Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by MBCook on Friday November 13, 2026 @07:46PM
(#50492277)
How is there not a second backup network???
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by jiggawatts on Friday November 13, 2026 @07:56PM
(#50492349)
Why only “one” network at all!?
The Internet was purpose designed to tolerate disruption as major as a nuclear war, which it achieves through decentralisation.
Private networks exist to make idiot managers feel more confident while actually dramatically reducing availability by putting all their eggs into a single basket.
Many aviation systems predate the internet. Depending on the region, some systems do not use Internet Protocol, let alone TCP.
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by jiggawatts on Friday November 13, 2026 @08:47PM
(#50492721)
The FAA Telecommunications Infrastructure (FTI) operated by L3harris was built between 2002 to 2007.
That is already well within the era of IPv6, let alone "the Internet".
There's no excuse.
For something so incredibly critical in real time, I’m not sure I would want to trust the Internet.
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by technol0gic on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:24PM
(#50493484)
thats like mandating using I-95 for all ambulance & firefighter traffic
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by Fripplebubby on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:33PM
(#50493969)
Isn't using a private network like mandating using I-95 (since it might be blocked from a freak accident one day), while using the internet, with redundant paths between hosts, like allowing the traffic to find the best path?
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by jiggawatts on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:25PM
(#50493916)
When was the last time the Internet "went down" globally?
The last time the internet caused flight outages was September 22nd of this year.
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by jiggawatts on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:04AM
(#50494736)
Over what area? Localised, nation-wide, or global?
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by ExoticPearTree on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:06PM
(#50493346)
One network can be a fully redundant design with multiple geographically distinct links and so on.
But it does not make it 100% resilient to cascading failures or possible Layer2/3 loops that might happen during a software upgrade, especially in a country wide deployment.
The FAA will give a root cause at some point of why this happenned.
The internet is pretty unreliable as it goes, and the internet in your locality is probably only one network (e.g. Comcast's) - what are you gaining by running critical systems over Comcast internet access, instead of Comcast leased line? Saving a few hundred bucks a month, yes, but that's because you're getting less reliability than you actually need.
Also lower MTTR and more robust SLAs in many cases. Business services will usually result in service credits being issued if the SLO is breached. Residential... not so much.
The more time I spend working in tech, the more I realize that everything important is held together with cardboard and duct tape.
You had duct tape? Lucky!
True for every industry / field I've worked in, unfortunately (which is more than I'd like to admit).
That's because everything really important is not just tech but a socio-technical system of tech+humans operating/building/maintaining that thing. A lot of the things can't/shouldn't be automated with tech (see the Irony of Automations paper) – they are up and running thanks to the resilience (socio-technical quality) which appears as a "cardboard and duct tape" for untrained eye.
Any time people freak out about these kinds of things and assume the absolute worse, I just tell them I’m surprised these things don’t happen more often
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by sillysaurusx on Friday November 13, 2026 @08:26PM
(#50492568)
Cue that line from DS9 where O’Brien says he’d never be caught without a secondary backup during a fight, and the cardassian is like “you have a second backup?” incredulously. https://youtu.be/o7o9ZtipVyo?is=y3for_WXwISmuqpd
I wouldn’t say anything but this is approximately the only time in my entire life this scene will be relevant.
Re:FAA Issues National Ground Stop
by stevenhubertron on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:19PM
(#50492980)
I remember that scene, but I can’t believe that you had it at the front of your memory like that. That’s awesome.