Looking at your example, it fails to explain why wages rose for 200 years before the alleged stagnation hit (sure, you can hack some Leninist stuff on about imperialism, but it's mostly unconvincing). Worse, Marx's grand scheme of progress is pretty flawed: even in one lifetime, people readily shift to and from one economic system to another, and each system relies upon and coexists with its predecessors and successors.
Wide swaths of life and economic activity aren't subject to what Marx described as capitalism, and as capital increasingly tries to squeeze more and more value out of people, people increasingly shift to using exit as a means of liberation. Look around you, and you can see it: that's what's most marvelous about the era we live in.
As it turned out, materialist history did provide a very revealing perspective, but not the one Braudel anticipated. Quite the opposite. Among its many revelations was the unavoidable fact that Marx's assertions about history simply weren't supported by the facts. Over time, Braudel found his reverence waning. Eventually, his loss of faith turned into outright rejection. That said, were it not for Marx, Braudel's absolutely brilliant history may never have been written. And that would be a shame, since the materialist approach that Braudel pioneered has become more relevant than ever in our own data-driven age.
http://www.amazon.com/Civilization-Capitalism-15th-18th-Cent...
I didn't intend to come off as wholly dismissive of Marx--it's very fair to say that he's one of the great thinkers of political economy and sociology. But relying on 19th century thinkers when they've been surpassed always strikes me as unfortunate.
Additionally, we've pretty much gotten over that problem. The problem now is a sovereign debt crisis, especially in Europe, and that has little to do with the market.
Abstract: No.
To me though it seems obvious that putting more people into the housing market, especially while it is experiencing a moderate boom would simply amplify that boom, as folks who managed to end up with some positive equity would work to maintain it, "flip" their properties, etc. As long as the market was always going up and people could generate positive equity just by sitting on their ass defaults were rare, because it would have been easy for people to sell their properties if they couldn't make payments in the future. Also, a lot of these mortgages were designed for flipping, having low payments early on before balloon payments later, making it easier to avoid default in the early years. On the other side of the equation, investors ate up securitized mortgages while the market was going up because they thought there was no risk. If people defaulted on their mortgages the properties would just be foreclosed on and since the property would inevitably have a higher market value than the mortgage, there was no downside for the investors. Which works just fine until the market reaches its breaking point and stalls out, after which people start going underwater on their mortgages, defaults increase, valuations fall, and everything goes to hell, as we saw.
The paper addresses the proposition of affordable housing legislation causing an excess in sub-prime lending just prior to the peak of the real estate boom. However, it fails to address the more important and more basic question of whether affordable housing legislation injected an excess of "unqualified" buyers into the housing market, distorting the market and leading to a bigger boom and a bigger bust.
However, as I mentioned, that whole mess (regardless of its cause) has only contributed a comparatively small amount to the much larger sovereign debt crisis that the world is facing now, which would take a lot of stretching to blame on the market.
When AIG and Lehman went down, the crisis had already hit. That's what was meant by "financial crisis". The government actions to abilout AIG only happened after. So you have your timelines backwards.
And the NINJA mortgage issuers (like Goldman's Countrywide) weren't issuing dodgy mortgages because the government was taking on the risk, they were doing it because they could offload the risk to chumps like AIG and Lehman.
Pure systemic free-market failure. Basically the banks were trusted to regulate themselves, and the risk controls all over New York, Frankfurt and London were pants. If we still had the heavy regulations of the 1970s, none of it would have happened.
Because poor people tend to get sick of their lot and revolt sooner or later. It's been a problem for monarchs through the ages.
http://www.worldvision.org/news/worldwide-fewer-people-live-...
Its just that wealth is being more evenly distributed and the U.S. is feeling some of that pressure.
I'm not sure exactly what you mean by "so-called progress".
These are poisonous words made by people dreaming of a world made of slaves. Dreaming of a world where the word "freedom" would be forbidden.
The last thing we need now in a time of crisis is socialists or communists trying to push their agenda.
I have to say though, your comment deeply disturbs me. Those weren't poisonous words. And I highly doubt that his comment, which seems quite informative, comes from his "dreams of a world made of slaves".
I can tell you're American. Constantly when I travel to the US, I get spoon fed this bullshit when people find out I'm Canadian. I have literally - on more than one occasion - had people tell me how they couldn't live in a "socialist" country like Canada. They then proceed to educate me (without any indication I want to hear shit about their opinions or beliefs) on the benefits of capitalism, how Obama is enslaving America, how universal health care is freedom lessening crap, and so on. It blows my mind the level of intolerance and subtle hatred.
He's just being part of the discussion, providing opposing information and some of his opinions. Chill the fuck out.
I wonder how you maintain the cognitive dissonance that so many people here seem to hate Obama and Obamacare, yet somehow re-elect him. Must be confusing.
Second, I don't think America is a "homogeneous mass that behaves that way" and neither did I say that. I said that this (getting to hear long-winded rants about political views, religion, social issues, etc.) occurs constantly when I'm in the US. You've confused my statement of anecdotal evidence as a statement of all encompassing truth. It isn't. I don't believe the majority of Americans are like this. I just think (note that word: think, not know, it's my opinion) you have a significant portion of people that are like this, are quite vocal about it, and aren't overly tolerant of differing opinions.
Third, I'm not confused and no simultaneously differing viewpoints are rolling around in my brain either. I didn't state my own opinions on the matter of Obama, capitalism, universal health care (bet you can guess where I stand on that one though), I merely stated MY experiences with the opinions of Americans I had ran into while traveling. Yes, you relected Obama. Cheers. 48.97% of people that voted didn't vote for Obama. Maybe the people I'm referring to are a subset of them, no?
I visit Canada frequently, Nova Scotia to be exact, and in my time there I have run across some interesting viewpoints, but I would not pretend to have a firm grasp of any significant portion of Canadians. I understand it is one fairly isolated region, it is small, and I don't have full context.
Now, to give you some perspective, there are 310 MILLION Americans, which is 10 times more than Canada. I think people often don't realize this. There are as many people in California alone as all of Canada (more actually). Within the span of 9 hours we could drive and visit cities within California with such different ideologies you'd not understand how they can all operate together.
So excuse me for being highly suspicious of any person claiming they've met some Americans and thus reached some conclusion on how a significant portion of them think. Especially when normally something like this could just as easily be explained by confirmation bias and particularly vocal minorities.
I suppose my point is that I don't understand the need to bring "Americans" into this at all. You were having a discussion with one individual that you know little about, so what is the need to essentially say "I bet you are of nationality X for this negative reason". Outside of being a by the book presumptive and prejudicial position, it will also serve to alienate people that may otherwise agree with you.
Nobody else on the planet says SOCIALISM with the Bill O'Reilly sneer and think that's a debate-ender.
Try to imagine a Chinese or a Frenchman saying that. Doesn't work. That's because in other countries "socialism" isn't a swear word.
Your knee-jerk reactionism betrays you. Marx is capable of having some good--or at the very least, thought-worthy--points amid an ultimately flawed solution (communism). For you to dismiss a point by painting it with a "red menace" ad-hominem (not your words, but certainly their spirit) is, too, dangerous thinking--or perhaps lack of thinking.
Basically if I get a free pass and resource to move anywhere, I where do I go find this "better" place that moved beyond Capitalism and is free of these contradictions.
I hear North European countries are a pretty good place to be? I've never been there. What makes that better and how far are they both from the current Capitalist system that US has and also how far are they from Marx's ideal?
I don't think you can tax your way into getting societies like these. The world wars gutted large parts of the population and society had to change.
The NHS in the UK was set up in response to having fought a war on their own soil, something which the US has not done in a long time.
The labor theory of value just doesn't make sense. The only system in which it does is a communist system. And even then, if somebody values the commodity more than the value of the labor that went into producing it, they'll pay that price to acquire it on the secondary market.
But workers don't create that much wealth in a day by themselves; they need plant and material to create the product or service that is sold. The buildings they work in, the machinery that they use, the raw material they consume, are equally important inputs to production and it is these which are supplied by the capitalist.
Even in this case, and in most cases. The workers are actually are super fortunate to even have and opportunity to make $200 without taking any risks at all. Everything is built ready, all the investments and risks are born by somebody else. All you do is work(Im not saying that's easy or insignificant, but it is individually insignificant to the larger scenario where somebody has built a big industry- your contribution are small but are compensated), and at that kind of financial security forgoing 1/6th part of your earnings is hardly a problem.
While I don't really know about the particulars of his proposed solutions, I think Marx does identify a real problem that free-markets on their own do not guarantee solutions to.
It's never a bad idea to be on the look out to make sure our economy is working to serve everybody involved in it, at least in my opinion. That's my biggest takeaway from Marx.
> The workers are actually are super fortunate to even have and opportunity to make $200 without taking any risks at all.
I think the most important point about Marx analysis is, that this statement may or may not be true. There is nothing in the 'capitalist production process,' which guarantees that the workers are treated well ( or even survive their workday). If the bourgeois gains a advantage by treating his workers well, he will do it. On the other hand, if he gains a advantage by hurting his workers then he will either do it, or be replaced by someone who is willing to hurt his workers.
19th century economists did then follow this thought to construct the market backwards, that is some were trying to model markets based not on utility of a product and demand, but purely on labor costs.
Because if you say we should go down to zero profits, then we get nothing to invest further. Needless to mention the enterprise/corporation/etc itself will have no motivation for growth, why should they when there is nothing to gain?
What's next after Karl Marx? That the homophobic racist murderer that was the Che Guevara was correct?
The thing that saddens me the most on a forum supposedly made of entrepreneurs trying to create wealth is to see that there are so many people who are still failing for the poisonous words of a corrupt few who would have just loved to rule the earth: be it Kim-Jong Ill or Kim-Karl Marx, it makes me very very scared.
The first thing socialists and communists tries to do is to ruin everyone and reinforce the power of the state.
I choose freedom. Even if it means bubbles and crises.
I prefer that to slavery.
"Better dead than red".
Thankfully I'm not alone.
Pray tell, what successes has communism and radical socialism achieved?
That said, and emphasizing I have no love of the following countries and think some form of liberal democracy would have worked substantially better...
Cuba started from a fairly good baseline, so we shouldn't read too much into it, but it has superior healthcare and education to much of Latin America.
The Soviet Union had a couple decades of breakneck economic growth: many economists, perhaps even the majority, expected it to have outgrown the West by the 1980s. This should be discounted somewhat, though, this time because the UK and the USA also rapidly developed at various points in their history.
The USSR also excelled at generating a large class of engineers, scientists, and mathematicians, who contributed a large body of knowledge to the world. And it made some pretty good chess players, too, when it wasn't cheating like crazy.
I'm no lefty, but you make a lousy case.
| Kim-Jong Ill or Kim-Karl Marx
I seriously doubt that Karl Marx would have approved of North Korea. Just because someone calls themselves 'Communist' doesn't necessarily mean it's so. There are plenty of dictatorships that call themselves "The Democratic Repubic of X" or something like that. Just because democracy is in the name doesn't make them democratic.(Oddly enough, Marx probably would have approved of the Khmer Rouge. He was really into violent upheaval to transition between forms of government.)
| The first thing socialists and communists tries to do is to
| ruin everyone and reinforce the power of the state.
|
| I choose freedom. Even if it means bubbles and crises.
|
| "Better dead than red".
This just seems to be an opinion born of privilege. Would you adhere to "better dead than red" if the death came from starving in the streets (while people born into money like Paris Hilton live it up) rather than some romantic idea of fighting off foreign invaders and living in the hills (i.e. Red Dawn)?socialism = Norway, communism = North Korea
So you think Norway and North Korea are identical?
Or are you under the delusion that Norway is badly managed? Do you think people get dragged to the Gulag there?
You better shut off the Fox News and go read a book.
Marx and Engels wrote that the world has seen five economic systems. Each system collapsed due to internal contradictions. The first system was hunting-gathering, then Babylonian/Greek/etc. style slavery, then feudalism, and then capitalism. They saw the Paris Commune as the harbinger for the next economic system which would replace capitalism.
The central contradiction in capitalism Marx spells out clearly in Capital, although its a little too much to explain in a comment. Basically workers create $240 of wealth every eight hour work day, but are only paid $200 a day. The $40 goes to profit, to get more capital, to make more commodities. But what is happening here - the worker is shorted $40 a day, and what happens with that money is commodities are made. Who are going to buy all these commodities when workers are not getting all the wealth they create? Well credit fixes that in the short term but creates a bigger long term problem.
The communist manifesto says "the commercial crises that by their periodic return put the existence of the entire bourgeois society on trial, each time more threateningly". I certainly feel this way. So apparently does Stratfor. On this point, the left and right are in agreement.