News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why TV Lost by pg on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @04:09PM (#501999)
Live television is nearly non-existent online.

I wish I could post the graph of unique visitors that the founders of Justin.TV sent me. But while their actual numbers are presumably secret, I will say that I have never seen a steeper graph of a one-year period from any YC-funded startup. And I have seen some steep graphs now.

Re:Why TV Lost by old-gregg on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @04:27PM (#502041)
... which supports a few other argumets Matt's making, because justin.tv is probably the most famous YC startup among my non-programming friends: we all watch live college football and european soccer games on it, re-translated by users with TV tuners.

I don't think this is something justin.tv is happy about because it kind of transforms "broadcast yourself" into "share your cable subscription with strangers" and inevitably leads to a conflict with Fox+ESPN+friends [and possibly with cable/sat. providers too]

It all comes down to bandwidth. It doesn't exist and the situation is not improving, I'm 100% with Matt here. Even ESPN's premiere 360 offering pretty much sucks, let alone Justin's streams: they're basically backups for people who don't have TV access (on the road, in another country, etc).

Security-minded, TCP-dominant, firewalled to death "Big Internet" is simply the wrong platform to stream live HD video. Having worked at an IP-based HD video surveillance startup I was amazed at how hard it was to reliably push high-def streams over TCP/IP even within a large local enterprise network. Most of our IP was all about bandwidth management. I honestly can't even imagine what would it take to stream even CNN to all their viewers, let alone superbowl.

Re:Why TV Lost by DomesticMouse on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @06:34PM (#502230)
Broadcast has bandwidth. Computers have brains. Why are these two competing? Broadcasting a signal that means something to computers, and having computers then marshal that for users is way more profitable.

Easy place to start - start hiring a small TV station for an hour in the morning, somewhere in amongst the informercials, and broadcast a signal that people with TV Tuners can decode. Using some variation of colour 3D barcodes, say. Have the TV Tuner decode software use this hour to pump content into squid or some other form of web cache.

Monetisation strategy: give people the ability to vote on what gets broadcast based on their cache logs.

Re:Why TV Lost by tjmc on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @08:50PM (#502397)
Bittorrent does the same thing more easily, but neither works for live broadcasts. The technical solution to the HD bandwidth issue is probably ISP level multicast, but they'd still only be able to deliver the most popular content, making them effectively "a la carte" cable companies.

Perhaps a frame based variation on the bittorrent protocol is the way to go, where you're constantly torrenting sequential blocks of content and viewing with a slight delay. I think people would find that acceptable for live events that aren't popular in their current location, but broadcast is still superior for mass appeal content.

Re:Why TV Lost by wmf on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @07:06PM (#502274)
Re:Why TV Lost by sketerpot on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @06:54PM (#502255)
Sounds like a lot of work compared to using Hulu or BitTorrent. The Internet bandwidth costs more, sure, but it's convenient. Lazy wins.
Re:Why TV Lost by DomesticMouse on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @07:10PM (#502277)
Where there is a price difference, there is an arbitrage opportunity. Sure it's a bunch of work, but it only has to be done once. With something like software radio it can even be invisible to the end user. It becomes a usb dongle that feeds them high def youtube et al.
Re:Why TV Lost by madh on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @06:08PM (#502190)
Does this mean that typical cable (e.g. comcast) or fiber (e.g. FiOS) networks have more bandwidth than the internet? Or is this just a multicast vs unicast thing?
Re:Why TV Lost by wmf on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @07:07PM (#502275)
Both; cable networks have about 5Gbps AFAIK and it is broadcast to all customers.
Re:Why TV Lost by Mazy on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @08:29PM (#502370)
Justin.TV is quantified: http://www.quantcast.com/justin.tv

including embedded players: http://www.quantcast.com/p-16uNVwiyGoWyg

Also, some real-time data: http://live.justin.tv/

Re:Why TV Lost by aswanson on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @08:49PM (#502395)
Those numbers have M after them. As in million. I never thought this would have ever worked. 100 percent convinced JTv was on a course with obscurity. Tell the honest to god truth -- weren't you?
Re:Why TV Lost by Mazy on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @09:20PM (#502424)
It is very cool that so many people are using the site, the problem though seems to be that the majority of the traffic is for illegal content. They have shown cases of big legitimate use, like the Jonas Brothers web chats, and the Keke Palmer web chat, however day-to-day it seems to be for sports, TV shows, and movies.
Re:Why TV Lost by whughes on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @05:05PM (#502099)
While I admire what justin.tv is doing, I think that in a way it's arrogant of the "Web 2.0"/Silicon Valley community to dismiss TV so quickly. Silicon Valley and the kinds of people who are adopting justin.tv are not the people who are watching TV in droves right now. I seriously doubt justin.tv commands the viewership in the tens or hundreds of millions that normal television does at its peak.
Re:Why TV Lost by pg on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @05:20PM (#502122)
The people watching Justin.TV are not sophisticated Silicon Valley early adopters, believe me. And while nothing streamed online has the numbers of TV yet, I believe Justin.TV's numbers are as big as anything else online.
Re:Why TV Lost by tommyx on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @10:40PM (#502496)
It's doing exactly what Stage6 did. Stage6 had amazing growth. The problem was that it was entirely fueled by the fact that they were hosting high quality pirated content. It's like standing on a street corner and handing out DVD rips of the latest movies for free. Of course you're going to be popular. Anyone with the balls and money to blow could do it, but why would they? It's a total gamble that you're going to sell the company before you get sued out of business.
Re:Why TV Lost by mattmaroon on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @09:58PM (#502461)
There's still a tremendous gulf between Justin.tv and a live telecast of a sports game or award show. Not that what they've accomplished isn't impressive, but it isn't what most people would refer to as live tv.
Re:Why TV Lost by apsec112 on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @04:22PM (#502026)
For the poor man's version, just check Alexa:

http://www.alexa.com/data/details/traffic_details/justin.tv

Re:Why TV Lost by pg on Tuesday March 03, 2009 @05:22PM (#502125)
The actual growth is steeper. I think few of their users have the Alexa toolbar installed.