- e.g. People use tax loopholes because certain areas are not enforced. The ever-true trend is to never use "immoral" loophoes but people still do.
The article claims the strict enforcement of making AI gen code as open-source, which is exterme AF.
nobody must force OpenSource
Right. Nobody must violate copyleft licences either!If LLMs weren't trained on AGPL/GPL/LGPL code, it'd be different. But they are.
Say you read those codes yourself and built same thing yourself but different code base. That's what AI is doing. Do you still enforce that open sourceness to those?
Let's say someone reads Harry Potter, and writes a book about Larry Claymaker, a 13-year-old who goes off to a magical school called Pigpimples. The school has a chamber guarded by a lizard who speak in lizardspeak. And it continues like that. That's plagiarism and a copyright violation.
That's what AI is doing with my creative content, and the creative content of others.
The current copyright regime, which you appear brainwashed by, is a relatively recent invention designed to, in the language of the US Constitution: "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries."
It's not doing that anymore. Ergo, we need a new copyright regime.
No, GPL and copyleft licenses very much do and should force OpenSource by its nature. If someone uses GPL or AGPL and doesn't open source, they should be forced to Open Source.
The opposite side had exrtreme views for at least 4 decades. They publish stuff, cram it into your face with advertisement and demand purchasing a license for consuming it. And if you don't buy they want you to pay thousands of dollars or go to jail. That's as extreme as it goes. Eff them. Reverse engineer, clone and open source everything. There shouldn't be a single proprietary piece of published software left in use.
First of all, nobody must force OpenSource. Period. Second, such exterme views spawn extreme views in the opposite side.
Discussion is good, but this article is too draconian to be practical.