News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by PeterStuer on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:05AM (#50505269)
It's a 3 way prisoners dilemma market where the prisoners have been caught explicitly colluding before. Now they do not need explicit colluding anymore as the pattern and outcome has been established already and the "jail" is as good as closed to new entrants. Clearly the expected "market" is not working in this niche, so something will have to be done about it.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by gpt5 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:50AM (#50506939)
I honestly don’t understand how can anyone conclude that. All 3 players have their entire inventory sold + reliable reports that their entire next year’s inventory sold.

If you really are thinking from a game theory perspective, in order for it to be the prisoner dilemma, they each need to benefit from lowering prices individually (to cheat). But given that supply outstrips demand so much, they each just lose if they lower price, regardless of what the other players do.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by vhold on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:08AM (#50507042)
They created the supply shortage by cutting their production, all 3 of them, at the same time. That's what is damning.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by bethekidyouwant on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:30AM (#50507191)
« You have to make things - if not believe it or not, straight to jail.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by lkey on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:42AM (#50507773)
If you are granted a monopoly over production of a strategically important asset, then yes, you do have to make that thing.

Failure to enforce this kind of thing gives us shortages of eggs and insulin too; It is a real source of social harm.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by sophrosyne42 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:44AM (#50508343)
They are making the thing. What they cannot do is see the future in all its particulars for anticipating how much of that thing to make. We alao don't want situations were we use up too many resources and end up with more ram than other chips (which would cause a different shortage).

These things are complicated, and people act like the mere existence of increased prices is evidence of malpractice. This is a naiive and juvenile attitude.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by lkey on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:59PM (#50509615)
When you have a mono/duo/oligo/poly, you can, in fact, conspire to set prices short term.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DRAM_industry_price_fixing has been linked elsewhere, but I'll link it again.

It isn't 'seeing the future', it is exercising your power in the present to control what futures are possible.

Like, for instance, forcing your customers to buy more chips than they can install, lest they be cut off entirely. Or increasing hypothetical demand artificially by breaking international smuggling laws using your girlfriend's shell company.

It is not 'naiive' (or naïve, even) to remember previous instances of crimes committed by exactly these companies using exactly the same tactics.

Unregulated markets create these predatory incentives, it shouldn't shock your or anyone that this has come to pass again.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by sophrosyne42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:42AM (#50515416)
Unregulated markets prevent such incentives. You yourself note that profits are short term; in the long term engaging in such behavior always leads to far greater losses. While the popular story naiively imagines otherwise, history has shown time and time again[1, 2] that attempts at forming monopolies in the free market come to utter and abject failure. In fact, regulations are the primary source of monopoly, because regulations create trade barriers which, if you put two and two together, are not different from a restriction of supply, a necessary prerequisite of monopoly.

[1] Railroads and Regulation by Gabriel Kolko [2] The Triumph of Conservatism by Gabriel Kolko

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by jayd16 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:40PM (#50508899)
You have to not conspire to create an artificial shortage as a smoke screen for price gouging.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by sophrosyne42 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:40AM (#50508305)
There is a very obvious reason for the supply shortage, and it's on the demand side
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by jayd16 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:45PM (#50508944)
Which they have an influence over by signalling shortages, forcing high priced commitment contracts.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by sophrosyne42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:43AM (#50515421)
A contract is a two way street, and they had no control over the motivations and willingness of AI companies in forming those contracts.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by toast0 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:45PM (#50510545)
They cut supply of DDR4 around the same-ish time because DDR4 prices were dropping significantly (due to oversupply) and Intel and AMD processors were going to DDR5.

If the AI bubble hadn't come around buying up all the RAM, most new ram purchased today would be DDR5. The shift towards selling more HBM is also probably a bit unexpected.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by braiamp on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:22AM (#50507141)
> Judge Wise found that near-identical customer-vetting practices all three companies allegedly adopted in January 2026 "strongly support a plausible inference of conspiracy." She rejected the companies' "obvious and non-conspiratorial explanation" of booming AI demand, noting that the vetting began after the AI boom and the HBM pivot were underway.

Note, it's not just one thing, it's a combination of practices that make the collusion more likely explanation than otherwise

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by doom2 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:31AM (#50507201)
> All 3 players have their entire inventory sold + reliable reports that their entire next year’s inventory sold.

If they had started building new fabs earlier, they might have been able to sell even more inventory _and_ gotten back into the consumer market that they now neglect. Instead they've been way too slow to respond to demand or, in this case, purposefully didn't respond to demand.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by gpt5 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:33AM (#50507216)
But memory was dead cheap just a year ago. About 10 times cheaper. I don’t know if it’s reasonable to assume collusion here. It’s far more reasonable to assume they (and everybody else) didn’t anticipate the shortage.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by reenorap on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:49AM (#50507318)
No one anticipated that OpenAI would put in an order for 40% of the global supply of memory in 2025. And then it became a mad dash for everyone and that’s why we are where we are today.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by lokar on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:14AM (#50507483)
I really doubt that it was a surprise. The big cloud providers talk to suppliers (and potential suppliers) frequently to telegraph future demand, both the amount of parts and specs.

OAI would be doing the same.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by reenorap on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:55AM (#50507879)
No it was a huge surprise. I bought a 512 GB Mac Studio for $9k in April 2025 which was market. Even as recently as Jan 2026 I bought a 5070Ti for $750, the retail price. Now it’s $1500. No one anticipated the effects.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by lokar on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:10PM (#50508580)
I meant it was not a surprise to the ram manufacturers when demand shot up. Customers did not show up with massive orders out of nowhere.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by kasabali on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:16AM (#50508079)
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by sophrosyne42 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:39AM (#50508292)
Failing to forecast demand is not price fixing.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by jayd16 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:38PM (#50508877)
The analogy/classification works if you assume they engineered the scarcity through collusion. Then its "lower prices to win the market" vs "work together to artificially lower supply as a smoke screen to squeeze on prices."

The sense of scarcity factors into the ability to negotiate these contracts. Cooking the reports has a direct impact on contracts and does increase real demand.

Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by jeremyjh on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:54PM (#50509027)
The reason there are only three is that other players in their industry have been wiped out by investing in new production capacity to meet demand that doesn’t exist by the time they come online. It is very much an open question whether HBM demand growth really continues as forecast - it could collapse dramatically for various different reasons.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by londons_explore on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:13PM (#50509734)
Isn't this what contracts for future delivery are for? Pass the risk on to the customer/financial markets.
Re:Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case by jeremyjh on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:31PM (#50509888)
You'd need years of contracts - at prices no can predict are going to be good - to pay off the investment. Do you think the companies who failed or left the industry did so because they didn't know what contracts or futures were?