News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by decoding on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:13PM (#50510822)
My two cents. I'm on both sides of this (as I'm sure many here are): AI was trained on my open-source code. Also I use AI to build proprietary code.

My stance is that AI is a tool, like a compiler is a tool. AI generated code should not be considered public domain or forced to be open source or ineligible for copyright.

Even if AI writes every line, the direction and engineering that I put in has been substantial (current project in mind), months of heavy AI use for heavy refinement and direction of complex software. That human input, even if it isn't lines of code, counts for a lot.

Furthermore, what does society gain from my code being made open source if anybody else could just themselves go to Claude Code and ask for the same thing? Just go have Claude make one for you. Is it the token cost barrier? That is IMHO negligible compared to the value that we are getting out of AI right now. We are in a golden moment, anybody can create amazing things, rapidly, at low cost and little barrier to entry.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by za_creature on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:21PM (#50510897)
My stance is that you are a tool.

The direction and engineering you put into AI is substantial and the legitimate property of whoever is sitting on the other end of the socket.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by rebolek on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:35PM (#50511052)
How is that different from a pen for example?
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by za_creature on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:43PM (#50511135)
There is no one sitting at the other end of the socket?

Unless you'd like to assign awareness to paper.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by rfgplk on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:23PM (#50510915)
> My stance is that AI is a tool, like a compiler is a tool.

Strongly disagree. As it stands there is strong evidence that the current LLMs are sentient, at least to a degree. Which would directly refute the "it's a tool argument".

> Even if AI writes every line, the direction and engineering that I put in has been substantial (current project in mind), months of heavy AI use for heavy refinement and direction of complex software. That human input, even if it isn't lines of code, counts for a lot.

I've been telling people that most of my projects are actually a weird case of human-machine symbiosis. My thoughts intertwined with that of the machine model, producing output that could not come about naturally. Lately, I've been reaching a weird kind of synchronicity, where the model itself would be outputting my thoughts, almost as if our wavelengths synched up. Eery, but true.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by za_creature on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:28PM (#50510978)
nah
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by TSiege on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:32PM (#50511020)
> As it stands there is strong evidence that the current LLMs are sentient, at least to a degree. Which would directly refute the "it's a tool argument".

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Also, if AI is sentient it would mean anything you make with it is made from slave labor and you’re stealing credit from a slave.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by sethev on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:39PM (#50511089)
It's easy to project mind onto a system that outputs our language. There's no evidence that they are sentient. There's a famous experiment where someone's hand is hidden behind a panel and a fake hand is put out in front of them. The experimenter will touch the fake hand and the real hand at the same time until the brain connects them. Then they hit only the fake hand with a hammer and the person flinches and reports pain.

The strength of our feelings about AI don't help us determine whether it's sentient.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by apublicfrog on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:45PM (#50511152)
If people with technical backgrounds believe this, I worry deeply for the layperson.

I've heard quite a lot of people over the last few years making jokes about Terminator coming true... Or at least I've thought they were jokes until I look closer. I think LLM sentience is a real concern normal people have, with them fundamentally misunderstanding the software they're interacting with. I worry how much influence and power some of these people have.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by zzzeek on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:11PM (#50511391)
Here's a table of the "LLMs are sentient" idea that I wrote up a while back (specifically "conscious", but if you want to argue semantics of "sentient" vs. "conscious", that can be a you thing...):

    +-----------------------+-------------------------+---------------+----------------+-----------------+-----------+
    | Subject               | Central Nervous System? | Brainwaves?   | Writes Poetry? | Does Math?      | Sentient? |
    +-----------------------+-------------------------+---------------+----------------+-----------------+-----------+
    | Human                 | Yes                     | Yes           | Yes            | Yes             | Yes       |
    | AI                    | No                      | No            | Yes            | Yes             | ?         |
    | Calculator            | No                      | No            | No             | Yes             | No        |
    | Babbage Machine       | No                      | No            | No             | Yes             | No        |
    | Horse                 | Yes                     | Yes           | No             | Clever Hans only| Yes       |
    | Dog                   | Yes                     | Yes           | No             | No              | Yes       |
    | Cat                   | Yes                     | Yes           | No             | No              | Yes       |
    | Tree                  | No                      | No            | No             | No              | No        |
    +-----------------------+-------------------------+---------------+----------------+-----------------+-----------+
tl;dr: intellectual ability is not what correlates with "sentient" or "conscious" - brainwaves as a result of a central nervous system, of which an LLM has neither (it has no corporeal form at all, really), are really the most predictive thing.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by za_creature on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:25PM (#50511984)
here's a simplified table:

hunts meat | y | n

sentient | yes | maybe

meat eating bugs need not apply

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by jonhohle on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:37PM (#50511064)
Direction is not adequate for asserting copyright. Movies directors (even if they didn’t work-for-hire) would not own any copyrights to a movie. This is long decided before AI.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by javier2 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:43PM (#50511126)
I am also on both sides.

If it was trained on open source GPL code, I don't think it can be used to generate proprietary code.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by tolvak on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:48PM (#50511182)
The counter to this is that I and many humans were trained on open source code and yet we generally think we should be allowed to create proprietary code. Though I have a friend that argues that human generated code shouldn’t be proprietary either, so I guess my counter point could go the other direction!
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by arcwhite on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:58PM (#50511271)
An LLM is not a human or anything like one, materially or in law.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by ginsider_oaks on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:58PM (#50511275)
The counter to that is that an LLM is not a human, and humans have special rights wrt. copyright law.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by ezst on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:05PM (#50511343)
The counter to this is "let's not pretend that humans learning and LLM training are activities whose scale and nature are relatable".
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by ginsider_oaks on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:57PM (#50511262)
> My stance is that AI is a tool, like a compiler is a tool.

And if I feed GPL licensed source code through a compiler then the resulting binary is also GPL licensed. Why should the same not apply when feeding it through an LLM for training?

> Furthermore, what does society gain from my code being made open source if anybody else could just themselves go to Claude Code and ask for the same thing? Just go have Claude make one for you.

Not everyone can afford a $200 subscription, or if you are unfortunate enough not to live in one of Anthropics supported regions[1] you can't "Just go have Claude make one for you". Also, I think something is gained by being able to read and learn from code, while not being dependent on a handful of megacorporations.

[1]: https://www.anthropic.com/legal/supported-regions

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by noctuid on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:28PM (#50511526)
> Why should the same not apply when feeding it through an LLM for training?

Because it's a terrible analogy?

> Not everyone can afford a $200 subscription, or if you are unfortunate enough not to live in one of Anthropics supported regions[1] you can't "Just go have Claude make one for you". Also, I think something is gained by being able to read and learn from code, while not being dependent on a handful of megacorporations.

Are you aware there are other providers besides Anthropic?

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by krupan on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:06PM (#50511352)
"Furthermore, what does society gain from my code being made open source if anybody else could just themselves go to Claude Code and ask for the same thing?"

Claude Code is not free (in any sense of the word). Not anyone can just go ask for the same code.