News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by paxy on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @07:46PM (#50267499)
They have no doubt realized that hosting third party models is far more profitable.

Let someone else take on the training costs, and charge a premium for your hardware.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by appplication on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:21PM (#50268224)
handshake meme with Amazon and Apple
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by boringg on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:21PM (#50268225)
Seems like the smartest move. Microsoft went all in and have really not got much out of their efforts.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by aleph_minus_one on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @10:15PM (#50268579)
> Microsoft went all in and have really not got much out of their efforts.

The problem was rather that Microsoft had no real plan what they wanted to get out of AI. If they had a plan, they could have laser-focused their all-in on AI.

Instead, Microsoft just AI-slopped a lot of their bread-and-butter products, making them much worse than before. If AI is as revolutionizing and beloved by users as Microsoft believes, Microsoft could easily have created an offering like "Windows AI Pack" or "Microsoft AI" that should sell like hot cakes.

On the other hand, if you have to force AI functionality onto the users, it should be considered as a strong sign that perhaps it is not something that the users want.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by ngc248 on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @05:45AM (#50271100)
Regular ppl i.e non-techies love the copilot integration into all office products. Since techies know better, they think microsoft messed up with the AI integration everywhere.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by roryirvine on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @06:00AM (#50271198)
Even tech-adjacent folk in areas like product, user research and enterprise architecture seem to love it.

The bulk of the hands-on-keyboard time for those disciplines now seems to be using Copilot 365 as "fancy autocomplete" and "make this presentation better", Copilot Notebooks for deeper work, and coming up with all sorts of Copilot integrations and agents for managing email, Teams meetings and chats.

It's almost as if "copilot" has already become the generic term for "professional LLM", and many genuinely can't understand why us techies find it so limiting.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by watwut on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @09:30AM (#50273233)
> Regular ppl i.e non-techies love the copilot integration into all office products.

Do they, actually?

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by red-iron-pine on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @09:47AM (#50273494)
no regular person i have met loves AI integration with anything

3 of the 4 orgs I consult with have actively warned people not to use it, and/or to only use their approved AI tool (OpenAI/Claude/Gemini)

clippy 2.0 is not selling well

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by charlieyu1 on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @04:38PM (#50280558)
Regular people don’t even upgrade to Win 10/11 unless they are forced to.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by aleph_minus_one on Thursday October 29, 2026 @07:52AM (#50287551)
> Regular people don’t even upgrade to Win 10/11 unless they are forced to.

In consideration how much spying functionality was added with Windows 10 (which worsened even more with Windows 11), and that Microsoft made it insanely hard to install Windows 11 without creating some Microsoft account, it is actually very sensible that people don't want to upgrade to Windows 10/11, despite the technological improvements that these versions provide.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by trimethylpurine on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @06:06AM (#50271241)
They forced Teams on everyone and it played out well for them. Users not wanting it might not itself be a sign that it's bad for business.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by mancerayder on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @10:31AM (#50274275)
I, for one am very thankful for what Microsoft did with Windows 11. It has exactly the feature set, and AI value-add ... to inspire me to take the plunge to Fedora Workstation and I've never been happier. Even Steam games (kind of) work. More importantly dnf update -y becomes exciting.

Windows (and increasingly Apple) updates are more of a sigh and lip biting experience than an exciting one.

I'm really happy not to have touched Windows recently at all.

At work Microsoft's updates are buggy - Outlook and Teams are pretty awful on corporate Macs. Teams especially, it has a bunch of papercut type annoyances. And updates torture Corp IT.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by diogenes_atx on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:27PM (#50268257)
There is intense competition in the AI industry, especially with AI firms in China driving down prices, so it seems likely that LLM's and software products may become fungible commodities that trade close to marginal cost = marginal revenue = minimum average total cost. In other words, most of the profits from AI and software development will be competed away, eventually.

Data center hardware, by contrast, is a scarce commodity with rapidly growing demand, and therefore likely to capture most of the profits from AI and software development, if current market conditions persist.

Today's IT business trends represent a remarkable change in the industry compared to the situation 50 years ago, when startups like Microsoft and Oracle, whose business models were based exclusively on software development, challenged and overthrew the dominant player, IBM, whose primary source of revenue was from hardware.

[dead]
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by diogenes_atx on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @09:48PM (#50268382)
It's just basic economic theory applied to current IT market conditions.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by jan_m_savage on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @11:51PM (#50269171)
Thanks for the reply. Yes, indeed, it's a great analysis.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by GoToRO on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @01:08AM (#50269556)
I use AI so much that I too started hearing myself using the same phrasing as AI... not happy about it.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by jan_m_savage on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @01:15AM (#50269596)
same here :)
[dead]
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by jan_m_savage on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @11:49PM (#50269159)
my comment has been satisfactorily answered by the person it was addressed to.

it doesn't concern you.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by fifilura on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @02:54AM (#50270018)
It was not a DM.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by tomhow on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @03:24AM (#50270228)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50268257 and marked it off topic.

Please don't accuse people of writing AI-generated comments. If you suspect it, please email us: [email protected].

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by jan_m_savage on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @09:58AM (#50273662)
alright. thanks.
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by carefree-bob on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @10:12PM (#50268559)
Just as there is product-market fit, there is also product-company fit. Amazon as a company has their own cost of capital, earnings expectations, talent distribution, and organizational capacity. It is not a place where the best of the best work in mainline product development, nor is it a place that is willing or able to go through long periods of losing money in order to rapidly improve the product. The Amazon of old did that, and had different capabilities, but today's Amazon is not the same company.

Notice that you also see Google really struggling (and falling behind) in the AI race. This, despite massive resources and being responsible for key pioneering research. Same reason why IBM has failed in this area. The big established companies tend to shut their brightest people into research departments where they write papers and produce demos while the main cash cow areas remain undisturbed, so they have collections of bright people and they have money, but they rarely let their brightest people make big bets with the money, whereas startups do.

It's also why poor people spend more on lottery tickets than rich people.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by bushbaba on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @11:11PM (#50268899)
The best of the best do work at Amazon. Their cloud infra is world class. They just cannot compete in the ai/ml space with different economics. It’s an operational company and not one to do tech innovation.

Basically you want to run an LLM, Amazon. You want to build an LLM not Amazon

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by mm321 on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @11:24PM (#50268991)
> Let someone else take on the research and training costs, and charge a massive premium for your hardware.

the linked article is from July, it is almost three months old.

Now there may be a very relevant recent story; it has the potential to reduce the flow of new open weight models. This could change quite a few expectations, which are based on open weight models:

"China’s STAR 50 Index Falls 40%, Erasing $480 Billion as AI Stocks Crash"

https://www.technology.org/2026/10/27/china-ai-stock-bubble-...

https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-ai-bubble-has-alre...

Reuters says there is a run, but also deeper reasons:

"There has been no obvious selling trigger in China, although traders said high prices, tax bills and the threat of the US or other nations banning Chinese equipment in data centers all contributed."

So far I don't see any discussions of this story on HN, interestingly.

Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by alienbaby on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @03:57AM (#50270440)
The article implies they are wrapping up their current models, and instead aiming to go all in on a frontier class model?
Re:Amazon Is Gutting Its AI Division After Sustained Failure by cwillu on Wednesday October 28, 2026 @04:39AM (#50270712)
“Instead, labor and computing power are being diverted toward a singular “frontier-model effort””

Sounds like the opposite of what you're suggesting they're doing?