I think “it works” is a very low standard for any creative work you set out to do, professionally or as a hobby. Possibly the lowest standard. We should aim higher in all things.
He released a product, not a PCB. For him that's probably not the part where his creativity is focused on.
Re:AI-assisted PCB design for KiCad 10
by ryandrake on Saturday October 17, 2026 @03:28PM
(#50134263)
I think my attitude equates to the old Jobs saying on "finishing the back side of the cabinet." Paraphrasing: You wouldn't use crap wood on the back of the cabinet and not paint it. Of course, nobody would see it or know it was there but you'd know it was there. For you to sleep well at night, the aesthetic, the quality, has to be carried all the way through the product.
Unfortunately, that doesn't seem to be a popular ethic, particularly around here. These are the disciples of MVP and 'move fast, break things' and all the rest.
Re:AI-assisted PCB design for KiCad 10
by someguydave on Friday October 16, 2026 @12:08PM
(#50120175)
Ok good luck with taking that attitude to the marketplace
Believe it or not "it works" is actually incredibly high standard. Many commercial products are released after meeting the "I can't believe it works" threshold.
Re:AI-assisted PCB design for KiCad 10
by mapontosevenths on Friday October 16, 2026 @02:25PM
(#50122314)
FWIW - I agree, generally.
However, capitalism demands it and we all have to compete. Look at the fortune 100. How many of those companies produce finely crafted artisanal hand-made things of beauty designed to last for 100 years and be passed on for generations?
The truth is that people say they want quality, and then buy the cheapest thing they can find that works for today. It has always been, and will always be this way... At least until/unless we find ourselves in Treks post-scarcity, fully-automated, luxury communism.
In the meantime I try to apply my limited time on earth as effectively as I can, but putting the most work into the place where it will do the most good.
Re:AI-assisted PCB design for KiCad 10
by oscillonoscope on Friday October 16, 2026 @05:20PM
(#50124911)
Anyone can build a bridge that stands, it takes an engineer to build one that barely stands.
the OpenAI folks that worked on this demo include this X account w/ some further tips. https://x.com/0x50484244/status/2110189303418769839?s=20 The future is 100% not computer use in my opinion and experience
I did this months before that OpenAI demo, and produced a product that many people are using without knowing it was an AI designed PCB.
It ran using kicad completely headlessly from a terminal with a bit of python and DRC'd it in a loop until it passed. I sent it to PCBWay and it worked the first go. It did take a bit, but if you just set a goal and let 'er rip the LLM gets there in the end.
Would a real EE vomit if they looked at it? Maybe. Does it work? Absolutely.