News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @12:56AM (#5030406)
Basically workers create $240 of wealth every eight hour work day, but are only paid $200 a day.

But workers don't create that much wealth in a day by themselves; they need plant and material to create the product or service that is sold. The buildings they work in, the machinery that they use, the raw material they consume, are equally important inputs to production and it is these which are supplied by the capitalist.

Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by kamaal on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @01:21AM (#5030478)
I think Marx went into over simplification when it came to issues like these.

Even in this case, and in most cases. The workers are actually are super fortunate to even have and opportunity to make $200 without taking any risks at all. Everything is built ready, all the investments and risks are born by somebody else. All you do is work(Im not saying that's easy or insignificant, but it is individually insignificant to the larger scenario where somebody has built a big industry- your contribution are small but are compensated), and at that kind of financial security forgoing 1/6th part of your earnings is hardly a problem.

Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by cantankerous on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @01:37AM (#5030509)
Marx was concerned with the differences between an agrarian society moving to an industiralized society and the implications it had for the control of wealth and power. Prior to industrialization, at least in the mind of Marx, individuals were able to effectively reap what they sowed on a farm somewhere (also an oversimplification, but still). In an industrialized era, one man at the time could not compete on his own for lacking capital, an education, and connections (put Marx into the context of his time and geopolitical background). Marx wasn't overly concerned with the issue of compensation of a capitalist being commiserate with the risk s/he takes, but rather the protection of individuals who now live in a world where they are, more likely than not, stuck working for somebody else.

While I don't really know about the particulars of his proposed solutions, I think Marx does identify a real problem that free-markets on their own do not guarantee solutions to.

It's never a bad idea to be on the look out to make sure our economy is working to serve everybody involved in it, at least in my opinion. That's my biggest takeaway from Marx.

Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by yk on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @04:03AM (#5030785)
Marx was actually not so much concerned with fair compensation as with fair distribution of power ( of which money is one aspect).

> The workers are actually are super fortunate to even have and opportunity to make $200 without taking any risks at all.

I think the most important point about Marx analysis is, that this statement may or may not be true. There is nothing in the 'capitalist production process,' which guarantees that the workers are treated well ( or even survive their workday). If the bourgeois gains a advantage by treating his workers well, he will do it. On the other hand, if he gains a advantage by hurting his workers then he will either do it, or be replaced by someone who is willing to hurt his workers.

Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by cantankerous on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @01:25AM (#5030483)
I think an important detail to consider, if I remember it correctly, is that Marx is assuming that there's a moral imperative to consider when paying workers based on the value of their work because they aren't able to create this kind of value on their own in an industrialized society because the means of production is otherwise owned/controlled by a powerful establishment (bourgeois or something). An agreement between labor and management/capitalism is required to make sure that the workers' are able to take home a pay they find adequate considering the value they create. I think a way Americans have been able to strike this balance in the past is via labor unions. This probably isn't so much the case any more.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by yk on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @02:11AM (#5030569)
So the buildings get paid? Marx did work under the assumption of the "Labor theory of value" [1], which states that only labor adds value to raw products, and that only humans are paid. So the price of a consumer product may be broken down into labor costs, raw material, R&D, long term investments etc. But each of the non labor points can be broken up further and in the end you end with only labor.

19th century economists did then follow this thought to construct the market backwards, that is some were trying to model markets based not on utility of a product and demand, but purely on labor costs.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labor_theory_of_value

Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @02:56AM (#5030663)
No, the person who invested in the building and bought the machinery and raw material gets reimbursed and paid the opportunity cost of their investment, aka normal profits (as opposed to economic profits). I think the labor theory of value is one of Marx's main errors; it sort of works for agriculture because food does actually grow out of the ground, land was owned without being built, and in the 19th century the vast bulk of the expense involved was labor based, but this didn't translate well to industrial production at all.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by yk on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @03:31AM (#5030719)
I sort of agree, that the labor theory of value is one of the main problems of Marx's analysis. Sort of, because I think the premise that only people accept money and you always end up with profits or wages is essentially tautological. However, it is not a very useful way to think about (modern) markets, since one is too busy to trace back flows of money to actually understand their behavior.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by malandrew on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @01:20AM (#5030474)
Yes and no. Of the $40 the worker is shorted, a portion goes to the capitalist and a portion goes to the buildings they work in, the machinery they use and the raw material they consume. The benefits of those things accrue to the capitalist even though it was finance with the value created by the labor of the worker. Only the upfront costs to begin a business are attributable to the capitalist. All the growth of that business is attributable to the value created by the work being marshalled by the capitalist.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by lostlogin on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @03:41AM (#5030745)
I'm not sure that the $40, as a percentage of wage, would even cover my sick and annual leave, professional indemnity insurance, insurance against accidental injury, professional body costs, registration costs, mileage and expenses claims, clothing costs, immunizations, continuing professional development costs and the other things I guess I have missed. My employer is good.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by anigbrowl on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @03:04AM (#5030673)
Agreed. but I would argue that a) the upfront costs to begin the business are significant, b) the benefits also accrue to the workers insofar as a growing business provides ongoing employment, and c) the marshaling of work is itself a form of work. It's not like you just tell 200 workers to turn up somewhere and production/distribution/sales happens automatically.
Re:The Crisis of the Middle Class and American Power by philwelch on Wednesday January 09, 2013 @02:20AM (#5030585)
Plus, an individual worker might create $240 of wealth for the customer, or he might create $160, or he might create -$160. The big driver of the gap between value created and wage paid is the level of risk assumed. You cannot capture all the value you create in the economy without also capturing all the risk. People who try to do this are called "entrepreneurs" and they often end up insolvent.