News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by algoth1 on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:02PM (#50189807)
I wonder if the author is one of those people that doesn't have an audible inner monologue?
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by thanhhaimai on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:43PM (#50190101)
I'm not the OP, but I think everyone might have a different definition of what "audible inner monologue" mean.

For example, I don't talk to myself in "monologue". But I can close my eyes or stare at the screen and visualize the solutions. The words that I usually tell myself during that are "what?", "why?", "strange!", "really",... not a monologue or sentences.

Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by pulvinar on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:12PM (#50190328)
That's my impression too, that my thoughts are a hybrid, where I'll think in a rapid sequence of whole concepts and visual flashes, and then summarize that in my inner voice "for the record", as a jumping-off point for the next batch of thoughts. But I don't have much control over this, as my inner voice is hard to shut up for any length of time, always giving a running narrative.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by FuckButtons on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:23PM (#50190397)
Yeah I’m the exact opposite, thought is almost entirely auditory.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by UltraSane on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @10:40PM (#50190512)
I'm essentially thinking out loud in my head constantly.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by avallach on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:39AM (#50192389)
Like the response from the UltraSane: my thinking is and always was 100% made of internal language-based chain of thought ("imaginary talking to myself"), with some amount of introspection / meta reasoning when problem is particularly hard. This article indeed reads to me a bit like someone proposing a physical storage medium inspired by those pictures of little squares traditionally used as "save" icon, without realizing that this digital representation was in the first place based on an existing real world thing.

Anyway, a surprising related observation is that rubber ducking by describing the problem to quiet listener still often helps me, which suggests that internal chain of thought makes intuitive shortcuts that sometimes are counter productive, while talking to another person creates subconscious pressure to make the thoughts fully complete.

Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by purplepatrick on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:48PM (#50190132)
The author says they could narrate their own thought process out loud.

I couldn’t do that. I have no insight into my thought processes whatsoever. There are no semantic (or any other) processes to witness. It’s complete crickets at all times…

My wife is the opposite - constant chatter in her head. And she can trace every thought exactly. (No idea how people like her can focus or even function!)

Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by cnees on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:56PM (#50190203)
We focus/function via the inner monologue. It doesn't just do its own thing while we're trying to focus or get something done, it walks through the issue and comes up with solutions and then criticizes them and iterates, and as far as we're concerned, that's us solving the problem.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by purplepatrick on Thursday October 22, 2026 @09:16AM (#50194897)
Who's "we"? I am not in that group...
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by zer00eyz on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @11:36PM (#50190896)
Anendophasia? Fair number of people have this.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by idiotsecant on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:07PM (#50189833)
I am such a person and I've always done 'chain of thought' in a notepad in order to think through complex things, well before LLMs were a thing. There are certainly tasks I can 'one-shot' but I've learned from experience that for some problems that just results in me focusing on irrelevant things.
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by apt-apt-apt-apt on Wednesday October 21, 2026 @09:45PM (#50190114)
Curious whether the lack of audible inner monologue is a benefit for you?

I feel like I'm the opposite, where most of my thinking is done in inner English, which feels slow. I.e. as opposed to instantly realizing the result of deep subconscious processing or something, I usually go the slow language way, if you get what I mean.

Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by avallach on Thursday October 22, 2026 @03:56AM (#50192493)
My experience: intuitive thinking it's a shortcut, but it's less reliable when it comes to complex problems, especially involving multiple concepts that have to be reasoned about with non trivial relationships or rules. In a way I see a spectrum of approaches that range from fast to reliable:

1. Intuitive thinking

2. Language based internal monologue

3. Written scratchpad

4. Explaining the problem to another person until they understand it (rubber ducking)

Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by algoth1 on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:29PM (#50197624)
5. Get the person to the point where he is be able to do point 4. A self replicating agent of sorts
Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by idiotsecant on Friday October 23, 2026 @10:20AM (#50209536)
I completely lack the 'critical self narrator' that many people report being distressed by. If I make a bad decision there is nobody 'punishing' me for it internally. I also feel like I am better than average at very stressful dangerous situations - i find that i dont particularly analyze things in the moment, or at least the conscious part i aware of doesn't. I just act on 'autopilot' if that makes sense.

It does have an enormous mountain of downsides, though.

Re:Chain of Thought for Humans by slopinthebag on Thursday October 22, 2026 @12:27AM (#50191175)
i think everyone has the same inner monologue and it's entirely a matter of how we define "monologue"