Re:The Myth of Neutral Code
by timmmmmmay on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:40AM
(#50497881)
some of us have indeed read various bits of critical theory from these non-contributors and then rejected them. shockingly not everyone who reads this stuff becomes an immediate convert!
Langdon Winner is not a critical theorist. His work addresses Marcuse's but his argument is decidedly distinct from Marcuse's arguments, and in fact he levies some criticisms of Marcuse's work. Maybe you should reread his work and reassess your rejection.
Also, no one is asking you to "convert" to anything. It's not an ideology. It's a couple of (I think well-made) arguments that suggest being more careful about the ways in which we deploy technologies, something I'd argue, people interested in technology (more than capital) should be interested in.
Comments like yours, however, basically give me a vote of no confidence in the technical community.
Of course, most technologists have never read a letter of a single work in the philosophy of technology, so they don't know this, let alone who Winner is, let alone that people actually think about and theorize the impacts of technology on a broad scale seriously (even though Winner worked at MIT, the ever vaunted institution of the technical priesthood). Of course, the people building things are the very people who should be thinking about the potential effects of the things they are building deeply and seriously, but apparently that's too much to ask.