News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by Sharlin on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @06:44AM (#50452262)
What apps exactly do you think people actually use that could be replaced with LLMs?

Essentially every single non-builtin app on my phone fundamentally requires the internet to work, and is backed by some sort of SaaS with a proprietary API. And even if/when the APIs are open, no normal person is going to decide they want to somehow use YouTube or Tiktok or Feeld or Spotify by talking to ChatGPT.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @06:49AM (#50452299)
Some apps will remain as standalone apps for longer. For example, games. Youtube is another one. Instagram as well.

Spotify is an interesting one. I could see myself wanting to control Spotify with my AI agent.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by Sharlin on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @06:54AM (#50452342)
I give you that Spotify integration isn’t the worst idea, but more as an additional interface than a full replacement. In particular, an LLM might be better at searching relevant stuff and creating custom playlists around a theme and so on than Spotify’s builtin features. And Spotify does have an open API, though it’s rather incomplete (for example, it supports playlist creationn but not playlist folders).
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by cmsj on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @07:17AM (#50452554)
Discovery I can see benefiting from AI, but surely using an agent to control basic playback would be a profligate waste of resources?!
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @07:25AM (#50452616)
I assume AI will generate a playback UI for you.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by rafram on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:35AM (#50453241)
But why? Spotify’s engineers and designers already made a good one!
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:48AM (#50453376)
Actually, I hate Spotify's playback UI. The time bar tap target is too small. They keep making it smaller every year.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by andsoitis on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @09:12AM (#50453661)
> I assume AI will generate a playback UI for you.

It only needs to be created once. You don't want a different UI every time you listen to something.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @10:10AM (#50454364)
Agreed. It could create it, you can pin it and use it again and again. Change it whenever you want to whatever you want.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by mrbungie on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @10:47AM (#50454792)
I would expect this to be an ultra niche usage pattern. Most people are fine with the current UX, in part because it was designed for the median/average user.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @11:15AM (#50455105)
I'm sure Spotify's MCP will have a default UI that your agent can build.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by mrbungie on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @12:00PM (#50455664)
I hope I can go straight to an UI without going through an agent.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Thursday November 12, 2026 @01:24AM (#50463724)
I'm sure they'll let you do that once you "pin" a generated UI.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by satvikpendem on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @07:43AM (#50452737)
Spotify already has an AI chat bot inside, where you can tell it what music you'd like to listen to in plain language.

And that's the issue, each app maker will simply integrate AI themselves with their proprietary API rather than allowing ChatGPT to take their lunch.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @07:50AM (#50452799)
We're still very early. But I don't want to use Spotify's AI. I want to use my own AI, who knows me more.

IE. I want to stay inside ChatGPT/Claude.

I think Spotify will open up. Or some AI-native music service will be started to compete and fill the demand.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by Sharlin on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:20AM (#50453091)
It just doesn’t seem to make any business sense to turn an app into an API invisible to the user. A visible, established brand is a "moat" as they say. Without user-facing brandable software you’re basically nothing.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:27AM (#50453144)
If there is a demand for it, people will invent businesses to fill that demand even if a pre-AI company like Spotify is resistant to the change.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by andsoitis on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @09:11AM (#50453648)
> If there is a demand for it, people will invent businesses to fill that demand even if a pre-AI company like Spotify is resistant to the change.

Only if structurally it makes sense. There's demand for many many things on this planet without a business model that would satisfy that demand.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:10AM (#50463300)
The world is moving towards this whether legacy businesses want to or not. I'm sure the internet was bad for Yellow Pages' phone book business and Yelp ate their lunch regardless.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by booty on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @10:06AM (#50454324)

    overestimating (based on one datapoint?) the number of 
    people who want to use their devices from within an LLM 
    chat app,
I don't know about that. "Apps" were a step forward in many ways, but when spending time with older and/or non-technical users they are pretty overwhelmed by the sheer number of apps.

I think they would really like to have one unified, plain-language interface.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @11:14AM (#50455096)
I agree with you. That might be why people only use a few apps even if they download 100. It's just really hard to learn the user interface of every single app.

Nice username btw.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by booty on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @02:08PM (#50457189)
Non-technical users also get REALLY confused/upset about routine app updates that change the UX in any way whatsoever.

They learn these apps differently than "we" do.

They (again, particularly older users who didn't grow up with GUIs) don't understand GUI paradigms, so they compensate by memorizing... even a small change to their memorized flow is highly disruptive because they cannot reason about how to get back onto the happy path.

(It's like the old, pre-GPS-navigation days when you went on a road trip with a stack of printed out directions from MapQuest. It was great, until you missed a turn and had no idea how to get back on track...)

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by satvikpendem on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:55AM (#50453468)
You may not want to, but the company wants you to use their AI. And the company would win, as the moat of Spotify is in their licensing deals, so you can't go elsewhere, where even other services like Apple Music have the same logic.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @09:05AM (#50453590)
I personally think the Spotify would not win this fight. The better user experience will win.

If Spotify won't do it, then maybe Apple Music might. Youtube Music might. Tidal might. Deezer might. Or a new service might.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by satvikpendem on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @01:07PM (#50456476)
I doubt it, look at Amazon which denied access to other chatbots and subsequently their Alexa for Shopping app shot up in downloads.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by aurareturn on Thursday November 12, 2026 @12:11AM (#50463311)
They allow Alexa to shop on Amazon so clearly there is some demand for AI agents to shop.

It all depends on market share. If Amazon thinks they'll make more money letting ChatGPT/Grok/Gemini/Muse to shop, they will. I think they will personally.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by satvikpendem on Thursday November 12, 2026 @06:49AM (#50465852)
The point is every company as I mentioned before will have their own AI agent as it's not worth it for them to relinquish control to an AI company because said company can easily float competitors such as telling the user there are better deals on Temu for example.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by booty on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @10:04AM (#50454305)
Tangent about music recommendations specifically, not the overall discussion...

I've played around a lot with using my own AI to generate music recommendations and build playlists.

> I don't want to use Spotify's AI. I want to use my own AI, who knows me more

It's pretty tough to beat what Spotify (or Apple, or whatever your platform is) knows about you w.r.t. listening habits and preferences. My successful experiments have involved exporting Spotify / Apple Music data into sqlite and a skill that tells my agent how to query this data.

It works pretty well! Still, I'd say it's only roughly on parity with the AI stuff Spotify is working on. The main benefit to rolling my own is being sure (at least, for now) that the recommendations aren't being corrupted by sponsored placement which I'm sure is Spotify's end goal.

I have no real point to this point, just blabbering. Have you cooked up any good solutions via rolling your own?

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by illiac786 on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @04:00PM (#50458602)
“My own AI” will be Apple Intelligence or Gemini for 99% of users. You will be the exception.
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by mycall on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:41AM (#50453306)
> tell it what music you'd like to listen to in plain language.

I can imagine trying 'I want to hear a techno song that goes umm tss umm tss at 140bpm" and it finds a few million.

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by andsoitis on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @09:09AM (#50453628)
> I could see myself wanting to control Spotify with my AI agent.

In what way? To find recommendations? Or search for a particular track?

Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by KellyCriterion on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @08:41AM (#50453303)
Na,this health/walking-step counter apps do not require internet access permanently? :-D
Re:Apple has new Mac app coming to make running local AI mod... by Sharlin on Wednesday November 11, 2026 @09:35AM (#50453954)
Built in at least on my phone :P