Venus is younger, wetter, and too much atmosphere...
Makes sense that old lost civilizations would be on Mars, and dinosaurs and cavepeople on Venus.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by avadodin on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @04:10AM
(#50529162)
When I see a mid(exceptional) fossil, it haunts me with images of sentient interstellar carnivorous plants which used mammals with clear human foreshadowings sometimes as food sometimes as buffoons too.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @10:13AM
(#50532476)
It is absolutely necessary, for the peace and safety of mankind, that some of earth's dark, dead corners and unplumbed depths be let alone; lest sleeping abnormalities wake to resurgent life, and blasphemously surviving nightmares squirm and splash out of their black lairs to newer and wider conquests.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by Spalau on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @10:40AM
(#50532878)
Many tropical forests meet that description: the Darién Gap, the forests of Papua New Guinea, Chiribiquete in Colombia, and the deep Congo. They're so difficult to explore that a lot of these areas remain unknown, and some new diseases have been discovered there.
In Papua, there is a bird that poisons by touch because its feathers contain toxins.
In the Amazon, there is a manchineel tree that can kill humans just by standing under it.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by sph on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @06:01AM
(#50529869)
As an online discussion about Lovecraft grows longer, the probability that some edgy smartass comments about his racial prejudices or the name of his cat approaches 1.
I get it, it's very popular among the 13 years olds on Reddit.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by peddling-brink on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @09:41AM
(#50532038)
I didn’t see the comment you’re replying to, but I’m not sure a conversation about Lovecraft would be complete without mention of his racial prejudices.
Why not talk about it? Does it make Lovecraftian horror less-than?
I would argue that his fear of everything allowed him to convey that fear in a way that captures the reader.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by sph on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @07:40PM
(#50540352)
Yes, because derailing a literary discussion with a side argument on racism and slur usage across the years will create a very interesting and enlightening discussion on a public forum. One that certainly has never been done before.
You can go read about his racial prejudices and the effects on his writing on Wikipedia if you truly can’t help yourself.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by markus_zhang on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @08:24AM
(#50531034)
I discovered H.P.Lovecraft in my late teens. I was troubled, didn’t know what I want (still sketchy), so HPL filled in the void perfectly. Almost too perfectly.
I was naive enough to believe that Necronomicon is a real book and Abdul Alhazred was a real Arabian who practiced Occult. As a troubled teen I was willing to believe in anything that is bigger than the human-being (and still am), as long as there is a way to prove for or against it. I was even ready to believe that it was a Demon that slaughtered him in broad daylight, as long as I can see one with my eyes. After all I’m still a scientific man, who is willing to discuss with God about the universe he created if he is willing.
There is plenty of pleasure in uncovering hidden (Occult) knowledge and there is no greater pleasure than uncovering that of God.
Back to the topic, I read about his life and remember that he was very into Chemistry and other scientific topics since teenage. I particularly love the way he described the aliens, or the Old Ones, as they are different from the humanoid aliens we are more familiar with nowadays. His penmanship on the Cosmic Horror was also unique —- so many movies and games tried to catch the spirit but few managed to do so. I still get a little uneasy reading his books sometimes.
May Azathoth grant you madness and Nylathethop open your eyes.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by markus_zhang on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @09:54AM
(#50532200)
I’d say, I do hope some of it has some truth in it. As a scientific man I refuse to believe anything that has not been proved (“proved” may have many interpretations so let’s leave the details).
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by mock-possum on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @02:24PM
(#50536791)
No, that’s on him - he’s all knowing and all powerful, so ostensibly he knows precisely how to be clear on his communication, and instead chooses to be obtuse. How convenient that he doesn’t simply appear and say “here I am.” Because of course then the game would be over wouldn’t it? No no, he ‘works in mysterious ways’ claim his apologists, you have to pay the right sort of attention to see him, you have to trust, you have to believe.
Meanwhile, I play no such games with other people. Here I am, you needn’t believe in me, because the proof is right in front of you.
Aren’t I more real, and more accessible, than your god? Why not worship me, a being who is acthally evidently present, and capable of changing the world around me? If you pray to me in writing, there’s at least a chance I might answer you. Can your god promise that? He cannot.
Re:The Fossils That Haunted Lovecraft
by legacynl on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @10:32AM
(#50532761)
Although that's admirable in a sense, a scientific man would think about talking to god as much as talking to the invisible yellow elephant that lives in my garden.
Part of science is that it only really makes sense to talk about falsifiable things. It's good to realize that the existence of god can never be disproven, but that also makes any discussion about it meaningless.
"On the barren shore, and on the lofty ice barrier in the background, myriads of grotesque penguins squawked and flapped their fins"
AI goes onto say, "This slogan remains one of the most recognizable British confectionery taglines"
https://www.londonzoo.org/zoo-stories/blog/penguins-through-...
-Flannery O'Connor (on the American South, though it applies to the global south as well)
There's tons of things like ESP or pheromones or giant red suns which a contemporary reader, who's not very familiar with the history of ideas or science, will read as colorful fantasy, and yet the original author was giving a speculation, or believed it was simple fact (https://gwern.net/dune-genetics#scientifiction).
https://vrici.lojban.org/~cowan/omnilingual.html
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1590092.Omnilingual
The solar system was thought to have formed from the outside in. Mars is older, drier, colder, deader, with an attenuated atmosphere... Earth is in the sweet spot... Venus is younger, wetter, and too much atmosphere...
Makes sense that old lost civilizations would be on Mars, and dinosaurs and cavepeople on Venus.
In Papua, there is a bird that poisons by touch because its feathers contain toxins.
In the Amazon, there is a manchineel tree that can kill humans just by standing under it.
"There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, / Than are dreamt of in your philosophy." Hamlet
I get it, it's very popular among the 13 years olds on Reddit.
Why not talk about it? Does it make Lovecraftian horror less-than?
I would argue that his fear of everything allowed him to convey that fear in a way that captures the reader.
You can go read about his racial prejudices and the effects on his writing on Wikipedia if you truly can’t help yourself.
There is a time and place for some topics.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S87563...
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7732801/
Even today one encounters either humanoid aliens or aliens with very human like cognition and motives.
Real aliens I’d expect to be more like the Mi-Go, my favorite of his ET races. The “fungi from Yuggoth.”
I was naive enough to believe that Necronomicon is a real book and Abdul Alhazred was a real Arabian who practiced Occult. As a troubled teen I was willing to believe in anything that is bigger than the human-being (and still am), as long as there is a way to prove for or against it. I was even ready to believe that it was a Demon that slaughtered him in broad daylight, as long as I can see one with my eyes. After all I’m still a scientific man, who is willing to discuss with God about the universe he created if he is willing.
There is plenty of pleasure in uncovering hidden (Occult) knowledge and there is no greater pleasure than uncovering that of God.
Back to the topic, I read about his life and remember that he was very into Chemistry and other scientific topics since teenage. I particularly love the way he described the aliens, or the Old Ones, as they are different from the humanoid aliens we are more familiar with nowadays. His penmanship on the Cosmic Horror was also unique —- so many movies and games tried to catch the spirit but few managed to do so. I still get a little uneasy reading his books sometimes.
May Azathoth grant you madness and Nylathethop open your eyes.
Meanwhile, I play no such games with other people. Here I am, you needn’t believe in me, because the proof is right in front of you.
Aren’t I more real, and more accessible, than your god? Why not worship me, a being who is acthally evidently present, and capable of changing the world around me? If you pray to me in writing, there’s at least a chance I might answer you. Can your god promise that? He cannot.
Part of science is that it only really makes sense to talk about falsifiable things. It's good to realize that the existence of god can never be disproven, but that also makes any discussion about it meaningless.