If you really are thinking from a game theory perspective, in order for it to be the prisoner dilemma, they each need to benefit from lowering prices individually (to cheat). But given that supply outstrips demand so much, they each just lose if they lower price, regardless of what the other players do.
Failure to enforce this kind of thing gives us shortages of eggs and insulin too; It is a real source of social harm.
These things are complicated, and people act like the mere existence of increased prices is evidence of malpractice. This is a naiive and juvenile attitude.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DRAM_industry_price_fixing has been linked elsewhere, but I'll link it again.
It isn't 'seeing the future', it is exercising your power in the present to control what futures are possible.
Like, for instance, forcing your customers to buy more chips than they can install, lest they be cut off entirely. Or increasing hypothetical demand artificially by breaking international smuggling laws using your girlfriend's shell company.
It is not 'naiive' (or naïve, even) to remember previous instances of crimes committed by exactly these companies using exactly the same tactics.
Unregulated markets create these predatory incentives, it shouldn't shock your or anyone that this has come to pass again.
[1] Railroads and Regulation by Gabriel Kolko [2] The Triumph of Conservatism by Gabriel Kolko
If the AI bubble hadn't come around buying up all the RAM, most new ram purchased today would be DDR5. The shift towards selling more HBM is also probably a bit unexpected.
Note, it's not just one thing, it's a combination of practices that make the collusion more likely explanation than otherwise
If they had started building new fabs earlier, they might have been able to sell even more inventory _and_ gotten back into the consumer market that they now neglect. Instead they've been way too slow to respond to demand or, in this case, purposefully didn't respond to demand.
OAI would be doing the same.
The sense of scarcity factors into the ability to negotiate these contracts. Cooking the reports has a direct impact on contracts and does increase real demand.