News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rancar2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:43AM (#50498403)
Wow, if I'm reading this correctly, the Big Beautiful Bill introduced a pretty large gap that punishes married couples filing jointly: a couple making about $300K each can lose up to $15K in write-offs compared with filing separately, pretty much everywhere except the nine states with no broad income tax (Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming), where few couples pay the $25K in state and local taxes needed to trigger it. I think most tax software will assume the $5K cap each, but the regulation here is inconsistent. Here’s the take-away quote from the article:

“A married couple can deduct more state and local tax by filing separately. The deduction for state and local taxes (SALT) is capped, and the cap shrinks as income rises: by 30 cents for each dollar over $500,000 on a joint return. On a separate return, the law halves the cap after shrinking it, so it shrinks by only 15 cents a dollar. A couple earning $300,000 each can deduct up to $25,000 on two separate returns, but only $10,000 on one joint return.”

This is non-trivial impact to joint returns if this is true, and I won’t be surprised if there are multiple appeals for refunds and more people filling separately going towards.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jghn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:10PM (#50498656)
> punishes married couples filing jointly: a couple making about $300K each

The number of married couples where each partner is making $300K each is a very, very small percentage of the population. Not sure this is a big deal to be concerned about in the grand scheme of things.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jedberg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:29PM (#50498871)
It might be a few people nationwide, but it's a whole lot of families in the Bay Area, New York, Los Angeles, and a few other major cities.

The law was specifically designed to punish these people. Remember, at first they wanted to drop the SALT deduction completely to punish blue states.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by Auracle on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:52PM (#50499124)
Don’t tax the rich (and yes, 600k for a couple per year is absolutely rich territory)? “They need to pay their fair share!” Tax the rich? “They’re targeting people in blue cities!”

The SALT deduction is nonsense. Why should high tax states effectively be able to take money from the federal government?

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jedberg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:16PM (#50499333)
It's funny that me pointing out the fact removing the SALT deduction was meant to punish rich people makes people think I don't like it.

In fact, I was glad they got it done. The Dems didn't object very hard because they knew it had to go too. It's interesting that they didn't put it back when they had the chance.

I don't think the federal government should lose money when people choose to live in high tax states. And I pay high taxes in a high tax state.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rancar2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:21PM (#50500423)
It’s even more nuanced than that. The no income tax states like Florida get supplemented more from the federal government. So fed taxes with SALT limits are relatively shifting even more burden to the residence of states who tax their residence and pay for their own local services, which then having to do pay more of the burden for no income tax states.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by fluidcruft on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:06AM (#50507435)
It goes full cycle once you realize most of that "supplement" blue states complain about paying for covers services to the poor and seniors who are deliberately priced out of blue states (the same people who the blue party talking heads supposedly champion politically).
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rancar2 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:55AM (#50508443)
I am not aware of any data that supports your opinion. I will focus on Federal and state budgets for Massachusetts and Florida, IRS records, and Census data to make the point here. Poor people are not moving to Florida as IRS migration records show households relocating to Florida from New York, New Jersey, California, and Illinois bring an average income between $185,000 and $231,000. That includes nearly 30,000 net households earning over $200,000 that average $907,000 annually. Meanwhile, Census data shows poor residents in Massachusetts leave at the lowest rates because they rely on state safety nets that Florida refuses to fund. Ironically, federal taxpayers pay 58.2% of Florida's $35.5 billion Medicaid budget, putting up $885 per resident against just $635 in state funds, while Massachusetts puts up $1,540 in state money per resident. Because Florida rejected Medicaid expansion, between 2.5 million and 3.9 million Floridians (11% to 17% of the state) have zero health insurance, compared to 140,000 people (2%) in Massachusetts. That leaves Floridians with the second highest medical debt burden in the country, whereas Massachusetts protects its residents from medical debt. Furthermore, Rockefeller Institute data shows Florida's $325 billion in federal inflows ($13,900 per person) overwhelmingly pay for Social Security and Medicare, which are earned payroll tax benefits rather than welfare supplements for displaced poor residents.

Florida runs the exact same playbook in public education by shifting fiscal burdens onto federal taxpayers while funneling state money into private schools. Massachusetts invests $2,735 per resident in state and local school funds ($22,947 per student), keeping federal aid down to 7% of its school budget. Florida puts up just $1,330 per resident ($12,689 per student) and leans on federal grants for up to 15% of its public school funding. At the same time, Florida diverts $5 billion in state money into private vouchers for over 530,000 students (within a broader pool of 680,000 nonpublic students outside federal oversight), heavily subsidizing private tuition for wealthy families while systematically underfunding public schooling for those families that financial cannot afford private schooling.

I very much welcome corrections and nuances here, but generally, I’m just not currently aware of data supporting your opinion here but my awareness of Florida vs Massachusetts are much higher since I have family in both who very much are represented in this data I presented above and all of its negative/positive impacts of the respective state policies.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by fluidcruft on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:56PM (#50509575)
The overwhelming red state/blue state discrepancy in terms of federal money outflow is funding of entitlement programs. Entitlement programs do include poverty programs, but they also notably include retirees and senior citizens.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by devman0 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:10PM (#50500852)
States should be encouraged to provide services to their citizens and reduce burden on federal programs, allowing SALT write offs is part of that. This should be a "win" for all the smaller fed government folks many states are not taxing at appropriate levels and then take a bunch of federal money.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by contubernio on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:23PM (#50499398)
Those people should be taxed a lot.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jedberg on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:28PM (#50499450)
I agree. I never said they shouldn't.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by bahmboo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:52PM (#50499678)
No, you should be taxed a lot.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by airstrike on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:21PM (#50499923)
[delayed]
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by selectodude on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:36PM (#50500039)
This is about a family earning $600,000/yr.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by InsidiousWombat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:36PM (#50500040)
Maybe read correctly before you start complaining. It was 300k EACH, so 600k
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jghn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:25PM (#50500471)
I live in a borderline HCOL/VHCOL city, and arguments like this get thrown around a lot on local boards. But yet the median household income is right around 100k.

People on sites like this tend to have a skewed view of normal.

Also we're discussing a household income of 600k+, not 300k.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by qurren on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:39PM (#50501177)
Median income != Livable income

Livable income = income that pays for (housing, food, clothing, transportation, medical preventative care and treatment, an emergency fund) x 4

( x 2 for retirement savings, x 2 for government stealing half your money [1])

[1] pre-emptive note to shut up the people who will inevitably come to this forum just to lecture me that taxes aren't that high. they are. a LOT of taxes are hidden into things that aren't paid in April.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jghn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:50PM (#50501293)
If you're going to claim that literally half the households living in a city aren't making a livable wage, then I'm going to claim you're exactly the type of person I'm describing who has a cushier view of livable wage than reality.

I agree that your definition is a comfortable living, but that's not reality for the majority of americans.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by qurren on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:49PM (#50503807)
> but that's not reality for the majority

Yeah, I know, and that's a problem. If they don't solve it, the country will go downhill.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by UncleMeat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:27PM (#50501637)
I assure you that a married couple making 600k a year has plenty of money.

Also, the government stealing half of your money is a ridiculous over-exaggeration. This year my MFJ household income will be around $950,000. My effective tax rate is nowhere near 50%.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by airstrike on Saturday November 14, 2026 @06:50PM (#50502329)
[delayed]
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by qurren on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:25PM (#50503695)
You are exactly the type of person I thought would come to try to "educate" me on effective tax rates.

You pay a lot more to the government than your "effective tax rate".

Sales taxes, car registrations, property taxes (which may be a chunk of your rent), tariffs baked into prices everywhere you look, utility pricing, and a lot more. The government deliberately spreads it all over the place to dupe people like you into thinking you are paying "nowhere near 50%" but you're actually paying a lot more.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by UncleMeat on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:55AM (#50507368)
Include all that if you want and I'm still nowhere near 50%.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rexpop on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:34PM (#50498935)
But isn't that an undue burden on "job creators" with proportionately far-reaching downstream economic consequences?
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by nyargh on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:47PM (#50499072)
/s
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jcranmer on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:11PM (#50499286)
$600K household income is 98th percentile, and I'm willing to bet that most of those aren't "each partner making $300K". ($300K household income is 93rd percentile). Even in a high-income area like the bay area, $600K is pretty damn rich.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by airstrike on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:21PM (#50499925)
[delayed]
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by InsidiousWombat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:36PM (#50500043)
It's 600k. 300k each
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by jghn on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:27PM (#50500485)
So in other words, we're talking about someone making 230k in Alabama?
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by nullc on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:17PM (#50502983)
a household making 230k in Alabama.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rancar2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:13PM (#50500362)
I just think the team did a good job from what I’m reading. This inconsistency doesn’t impact the top 1% household (who commonly use larger loopholes to avoid taxation at magnitudes more significant than this inconsistency like using loan against assets which they can write off interest against taxes instead of paying taxes to the government). This quirk impacts households in the 2% level for just one fiscal year or more where they might just have a taxed event like a real estate sale (non reinvested primary within the timeline), a taxable equity grant (that the pay taxes on but may lose), one time capital gains from investment sales, etc.

Tax law is supposed to be consistent and fair in general, and the introduction of the Big Beautiful Bill created a weird quirk here, that gets quirkier that you can file separately and correct to jointly but not the other way around legally right now. From 2018–2024, the tax code was consistent on SALT, then in 2025 and looking forward to 2029 SALT taxation becomes inconsistent under certain joint filing conditions that impact a non-trivial number of households especially when it starts at $250k each, or a lopsided earnings of that combined amount and peaks at the $600k.

This team is identifying a pretty big quirk that goes against the principle of consistency in tax law and did a very good job of it applying formal logic to law if they prove this to be correct. Others have done too before AI (which is what your tax software is conservatively doing), but it’s just easier now with AI.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by EPWN3D on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:53PM (#50500698)
> I just think the team did a good job from what I’m reading. This inconsistency doesn’t impact the top 1% household (who commonly use larger loopholes to avoid taxation at magnitudes more significant than this inconsistency like using loan against assets which they can write off interest against taxes instead of paying taxes to the government). This quirk impacts households in the 2% level for just one fiscal year or more where they might just have a taxed event like a real estate sale (non reinvested primary within the timeline), a taxable equity grant (that the pay taxes on but may lose), one time capital gains from investment sales, etc.

The top 1% have a significant portion of high-income W2 earners who basically have been forced into the standard deduction since the TCJA. It definitely impacts them because that's exactly what the SALT cap was designed to do.

The business owners (lawyers, dentists, investment bankers) are the ones that have all the fun tax breaks, and they're probably more like top-0.1%.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rancar2 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:01PM (#50502399)
This specific quirk starts at $500k peaking at $600k and phasing out towards $650k collective yearly income.

Agreed that it’s W2 earners paying taxes at high rates than business/capital owns, which is why it’s a mostly income tax system of collection. This is where many of us see this as an unfair tax burden being put first on people not businesses nor its owners and leveraged mostly towards income of w2 workers. People don’t pay taxes on our their income after expenses and extensive rebates like businesses/capital ownership.

Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:37PM (#50498962)
The tax code has significantly punished dual-income married couples for quite a while. It presumably started some time in the 20th century as some sexists not wanting women in the workplace and then continued because changing it to have them pay the same taxes as they would if they were unmarried would result in a significant reduction in government revenue.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by quaffcode on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:12AM (#50504192)
Seems to me that tax breaks for marriage are to encourage family creation. If child tax credits achieve that, why should society reward dinks?
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by derwiki on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:07PM (#50499246)
Thank you for posting this!
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by UncleMeat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:25PM (#50501623)
This isn't really a punishment. You can choose to file separately. You just pick the option that leads to the least tax.
Re:Formalizing US Tax Code (Using Lean) by rancar2 on Monday November 16, 2026 @10:32AM (#50518678)
The tax code was and supposed to be remain consistent here and failed to do so. It’s typically viewed as “punishment” for filing jointly as joint filing is currently a one-way street of no legal return without a likely appeal/denial/court battle (which would likely be more costly than the $5k max at stake with this quirk), while filing separately can be amended after the tax year if it proves to be beneficial for the tax payer.