Absolutely not. Constraining the set of possible actions instead of having you verbalise what you want every time is often a feature, not just a technical limitation. A camera with a shutter button is better design than having to tell the camera “please take a photo”.
At the supermarket, I personally also prefer the self-checkout machines over going to a human cashier.
The UI is totally fluid at all times, because an "intelligence" is actively manifesting it at all times. Nothing needs to be hard coded.
Hell the computer might even see your face, see your age and style, and be like "Yup, this guy definitely wants to checkout with a dumb, midi keytone 8-bit styled program"
But already AI design is everywhere and regular people don't even notice. It's only going to get better as people can interact with the design the same as the interact with another person.
The only reason it works out in my favor is that I enjoyed doing it. Normal people don't want to fuck around with that kind of shit.
You're also assuming that there are no negatives to saying what you want compared to just acting on things, but since the beginning of computing many people have proven this wrong time and again. I suggest you read about HCI as a research field and its history, it doesn't take much to realise how limited the average HNer's understanding of UI/UX design is, and how far current LLMs are from the skills required to be able to carefully design an app for productive human use.
Good design rarely calls for a “you can do everything” approach. Good design is often context specific and subtly guides users to better outcomes.
Doctor appointments would absolutely suck if I had to navigate decision trees and click buttons to communicate my symptoms. Car blinkers would absolutely suck if I had to type “blink left” into a chat window before every turn.
Maybe it’s just the ‘tism, but I hard disagree that I would ever say another person is a superior interface into… anything? It’s slow, they may misinterpret you, they have their own ideas and motivations, they’re (mostly) expensive because the only reason I need them is because there’s information / skill asymmetry. I don’t know that many or even most of those problems are resolved with ai, in some ways the problems are amplified.
I like to customize my Neovim setup or terminal and a bunch of scripts that I keep making them nice and maybe my blog and so on.
I don't want to become the PM of every app I need. But I do agree changes will happen to the current apps and how we buy and use them. Not sure exactly where it will settle. But still unknown unknowns and domain knowledge and vocabulary is not yet allowing anyone to build their own apps unless for simple cases.
Or maybe it is just me: I want someone else to think about my accounting app. I dont want to spend time to learn and understand and keep myself up to date or setup a series of LLM sessions that navigate and watch laws and propose changes.
Why do you need an accounting app when you have an accountant?
Programs of the future will in no way resemble what they are today. I don't even want to call it a "program" because in my head it's more like an intelligent digital liquid that can rapidly flow into any state. This flash-in-the-pan 50 year archaic era of software will look like what the oil lamp looks like today. A crude intermediate tech during a time of much larger transition.
it's nice to see my financial situation at a glance, without asking my accountant.
speech/text is one modality. we humans are also visual and tactile. and we need consistency and recurring patterns of interaction to function well.
Same thing for your accountant.
Imagine that both of them, while being good at their respective jobs, are also software engineers that can mint a custom throwaway app for you at a moment's notice.
I'm sure your secretary will make a note of your preference.
Sounds cumbersome, slow to use, and prone to failure.
I don't see any future where programs follow the static nature of old paradigm programming. A nice intuitive UI? What about just telling the app what I need when I need it? The gold standard of consumer UI is...another person.
If I have a team of god tier SWE's at my disposal, why the fuck am I fumbling around in an actions panel? The program can just be dynamically modified in real time to be whatever I need it to be in that moment.
If you extrapolate LLMs out to their extreme, you get a shape-shifting liquid array of bits in memory that manifest anything at the behest of a completely natural language interface.