Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by CPUHall on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @12:05PM
(#50261313)
Title is misleading. The ruling said training on books is fair use. What got them in trouble was grabbing the books from LibGen instead of just buying them, which is a pretty dumb way to lose $1.5B. If I torrented half a million books I'd be getting a lot more than a $3k-per-book settlement.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by car on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @12:18PM
(#50261493)
Thanks, I’ve changed the submission title from the author’s original.
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by simonw on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @01:13PM
(#50262389)
Anthropic also claimed that those pirated books had not been used to train their models.
They've since bought vast numbers of second hand books and scanned those for training, which appears be legal.
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by rpdillon on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @03:41PM
(#50264670)
> which appears be legal.
Interesting phrasing from you, Simon. Is there any legal theory under which it should be illegal?
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by FireBeyond on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @03:50PM
(#50264786)
Appears to be legal in that current rulings and legislation say that to do so does not run afoul of fair use.
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by skew-aberration on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @06:41PM
(#50266889)
LLMs can reproduce the training data verbatim, under some circumstances. They have to be trained not to.
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by simonw on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @07:16PM
(#50267234)
No idea, I'm not a lawyer.
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by HDThoreaun on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @01:39PM
(#50262805)
We went through this with Google. Scanning books is legal as long as you then immediately destroy them. Then since training with material you own is fair use they’re good to go.
Re:Anthropic trained Claude on illegally obtained Stanford p...
by Madmallard on Tuesday October 27, 2026 @08:00PM
(#50267630)
"The ruling said training on books is fair use."
Like when people bring this up as if it's somehow just like acceptable.
It's not at all. That's utter bullshit. The people that run the courts have been bought out. They have no idea what the far-reaching consequences of this is.