News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by hatradiowigwam on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:34AM (#50497831)
This sounds like a /lot/ of opinions on a /lot/ of open source work - that the author has contributed nothing to. Snipe at RMS, trivialize GNU, and add all types of emotional nonsense that didn't exist at the time all this free software was being written. The author would should that - except they were likely not born yet, and are speaking on concepts they are utterly ignorant of.
Re:The Myth of Neutral Code by hn_acker on Thursday November 19, 2026 @06:52PM (#50568286)
> open source work - that the author has contributed nothing to

Is there not relevance to the free software that the author of TFA did build or contribute to? FSF calls free software a movement. People working on different things within a movement should have opinions about how the most prominent projects reflect on the movement. Maybe "reflect on" is an understatement: you seem to perceive projects like GNU and Emacs as continuing to define the movement in the present day, in which case everyone in the movement should be free to have an opinion on GNU and Emacs.

> Snipe at RMS

No snipe happened in my reading. Would you mind explaining where and how the snipe is?

> trivialize GNU

That did not happen.

> add all types of emotional nonsense that didn't exist at the time

Would you like to explain what is nonsense about it? Not to mention, the emotions behind TFA do not exclusively occur in the most recent generations of human beings.

> that didn't exist at the time all this free software was being written. The author would should that - except they were likely not born yet

I don't see how this is relevant. Forced labor and unfair pay in e.g. chocolate production started before James Cornfarmer was born, therefore James has no business publishing a normative opinion about forced labor in chocolate unless James switches his occupation to chocolate farming?

> This sounds like a /lot/ of opinions

I like hearing free software developers' opinions of free software.

> and are speaking on concepts they are utterly ignorant of.

How is the author ignorant of free software concepts when TFA demonstrates otherwise? Do only Emacs contributors understand free software concepts?