News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by leoqa on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:36AM (#50367099)
“Let’s stop all new economic activity as it might have an effect on <insert commodity> prices” is just so juvenile and poorly thought through.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by tenacious_tuna on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:50AM (#50367307)
That's a reductive take in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis. Of course people will resist commercial developments that'll increase the cost of one of the most essential resources everyone uses day-to-day for the sake of shareholder value.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by throw10920 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:12AM (#50367672)
> That's a reductive take in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis. Of course people will resist commercial developments that'll increase the cost of one of the most essential resources everyone uses day-to-day

Your argument conveniently ignores that electricity is tiny fraction of the average American's budget, which is far more heavily weighted toward housing, gas, and groceries. This argument is extremely tenuous.

> for the sake of shareholder value

This is emotionally manipulative and without substance. Data centers are being built because there's demand for them from people who want to use AI, like me. These data centers drive down the cost of AI, which is valuable to me, and to society. The fact that it also happens to increase "shareholder value" is irrelevant.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by bluefirebrand on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:24AM (#50367898)
> Data centers are being built because there's demand for them from people who want to use AI, like me

No they aren't

They're being built so shareholders can profit off of people like you. The fact that you benefit from it does not actually factor in any way aside from the fact that you will pay them for that benefit

They aren't benevolently trying to help you out, they just want your money.

The fact that you want AI and think it will help you and society is actually what is irrelevant. If they weren't confident it would make them money it would not be built no matter how beneficial it would be.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by throw10920 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:52AM (#50368307)
>> Data centers are being built because there's demand for them from people who want to use AI, like me

> No they aren't

You literally said they are building data centers to cater to demand later on in your own comment:

> If they weren't confident it would make them money it would not be built

There you go. Your own point debunked by your own words.

> They aren't benevolently trying to help you out

I didn't say anything about the owners building stuff out of charity or benevolence. Are you responding to the wrong comment? Yours is more-or-less irrelevant to mine in addition to being self-contradictory.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by bluefirebrand on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:09PM (#50368524)
Come on bud. You claimed

> The fact that it (building data centers) also happens to increase "shareholder value" is irrelevant

It's not irrelevant. It is the primary reason they are being built

Your understanding about the cause and effect around why data centers are being built is backwards

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by throw10920 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:17PM (#50368622)
Please own up to the fact that you self-contradicted yourself in your own comment by first claiming that "No they aren't" and then "If they weren't confident it would make them money it would not be built".

> It's not irrelevant. It is the primary reason they are being built

...and without any implications, that fact is irrelevant. Do you understand what relevance means? It means that there's meaning, implication. You haven't given a single follow-on implication from that hypothesis that actually matters to the discussion.

> Your understanding about the cause and effect around why data centers are being built is completely backwards

You don't understand your own position. You can't possibly understand mine.

If you had taken a high-school economics course you would know that in this case, shareholder value and market demand imply each other. Your statement "Your understanding about the cause and effect around why data centers are being built is completely backwards" betrays a complete and total lack of understanding about economics, because there is no "backwards" when two things cause each other.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by bluefirebrand on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:13PM (#50369382)
> and without any implications, that fact is irrelevant

If you think people's motivations are irrelevant then we just live in different worlds, and there's no point continuing

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by throw10920 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:58PM (#50374581)
> If you think people's motivations are irrelevant

I never said that peoples' motivations are irrelevant in general. Just that they're irrelevant in this specific case. You're putting words in my mouth, which clearly indicates malice.

> then we just live in different worlds, and there's no point continuing

We do. I live in reality, where most people understand basic facts of economics, causality is meaningful, and you still haven't actually provided a reason why you think that the motivations matter, so as far as the rest of us in the real world know, they don't. You've had three comments to point that out, and you haven't, so the reasonable conclusion is that you don't have a reason, and you're running away to avoid that intellectual dissonance.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by rcxdude on Thursday November 05, 2026 @04:34AM (#50377128)
There can be multiple effects for a given action. The main objection I have to this argument is the idea that the only beneficiaries of any corporate decision are the shareholders.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by tenacious_tuna on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:46PM (#50369017)
> Your argument conveniently ignores that electricity is tiny fraction

You assume people's psychological resistance to increased cost is entirely based on the proportional impact of those cost increases. Yes, housing/gas/groceries are much larger portions of the increase in cost, but datacenters are much more visible than poor foreign policy or starting new conflicts with overseas energy producers. Also, electricity traditionally has much less cost variation than gas/housing/groceries.

> This is emotionally manipulative and without substance. Data centers are being built because there's demand for them from people who want to use AI, like me.

At my company's internal conference we had a rep from one of our partners come speak, and he emphasized that a significant value-add of our company's relationship to our partners is that we're much more tech-forward. he went on to say "Execs in [partner industry] don't know what AI is or what it does, but they know that they want it."

We're seeing AI features being bolted into every application under the sun, whether it actually adds functionality or not. I think you bear a significant burden of proof to the claim that the demand for datacenters is in turn driven by consumer demand for AI, and company boards losing their minds over what they think AI can do and demanding their R&D divisions sink millions of dollars into AI spend to try and capitalize on their dreams.

I'm reminded of Bitcoin: for a hot minute every startup was talking about blockchain and GPUs were getting snapped up by miners left and right because of what people imagined the value could be. That's what I'm getting at when I say "shareholder value:" these developments seem to be less about what value a company is _actually_ producing (& thus the inherent cost-of-goods-sold demand), and more about the _possibility_ of what value a company _could_ produce.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by throw10920 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:50PM (#50369068)
> You assume people's psychological resistance to increased cost is entirely based on the proportional impact of those cost increases. Yes, housing/gas/groceries are much larger portions of the increase in cost, but datacenters are much more visible than poor foreign policy or starting new conflicts with overseas energy producers. Also, electricity traditionally has much less cost variation than gas/housing/groceries.

This is a good point. I see that I misunderstood your original argument - I thought you were claiming that the increase was going to be financially meaningful, rather than what you actually said, which was the perception of and response to the increase. My apologies. Thank you for your thoughtful response!

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by tenacious_tuna on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:17PM (#50369420)
> I thought you were claiming that the increase was going to be financially meaningful

tbf, I didn't state the psychological thesis up front either :)

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by joquarky on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:06PM (#50372193)
Some people on HN live in an ivory tower. Every "tiny fraction" is a big deal to someone working two jobs to pay rent.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by blooalien on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:58PM (#50374579)
> ... to someone working two jobs to pay rent.

Or two jobs and a "side-gig" or three, and still barely "squeaking by", and still unable to afford health care or any other such "luxuries" of life.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by oklahomasports on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:10PM (#50374674)
there is no cost of living crisis
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by harimau777 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @10:55AM (#50367408)
I mean, if the new economic activity primarily serves to further enrich the wealthy then ya, that seems like a reasonable stance.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by pjc50 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:11AM (#50367657)
If I get a vote about new economic activity, and it makes me personally poorer, I'm going to need a very good argument as to why I should permit it. Or, you know, pay me.

If the data centers hadn't been _quite_ so hostile to absolutely all their critics and instead had simply offered to pay for some local schools or libraries or something, at like 5% of the cost of the data center, this would have gone differently.

Instead Altman says it will destroy the world: https://www.techradar.com/pro/quote-of-the-day-by-sam-altman...

So it's bad for the world according to its proponents, and at the same time, a bad neighbour? Why would anyone not vote against it given those?

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by walt_grata on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:17AM (#50367760)
If that new economic activity has lopsided benefits and will never pay off for those negatively impacted by those price increases, then yeah shut it down or regulate it so that the benefits are shared equally by all. Shorter version, if the new economic activity is exploitive of people and their communities, then shut it down hard.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by ryandrake on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:38PM (#50369717)
People are tired of New Economic Activity that only benefits the already-rich.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by watwut on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @12:48PM (#50369049)
Generally, economic activity is supposed to raise living standards. AI promisses to a.) speed up climate change b.) facilitate surveillance and authoritarian tech bros b.) make people obsolete and unemployable c.) kill us all because reasons.

Datacenter is not bringing more economic activity to the area.

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by insane_dreamer on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @01:45PM (#50369814)
future economic activity is fine;

the questions are 1) who is footing the bill and 2) who is benefiting from that economic activity

if it's not the local community, then why should they agree to it much less pay for some of it

Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by hardbass on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:08PM (#50372728)
Further question, why is it the default position that others should have a say on legal activities you are allowed to do on your own land? Thats frankly absurd. It should be on the people breaching others private property rights to prove real damages.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by 12_throw_away on Thursday November 05, 2026 @12:26AM (#50375553)
Pretending that market-distorting impacts on local utilities, air pollution, noise pollution, etc. etc. are just "legal activities you are allowed to do on your own land" is flabbergastingly dishonest.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by hardbass on Thursday November 05, 2026 @02:36AM (#50376269)
Are you sure about noise pollution or are you copying something heardd from uninformed people? Again, thr onus should be on you tonprove damages in court. Its fucking ridiculous that people are clamoring to control others private property.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by insane_dreamer on Thursday November 05, 2026 @10:32AM (#50380394)
is this a serious question? because a DC has external impacts which, say, a workshop on your property does not; that's why.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by hardbass on Thursday November 05, 2026 @11:45AM (#50381322)
How can you be sure the workshop on your property doesn't have external impacts? You are being a bad community player by not first getting your workshop inspected and tested and awaiting the permission of the community and government before doing anything there.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by enaaem on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @03:55PM (#50371385)
Juvenile? Seems like utility maxing rational actors to me.
Re:US voters roundly reject data centers in ballot measures by 9935c101ab17a66 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:54PM (#50372598)
This is an intellectually dishonest and frankly completely inappropriate attempt to twist someone’s words. HN generally has good standards about acceptable comments and I’m surprised to see this here.