News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by mrkeen on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:14AM (#50497675)
For the opposite take, here's a former emacs contributor recoiling in horror at discovering that FSF isn't there to fight climate change, whaling, civil war or whatever moral struggle you hold dear this week.

https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2026-11/msg00...

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by Chatter9220 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:17AM (#50497707)
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by 3dedb728-3f77 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:08PM (#50500318)
So they have no soul?
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by voidhorse on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:20AM (#50497724)
This extends beyond software to technology in general. The "tool use" theory, by which technologies are neutral instruments with no moral or political implications until put to use, is an incredibly naive, weak theory that was basically killed and buried by Langdon Winner back in the 70s. If you don't have time to read his books, at least read ["Do Artifacts have Politics?"](https://faculty.cc.gatech.edu/~beki/cs4001/Winner.pdf) which states the case very clearly.

Of course, most technologists have never read a letter of a single work in the philosophy of technology, so they don't know this, let alone who Winner is, let alone that people actually think about and theorize the impacts of technology on a broad scale seriously (even though Winner worked at MIT, the ever vaunted institution of the technical priesthood). Of course, the people building things are the very people who should be thinking about the potential effects of the things they are building deeply and seriously, but apparently that's too much to ask.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by timmmmmmay on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:40AM (#50497881)
some of us have indeed read various bits of critical theory from these non-contributors and then rejected them. shockingly not everyone who reads this stuff becomes an immediate convert!
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by voidhorse on Monday November 16, 2026 @08:13PM (#50526101)
Langdon Winner is not a critical theorist. His work addresses Marcuse's but his argument is decidedly distinct from Marcuse's arguments, and in fact he levies some criticisms of Marcuse's work. Maybe you should reread his work and reassess your rejection.

Also, no one is asking you to "convert" to anything. It's not an ideology. It's a couple of (I think well-made) arguments that suggest being more careful about the ways in which we deploy technologies, something I'd argue, people interested in technology (more than capital) should be interested in.

Comments like yours, however, basically give me a vote of no confidence in the technical community.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by hatradiowigwam on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:34AM (#50497831)
This sounds like a /lot/ of opinions on a /lot/ of open source work - that the author has contributed nothing to. Snipe at RMS, trivialize GNU, and add all types of emotional nonsense that didn't exist at the time all this free software was being written. The author would should that - except they were likely not born yet, and are speaking on concepts they are utterly ignorant of.
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by hn_acker on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:52PM (#50568286)
> open source work - that the author has contributed nothing to

Is there not relevance to the free software that the author of TFA did build or contribute to? FSF calls free software a movement. People working on different things within a movement should have opinions about how the most prominent projects reflect on the movement. Maybe "reflect on" is an understatement: you seem to perceive projects like GNU and Emacs as continuing to define the movement in the present day, in which case everyone in the movement should be free to have an opinion on GNU and Emacs.

> Snipe at RMS

No snipe happened in my reading. Would you mind explaining where and how the snipe is?

> trivialize GNU

That did not happen.

> add all types of emotional nonsense that didn't exist at the time

Would you like to explain what is nonsense about it? Not to mention, the emotions behind TFA do not exclusively occur in the most recent generations of human beings.

> that didn't exist at the time all this free software was being written. The author would should that - except they were likely not born yet

I don't see how this is relevant. Forced labor and unfair pay in e.g. chocolate production started before James Cornfarmer was born, therefore James has no business publishing a normative opinion about forced labor in chocolate unless James switches his occupation to chocolate farming?

> This sounds like a /lot/ of opinions

I like hearing free software developers' opinions of free software.

> and are speaking on concepts they are utterly ignorant of.

How is the author ignorant of free software concepts when TFA demonstrates otherwise? Do only Emacs contributors understand free software concepts?

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by deepnet on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:37AM (#50497861)
At the brink of the epistemological and societal shift of modern AI.

How do the four freedoms and their raison d’être apply in the AI age ?

Doesn't it hold that If you don’t own the weights the AI ( or its sponsoring entity ) owns you.

Are weights like software or akin to content ?

For the AI to be free software a user should be able to :

Run the AI model on their own hardware

See the AI’s weights, architecture

Modify the AI by fine tuning, quantization, and any other method.

Share the modifications with the community

As some legal precedents are that an AI cannot create work that is copyrightable.

Thus if an AI creates an AI is it therefore public domain ?

As it would seem many AI are trained on copyrighted work by humans some of which is CC0, free software and public doman does it therefore follow the AI weights are uncopyrightable ?

As there are open-weight models that are not open-source nor free should the OSI and FSF provide and promote the advantages of new types of license for AI’s as well as explicit public domain licenses for AI output to remive all doubt.

Can copyleft licenses apply if copyright doesn’t ?

Is the source code of an AI its training program and its training and validation sets ?

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by bigbadfeline on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:31PM (#50498897)
> The future is exciting, dangerous, awful and fun. Freedom is worth fighting to ensure.

Chaos is most definitely not freedom, it's a cover for slavery. "Fighting" for the sake fighting for a future that's "exciting, dangerous, awful and fun" will never achieve anything approaching freedom, it's chaos for the sake chaos.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by delichon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:43AM (#50497920)
This is the logic of "if you're not with us you're against us." It denies the possibility of neutrality even by inaction. The concept of neutrality becomes the myth, and there's no point in debating whether it applies to any domain, because that becomes false as a tautology.
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by jjj123 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:51AM (#50498481)
I think you’re conflating a rejection of neutrality with black and white thinking.

A civilian who does not actively protest their government is not neutral, but they are not as complicit as the active participants.

Refusing to take a stance benefits the status quo. The status quo is not “neutral”.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by delichon on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:25PM (#50498823)
If the status quo is not neutral, does neutrality exist? Can you describe any nontrivial neutral position?

If neutrality exists in some arrangement other than the status quo, isn't that vision of what could be necessarily a political one, and therefore not neutral?

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by danaris on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:45AM (#50505859)
> If the status quo is not neutral, does neutrality exist?

No. It does not. It is, and has always been, an illusion of the privileged.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by unrented7977 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:06PM (#50499241)
Rejection of neutrality literally is black and white thinking.
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by danaris on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:45AM (#50505852)
Inaction inherently supports the status quo. That's not "neutral", it's not apolitical, and it's not a way to avoid ever having to take a side.

It's also not "if you're not with us you're against us." It stems from a genuine analysis of how systems work, especially systems of oppression.

No one is exempt from politics. No one can avoid being part of the system, one way or another. It's just that some people are privileged enough that the status quo supports us in ways they never ever notice, the way we never stop and think about the air we breathe. Others aren't so lucky: their continued existence is labeled by many as "political", especially if they want to be seen in public or involved in government.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by skaushik92 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @07:46PM (#50512639)
Not trying to be rude but is this supposed to be sarcasm?

If I’m understanding you correctly, what your saying is: every decision has some transitive implications that are statistically non-neutral so all actions are non-neutral. In a mathematical sense this is true in the same way that a uniforming sampling of a real number from -1 to 1 will never be zero. In the general sense that people use the word neutral though that’s not true. Because people use the word in a broader sense. And in this analogy it’s like saying neutral is 0 ± 0.1.

Additionally intent, responsibility, and free will play a part in this. A doctor healing a soldier is a noncombatant because they’re not responsible for the behavior of another human (who’s own decision making could change and could turn to corrective actions for example through surrender or informing).

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by zzzeek on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:49AM (#50497959)
Sorry, it's just hard for me to get through a post like "Now, Richard Stallman is widely known as a creeper who advocated for sexual assault, but hear me out about his highly moral and ethical movement...."

is there some kind of outcry on codeberg? I assumed the whole point of codeberg was a more heavily code-of-conducted environment compared to github and banning LLM repos would be kind of step one for that today. you dont need to go into an FSF moralizing loop to make that argument.

Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by neuroticnews25 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:00AM (#50498058)
Ok then, my radical political ideology is "what would Linus Torvalds do".
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by ghusto on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:52PM (#50499119)
Through most of my professional carrier, "leave your politics at the door" was never stated _because it didn't need to be_. It was obvious that it has no place in what we do.

If we're talking about the left-wing politics of "Freedom" however, yes of course; that was the entire point. We were rebelling against the system for the good of humanity, or something. Changing "master" to "main" is not even close to being the same thing.