News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by syntaxing on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:10PM (#50399778)
I’m so desperate for home battery using sodium batteries. Safer and lower temperature it can operate at. Low energy density but I don’t care for home battery.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by margalabargala on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:15PM (#50399814)
There is an aqueous variant of sodium ion batteries that are safer than lithium, but most sodium ion batteries are NOT that variant and are more dangerous than LiFePO4.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by syntaxing on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:41PM (#50400027)
Wait what? All data I see about sodium ion is safer than LiFePO. I’m by no means an expert and would love to see why it’s the other way around
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by margalabargala on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:08PM (#50400262)
It's definitely not that cut and dry. Here's a paper with a good breakdown of safety comparisons: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352152X2...

Tldr: while sodium thermal runaways are less dangerous than lithium, they are more likely to happen, and in particular charging a sodium battery to 100% SOC makes thermal runaway significantly more likely than in LFP batteries.

It's true that things like puncture or short circuit are much much less dangerous than with lithium. That is a big part of why the increased thermal runaway risk gets overlooked.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by DannyBee on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:13PM (#50400308)
Agreed.

The main thing about LFP is people (stupidly) shove them in a basement or enclosed space because they are "safe".

But the "safe" part is that they outgas hydrogen when in thermal runaway, which, combined with enclosed spaces like basements (where people often have gas heaters or ....), is .... a super super bad idea.

Ironically, in this situation, sodium-ion is worse than LFP in almost every conceivable way - the gas is more flammable, toxic, etc.

People who think sodium-ion is "safer" are being sold a bill of goods.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by adrian_b on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:15AM (#50403213)
> the gas is more flammable, toxic, etc

There are many alternative materials for the cathodes of sodium-ion batteries and for now the industry has not settled on one of them as being the best.

The safety properties depend on the cathodic material. The vented gas can be toxic only for one class of materials (Prussian blue analogs) and IIRC none of the currently existing commercial sodium-ion batteries uses this kind of cathodes.

For the other cathode types, the vented gas is hydrogen exactly like in almost any kind of battery, and it is equally flammable for all kinds of batteries.

In the article linked above, the conclusion was that for one kind of cathodic materials, which perhaps is the one used in most currently existing sodium-ion batteries, the risk of damaging the battery by overcharging and the risk of thermal runaway (assuming that the battery management system fails to prevent these), are slightly higher than for LFP but lower than for other lithium-ion batteries.

On the other hand, mechanical damage by puncturing the batteries is less dangerous than for any lithium-ion batteries.

These conclusions are not definitive about sodium-ion batteries, because other cathodic materials will behave differently, and there is still a lot of experience to gain with sodium-ion batteries, so it is certain that the cathodic materials used in 2030 will not be the same as today.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by WarmWash on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:22PM (#50400355)
There is also the possibility of releasing hydrogen cyanide during a runaway event for some variants too
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by adrian_b on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:21AM (#50403237)
That can happen only for the sodium-ion batteries that use 1 of at least 5 possible classes of cathodic materials, i.e. Prussian blue analogs, and it seems that none of the currently existing commercial sodium-ion batteries uses this kind of cathode.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by mycall on Saturday November 07, 2026 @06:44AM (#50403692)
Isn't a better/safer solution than Li or Na is for the industry to switch to solid state?
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by toomuchtodo on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:16PM (#50399818)
Are you in the US?
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by syntaxing on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:42PM (#50400037)
Yup
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by toomuchtodo on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:47PM (#50400501)
So, I’m really hopeful that sodium batteries are going to come down in cost quickly, but if you can find a provider like Base Power or similar where it’s heavily subsidized, there’s a small upfront fee, and they can provide you the economic benefits until sodium batteries reach favorable economic success criteria, that’s a shim until you can replace that with sodium batteries you own outright at a favorable price. You’d have to model what you can get today with a sodium chemistry versus what you can get on offer from one of these battery service providers.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by maxnevermind on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:30PM (#50399931)
I thought the main advantage in comparison with LFP is the lower price(long term) and better sub-zero performance?
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by syntaxing on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:42PM (#50400033)
Nope. Almost all batteries I see for LFP have heaters for them at too low temps (around freezing 0C/32F). Where as sodium ion can discharge at -25C
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by rcxdude on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:59PM (#50400193)
lithium batteries can usually discharge below 0C, it's the charging at sub-zero temperatures that kills them.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by pfdietz on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:01PM (#50400204)
There's a yttrium-doped variety of LFP that's supposed to work better at lower temperature.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by benjiro29 on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:11PM (#50400281)
Discharging is not the issue with LiPo4 or other lithium tech. They can work up to negative temperatures without any issue. They can go down to -20°C (-4°F).

The problem is charging the battery at negative, as this damages the internal structure. So you need to heat up the battery (aka, you discharge by warming up heating elements), until you hit the right point. And then you can charge up, what will create heat and thus allow for non-damaging charging.

Some even have a fun trick, where if your going to a EV station with your car (end point route on your build in sat nav). They can start to pre-drain the battery if its really too cold, to warm up the batteries even more. So by the time your at the charger, the batteries are on temperature. I forgot what brand did it that way, seen that feature years ago.

What is different is that Sodium-Ion batteries can charge from negative (i think it was -10°C), as they do not suffer from the same damaging effect.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by dwattttt on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:18PM (#50400329)
Tesla do this if they know they're navigating to a charger.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by martinald on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:45PM (#50400492)
Nearly all EVs now do "battery preconditioning" when on the way to a charger. They would be pretty unusable without, I know one person had a model that didn't have it (this was a few years back) and he could barely pull more than 10kW in winter from public chargers, vs 100kW+ in summer at the exact same chargers.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by lazide on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:44PM (#50400482)
Lithium can discharge just fine at -25C without heaters.

Charging it at or around 0C will destroy it extremely rapidly due to electroplating of lithium.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by fpoling on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:56AM (#50402851)
LFMP variant of LFP with added magnesium mostly solved this. Presently it is not as long-lasting as LFP so is not suitable for home batteries, but it covers typical lifespan of a car and solves the issues with cold climate.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by rootusrootus on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:09PM (#50400268)
[delayed]
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by ricardobeat on Friday November 06, 2026 @08:56PM (#50400897)
Standard sodium batteries are much more explosive than LiFE
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by nine_k on Friday November 06, 2026 @10:01PM (#50401224)
Can they experience a thermal runaway? Can it be triggered by minor deformations or dents?
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by ricardobeat on Friday November 06, 2026 @10:14PM (#50401281)
https://youtu.be/W1ya_ls1zkA?t=209

CATL has demonstrated much better safety for their sodium EV batteries, but home and energy storage batteries are likely packs of standard 18650 cells like the on in the video.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by margalabargala on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:16PM (#50408579)
Yes and no, respectively.

Deformations and dents do not trigger a thermal runaway in sodium batteries.

A sodium battery is MUCH MORE likely to experience a spontaneous thermal runaway due to being at a high SOC.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by numpad0 on Friday November 06, 2026 @09:56PM (#50401196)
[delayed]
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by unrented7977 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:42AM (#50404971)
You can have an interposer charge controller. It isn't complicated. Many/most cells in consumer products already have one.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by marcosdumay on Friday November 06, 2026 @10:06PM (#50401247)
There will probably never be a battery that can power your home but can be used without any kind of worry.

The right thing is to place the battery in a way that you don't have to worry abut the fire, not to expect a high-density battery to be perfectly safe.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by adrianN on Friday November 06, 2026 @10:14PM (#50401280)
A tank of diesel and a generator are a kind of battery that you have to worry about very little. Sodium ion batteries are much safer than lithium.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by otherme123 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @03:07AM (#50402630)
They are kind of difficult to recharge using solar panels. They also smell bad and are noisy.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by adrianN on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:27AM (#50403006)
Of course, but that was not the point. Evidently there are ways to store energy that are quite safe, so you can't conclude that all forms of storage are inherently unsafe.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by qwytw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @01:51PM (#50406942)
Well diesel can catch fire in certain circumstances and can do a huge amount of damage when it does. I'm not sure it's that much safer than some types of batteries...
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by otherme123 on Monday November 09, 2026 @04:10AM (#50423060)
When a battery/electric car catches fire, the news are heavily amplified. The fire is spectacular, true, and there is no way to put it out but to wait for the car to consume.

But the reality is that the burning rate of ICE cars is a lot higher than electric cars (only electric, that don't carry a heat source along the battery), by far: https://www.motor.com/2026/07/ev-fires-vs-ice-fires-myth-vs-...

Same tune for diesel generators: they catch fire, fumes must be correctly ventilated or you get a flammable atmosphere, rooms where they are installed must be seriously protected against fire hazards (https://global-generators.com/blog/diesel-generator-fire-saf...). But when one catches fire, only local news report it, nobody outside town ever get notice of it, and people tend to think they are 100% fireproof. Meanwhile, a big lithium battery catches fire in California, and the news might even go global.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by marcosdumay on Saturday November 07, 2026 @02:48PM (#50407439)
Are you seriously claiming that fuel depots bring no dire risks? Really?
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by kasabali on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:58PM (#50408430)
Diesel is damn hard to set on fire
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by Brian_K_White on Friday November 06, 2026 @11:29PM (#50401623)
inherently self-limiting processes are nothing rare or special
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by cowlevel on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:39AM (#50401963)
LFP batteries are pretty safe. Look up some videos of demonstrations. You can cut them in half with a metal knife and nothing happens besides the loss of capacity, and I suppose the knife heats up from the short-circuit current as well.

I don't know what kind of shenanigans are going on to make that happen, but it's impressive.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by audunw on Saturday November 07, 2026 @04:07AM (#50402914)
Battery safety has very little to do with energy density. High energy density can make the outcomes worse for an unsafe battery, but doesn’t tell you anything about the risk of the fire to begin with.

The reason current Li-ion batteries are unsafe is that they contain a flammable electrolyte. There are batteries with higher energy density that have solid or semi-solid electrolytes. They’re so safe you should probably worry a lot more about driving your car than charging your battery.

Worrying about LFP or So-ion is probably also a waste of time.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by scheme271 on Saturday November 07, 2026 @12:34AM (#50401934)
LFP batteries are quite a bit safer than the LMN or NMC batteries. The sodium batteries are more stable than LFP I think but I'm not sure how much longer and if that matters too much for home battery usage.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by UncleOxidant on Friday November 06, 2026 @07:11PM (#50400287)
Sodium batteries will only continue to get cheaper. Cost parity now, but probably closer to 1/2 the price in a few years as production ramps up.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by UqWBcuFx6NV4r on Friday November 06, 2026 @08:29PM (#50400740)
Honestly, yes, re energy density. I hadn’t seen home batteries in-person until a couple of years ago. I was surprised by how small they could actually be (still with a decent capacity). I’d totally trade some of that for chemistry with a less… catastrophic failure mode, and I don’t even have a big house, even for non-US standards.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by MarsZebra on Friday November 06, 2026 @09:54PM (#50401185)
Aren't sodium lower density (at least in terms of weight) than LiFe?
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by pg_bot on Friday November 06, 2026 @11:27PM (#50401612)
No, sodium batteries are less energy dense.
Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by adrian_b on Saturday November 07, 2026 @05:31AM (#50403294)
No.

The ratio of the stored charge per mass is 23/7 = about 3.3 times higher for lithium than for sodium, and the voltage can be higher by around 10% for lithium, leading to an even higher energy per mass ratio.

Nonetheless, both sodium and lithium are only a small fraction of the mass of lithium-ion batteries and sodium-ion batteries, so the difference in stored energy per mass is much smaller than for the pure metals.

In practice that means that today LFP batteries and sodium-ion batteries have about the same energy per mass ratio, with both having a lower specific energy than the more expensive NMC lithium-ion batteries.

For now, sodium-ion batteries are very new, so they are still a little more expensive than LFP, but eventually they will be significantly cheaper.

Already now they have important advantages, so there applications for which they are preferable even when still more expensive, e.g. where it must be possible to charge them at very low temperatures or where it must be possible to discharge them completely.

Re:CATL Sodium Battery Hits LFP Cost Parity in 2026: 15,000 ... by SubiculumCode on Friday November 06, 2026 @10:25PM (#50401341)
yeah, I am waiting to replace my home battery for the safer sodium option whenever it becomes possible. I keep hoping.