Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by subpixel on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:09PM
(#5010736)
Hopefully Ghostery [http://www.ghostery.com/] will start tracking Referly -- I prefer to know when a site is saying nice things about an affiliate who will pay them money if they turn me into a customer.
I'm not saying all affiliate revenue is distasteful. But affiliate links that aren't identified as such are, in my opinion.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by subpixel on Friday January 04, 2013 @11:09PM
(#5011540)
Users could tell which links are affiliate if there was copy on the page making it clear that "orange links that say 'buy' are affiliate links - if you click them and make a purchase Referly will make a commission on the transaction. That's the business we're in. Thank you!"
I don't think you have anything to lose by being upfront with your audience - they'd probably appreciate it.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by alanctgardner2 on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:26PM
(#5010025)
I know it's late in the game, but is there no switch to turn it off if you're not wearing it, or you're doing something you don't want to record? It looks pretty smooth and button-less to me. That would be a major deal-breaker, in addition to the fact that 98% of my life is terribly boring, and they don't appear to offer any suggestions on how I could only record the interesting parts.
I'd be more interested in a device that buffers the last hour, and lets me store it if something important - accident, surprise party, any random, cool thing - happens. I don't need 50 billion gigs of pictures of my desk, but there are definitely times when I wish I could travel back 20 minutes and remember to take a picture.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by martinkallstrom on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:38PM
(#5010095)
You switch it off by putting it somewhere dark or flat (in your pocket, bag or on a table). If there was an on/off switch and you switched it off before going into a dressing room or similar setting where it's inappropriate to take photos, other people will still be uncomfortable. By making the the on/off switch equal to taking the camera off, we make people more comfortable with the concept of a wearable camera.
A similar line of though went into design of the camera itself. We made sure through user testing that most people recognizes it as being a camera, and not as something else. But also that it is subtle enough to not be distracting. It was a fine balance to find between the two, but with the current design most people find it appealing.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by martinkallstrom on Friday January 04, 2013 @06:01PM
(#5010517)
It takes a few frames for the camera to switch off. Even flat on your back it would be a one in a million chance that your camera ended up being perfectly still with the front axis aligned with the gravity vector for any prolonged period of time. You are breathing and shifting slightly even when relaxed.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by kordless on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:15PM
(#5010756)
A cleaner implementation would simply be monitoring the contact between the clip and the case. A shirt would toggle this to false, in your pocket would be true.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by kingkool68 on Friday January 04, 2013 @05:17PM
(#5010302)
Software can filter your 46.5661287 exabytes of pictures to guide you to the ones that are most interesting. Besides, what's important is relative and could change with future events. For example, a rather casual photo of Bill Clinton hugging Monica Lewinsky was just a throw away photo when it was taken. But after the scandal broke it became worth a fortune.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by alanctgardner2 on Friday January 04, 2013 @10:26PM
(#5011372)
See, I'm all for big data and part of me loves the idea of analyzing these frames, but I wouldn't want to do it for my life. If you could constantly go back and re-evaluate every moment of the past, I think it would drive you crazy. Hell, my friend spent 4 months organizing 1 month of photos from a holiday. If you had your whole life to work with, forever, you could just get lost in the past and never come back.
Maybe an hour is too short, but I'd definitely want things I hadn't explicitly saved to 'decay' in some way; either a rolling window, or deleting one in n frames based on some measure of interestingness - where n is a function of time. It's not just a matter of hiding the old ones, I think it would be vital to know that deleted images were really gone - to give some urgency to actually looking at them, and to reduce potential time wastage looking at thousands of unique - interesting to a machine - but unmemorable photos.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by ndrake on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:38PM
(#5010100)
From the FAQ:
"Is there an on/off button?
No. The camera will turn itself off when it is laid flat or put in a dark place, such as a pocket. Otherwise, it will be on."
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by Luff on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:43PM
(#5010130)
According to a video on memoto.com it stops taking pictures if it's placed in your pocket. I'm guessing it could be implemented by just throwing away the mostly black images anyway.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by personlurking on Friday January 04, 2013 @05:10PM
(#5010271)
Not sure this will catch. When thinking of the act of taking photos, an important part of that act is pointing and shooting in any given moment and it seems that will not be possible with the Memoto. Of course, you can unhook it, point it and wait up to 2 minutes to make sure you have the shot but it's not exactly practical. On the other hand, this isn't a replacement for pointing and shooting with a normal camera.
With more and more lifelogging devices coming, I hope someone will make a device similar in size to the Memoto that I can wear on my collar which blurs out my face when I'm being lifelogged by someone else.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by martinkallstrom on Friday January 04, 2013 @06:05PM
(#5010545)
Hi, Memoto founder here. You can in fact double-tap the camera to have it take a photo at once. It will also be bookmarked for easy retrieval. If you want a viewfinder as well, the Memoto app allows you to take photos the normal way which end up in the same timeline as the rest of your pictures.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by codex on Friday January 04, 2013 @09:03PM
(#5011084)
There are some legal issues to be aware of here.
Taking photos in a public bathroom (such as in an airport or restaurant) is illegal. Make sure you don't forget you are wearing the device as you wander around.
Photos on private property can be restricted by the property owner (shopping malls, casinos, private residences, etc.). If you do not comply, you can be kicked out and possibly charged with trespassing, and could even be injuncted or sued for damages in a civil court.
Note that video surveillance in private or semi-public places may get you in trouble with the law too. Presumably this is one reason why this device does not have a microphone--laws regarding un-consented audio capture (wiretapping) are even more severe in many states and countries.
And I hope that refer.ly gets popular, if only to reduce the level of refer.ly traction-whoring-growth-hacking here on HN.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by summerdown2 on Friday January 04, 2013 @06:47PM
(#5010689)
> All the pictures are safely stored on Memoto's remote storage service. We know what you're thinking... two photos a minute is a whole lot of photos
Apparently you don't know what I'm thinking. I was thinking that a whole host of minor crimes like reaching 35 in a 30 zone or downloading copyrighted files can suddenly be data mined. Or computer passwords. Or pin numbers off a cash point, or confidential documents like passports, or credit card numbers ...
> Will it be possible to use the camera without ever uploading any photos to Memotos cloud storage?
> Yes. You can use the camera with local storage only if you want. You will however not be able to use the data from the GPS and you will have to manage and organize all the photos yourself. The data from the GPS is not converted into a useful position in latitude and longitude until it has been processed in our cloud service.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by pcl on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:34PM
(#5010073)
> The data from the GPS is not converted into a useful position in latitude and longitude until it has been processed in our cloud service.
That doesn't sound right. Clearly, the GPS data must include latitude and longitude data. I wonder if they're doing some sort of encryption of the data, or if it's just an encoding issue or something.
EDIT: just read the answer after submitting: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5010057. That's a neat approach! Sounds like it'd be straightforward to do the same thing that their cloud service does in a non-cloud process.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by hayksaakian on Friday January 04, 2013 @05:13PM
(#5010278)
GPS data is just a series of timestamps from multiple satellites simultaneously. Making that into lat long is a typical use case, but not inherent to GPS data.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by martinkallstrom on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:31PM
(#5010057)
Memoto founder here, it's because the GPS radio data is converted to lat/long in the cloud. Before that it's just a radio sample. Normal GPS chips that compute the lat/long on the fly drains the battery very quickly since they need to wait for a fix. Which basically means that they wait to download the ephemeris of how satellites are positioned at the moment.
By offloading that computation to the cloud, it suffices to get a 200 ms snapshot of GPS radio data. It means we can have a duty cycle of about 500 ms instead of 30s or more, which is how the camera can have such an extended battery life.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by darklajid on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:52PM
(#5010181)
Cool, in all seriousness.
Why can't owners get access to the same 200 ms snapshot of data though? To post-process that in similar ways (even if it needs reinventing the wheel if you decide to consider that a closed part of your business) later?
No data would be 'lost' and you'd be about hardware and convenience (backups, automatic tagging, whatever) instead of removing a core feature of a 'memento' device for users that want to run that thing standalone/offline.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by martinkallstrom on Friday January 04, 2013 @05:57PM
(#5010502)
"Maybe" is as close as I can get to an answer right now, unfortunately. We will certainly allow developers to create cool stuff that integrates with Memoto. Either through our API or by some other means. But there are a lot of hard challenges to solve when dealing with people's private data, and it's our responsibility to take a safety-first approach to everything we do.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by darklajid on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:42PM
(#5010830)
Thanks for the answer, but you're missing (or avoiding) my point.
The poeple in this subthread seem to be interested in your product, as far as idea and hardware are concerned. Now to please the crowd that still cringes whenever someone mentions the 'cloud' you'd need to offer a way to opt out of your online services, without losing too much functionality or even data.
What is the point of any privacy argument here? If I buy that thing from you, it seems (your words) that I can access my images locally, without using the online service. How is 'can I access the data you use to compute the GPS position' any different, privacy wise? We're talking about a device that I would potentially carry around my neck after all.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by martinkallstrom on Sunday January 06, 2013 @02:17PM
(#5017341)
Memoto is a service where the photos from a lifelogging camera are organized and made searchable in an app in your smartphone. The cloud, no matter if you embrace that term or not, is inescapably needed as part of our tech chain. I think you would agree that data stored locally will always be a nuisance to make available in your phone without synching to cloud servers. What we provide is an option for you to keep a local copy of your photos, no matter if you synch it to Memoto Secure Storage or not. None of the functionality provided in our app will still work if you disable synching to the cloud.
We are receiving a constant stream of feature requests supporting different use cases. At the moment we focus on functionality that supports as many use cases as possible. To provide the same functionality with local storage would mean to duplicate everything we have developed into standalone software, and then support that forever.
Regarding the privacy aspect, if we allow third party apps to integrate to our API, we can allow the user to retain control over what those apps have access to. But if we would chose to make a development effort to allow locally stored data to be used as an integration point for third party apps, we can no longer provide that level of control. An app that turns out to be malicious can't be disabled across the entire user base, because it's probably installed as an executable on local computers.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by pcl on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:41PM
(#5010120)
That's a neat approach. Is this commonly done by other services? Is there any historical data accessible online, or do you record your own ephemeris data for all the satellites?
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by dmor on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:10PM
(#5009918)
I have to believe they'll figure out a way to do this that makes people comfortable, although obviously it it creeps you out a ton then you probably won't be an early adopter of it. I think it is so funny how people say "creepy" when in reality most of our lives are so vanilla that nothing interesting would come of it, even if someone did spy on us.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by gte910h on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:11PM
(#5009932)
I know wearing it "all the time" is out of the question for cases of catching things like casual nudity or source code that's NDAed due to this feature.
Hopefully that conflict makes them make "software in the middle" to allow you to edit before upload.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by darklajid on Friday January 04, 2013 @04:55PM
(#5010192)
I'm confused. Why would 'catching casual nudity' be a problem (unless you're unaware of the camera and think that these things don't belong in pictures, period. Do you?) here?
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by gte910h on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:13PM
(#5010746)
I don't think it's a professionally smart decision for most Americans to put naked pictures of themselves on internet sites. I include my wife and myself in that.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by darklajid on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:55PM
(#5010874)
Not my native language. What is 'casually nude'?
My contact picture (Android/Google) of my wife (with her consent, of course) reminds me daily that breastfeeding changes women.. No nudity, btw.
But picking up here, would a picture of my wife breastfeeding cross the border of 'casual nudity'? That would seriously confuse me. It seems that this device is supposed to keep memories for you. That situation is certainly very well worth keeping for me/us, ignoring the required nudity to prevent your offspring from starving..
I guess I cannot understand limits based on nudity alone, since a good deal of nice pictures I have/want to keep show a lot of skin, both mine or my wife's (again, no need for anything fancy. Naked son on naked wife is certainly a normal picture to keep and remember).
I certainly agree that I wouldn't post the majority to Facebook, of course. Bit if this product is supposed to replace other ways to keep your special moments with you, I see no way to exclude all nude content.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by gte910h on Saturday January 05, 2013 @12:55PM
(#5013361)
By "casually nude" I mean a person walking to the shower, getting dressed, changing, walking around in their underwear for some random reason etc.
The fact the device goes straight to their servers means those pictures are out of my strict control (I don't even take pictures of those things and keep pictures IN my control). So while it's not the same as publishing to facebook, if they are ever hacked, we'll, that's a total loss of control of a serious aspect of my families financial life.
Morality clauses in company rulebooks alone can make nude pictures = fired. Even if they didn't they could be humiliating to have co workers/ex associates pass them around, or new employers finding them before a job search occurs.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by madethemcry on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:05PM
(#5010730)
This project always reminds me of "The Final Cut" with Robin Williams. A somewhat disturbing near future scenario about life logging with an a brain implant and the social consequences
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by bbx on Friday January 04, 2013 @06:31PM
(#5010644)
I've always wished for a device that would seamlessly log the things that I do, but in a text format. I'd call it "Log of my life" (and I hear the Queen song "Love of my life" when I think about it).
It wouldn't take pictures like the Memoto but rather keep track of the places I've been (restaurants, museums, bars, cities) and the stuff I've read, listened to, or watched. I love lists, just plain lists. I already manage lists of books, articles, albums, tracks and films, but I use a Google Document for that and it something is hard to remember everything.
I don't know how such a device would work but I think there'd be a market for that.
Re:With Memoto, Affordable Passive Lifelogging Has Arrived
by ommunist on Friday January 04, 2013 @07:22PM
(#5010774)
This is a creepy device idea. Imagine someone with 24/365 access to your data and some ideas of enhancing your life or redirecting it to someone's purpose. Automagically, like the software does.
I'm not saying all affiliate revenue is distasteful. But affiliate links that aren't identified as such are, in my opinion.
I don't think you have anything to lose by being upfront with your audience - they'd probably appreciate it.
I'd be more interested in a device that buffers the last hour, and lets me store it if something important - accident, surprise party, any random, cool thing - happens. I don't need 50 billion gigs of pictures of my desk, but there are definitely times when I wish I could travel back 20 minutes and remember to take a picture.
A similar line of though went into design of the camera itself. We made sure through user testing that most people recognizes it as being a camera, and not as something else. But also that it is subtle enough to not be distracting. It was a fine balance to find between the two, but with the current design most people find it appealing.
http://www.worldsfamousphotos.com/2008/10/15/bill-clinton-hu...
In conclusion, photograph all of the things and worry about analyzing it later.
Maybe an hour is too short, but I'd definitely want things I hadn't explicitly saved to 'decay' in some way; either a rolling window, or deleting one in n frames based on some measure of interestingness - where n is a function of time. It's not just a matter of hiding the old ones, I think it would be vital to know that deleted images were really gone - to give some urgency to actually looking at them, and to reduce potential time wastage looking at thousands of unique - interesting to a machine - but unmemorable photos.
"Is there an on/off button? No. The camera will turn itself off when it is laid flat or put in a dark place, such as a pocket. Otherwise, it will be on."
With more and more lifelogging devices coming, I hope someone will make a device similar in size to the Memoto that I can wear on my collar which blurs out my face when I'm being lifelogged by someone else.
Taking photos in a public bathroom (such as in an airport or restaurant) is illegal. Make sure you don't forget you are wearing the device as you wander around.
Photos on private property can be restricted by the property owner (shopping malls, casinos, private residences, etc.). If you do not comply, you can be kicked out and possibly charged with trespassing, and could even be injuncted or sued for damages in a civil court.
Note that video surveillance in private or semi-public places may get you in trouble with the law too. Presumably this is one reason why this device does not have a microphone--laws regarding un-consented audio capture (wiretapping) are even more severe in many states and countries.
And I hope that refer.ly gets popular, if only to reduce the level of refer.ly traction-whoring-growth-hacking here on HN.
I'm very excited for mine. I don't anticipate wearing it everywhere, but for vacations it will be fantastic.
Apparently you don't know what I'm thinking. I was thinking that a whole host of minor crimes like reaching 35 in a 30 zone or downloading copyrighted files can suddenly be data mined. Or computer passwords. Or pin numbers off a cash point, or confidential documents like passports, or credit card numbers ...
> Will it be possible to use the camera without ever uploading any photos to Memotos cloud storage?
> Yes. You can use the camera with local storage only if you want. You will however not be able to use the data from the GPS and you will have to manage and organize all the photos yourself. The data from the GPS is not converted into a useful position in latitude and longitude until it has been processed in our cloud service.
That doesn't sound right. Clearly, the GPS data must include latitude and longitude data. I wonder if they're doing some sort of encryption of the data, or if it's just an encoding issue or something.
EDIT: just read the answer after submitting: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5010057. That's a neat approach! Sounds like it'd be straightforward to do the same thing that their cloud service does in a non-cloud process.
By offloading that computation to the cloud, it suffices to get a 200 ms snapshot of GPS radio data. It means we can have a duty cycle of about 500 ms instead of 30s or more, which is how the camera can have such an extended battery life.
Why can't owners get access to the same 200 ms snapshot of data though? To post-process that in similar ways (even if it needs reinventing the wheel if you decide to consider that a closed part of your business) later?
No data would be 'lost' and you'd be about hardware and convenience (backups, automatic tagging, whatever) instead of removing a core feature of a 'memento' device for users that want to run that thing standalone/offline.
Impossible? Will never happen? Maybe?
The poeple in this subthread seem to be interested in your product, as far as idea and hardware are concerned. Now to please the crowd that still cringes whenever someone mentions the 'cloud' you'd need to offer a way to opt out of your online services, without losing too much functionality or even data.
What is the point of any privacy argument here? If I buy that thing from you, it seems (your words) that I can access my images locally, without using the online service. How is 'can I access the data you use to compute the GPS position' any different, privacy wise? We're talking about a device that I would potentially carry around my neck after all.
We are receiving a constant stream of feature requests supporting different use cases. At the moment we focus on functionality that supports as many use cases as possible. To provide the same functionality with local storage would mean to duplicate everything we have developed into standalone software, and then support that forever.
Regarding the privacy aspect, if we allow third party apps to integrate to our API, we can allow the user to retain control over what those apps have access to. But if we would chose to make a development effort to allow locally stored data to be used as an integration point for third party apps, we can no longer provide that level of control. An app that turns out to be malicious can't be disabled across the entire user base, because it's probably installed as an executable on local computers.
http://research.microsoft.com/apps/pubs/default.aspx?id=1726...
Hopefully that conflict makes them make "software in the middle" to allow you to edit before upload.
My contact picture (Android/Google) of my wife (with her consent, of course) reminds me daily that breastfeeding changes women.. No nudity, btw.
But picking up here, would a picture of my wife breastfeeding cross the border of 'casual nudity'? That would seriously confuse me. It seems that this device is supposed to keep memories for you. That situation is certainly very well worth keeping for me/us, ignoring the required nudity to prevent your offspring from starving..
I guess I cannot understand limits based on nudity alone, since a good deal of nice pictures I have/want to keep show a lot of skin, both mine or my wife's (again, no need for anything fancy. Naked son on naked wife is certainly a normal picture to keep and remember). I certainly agree that I wouldn't post the majority to Facebook, of course. Bit if this product is supposed to replace other ways to keep your special moments with you, I see no way to exclude all nude content.
The fact the device goes straight to their servers means those pictures are out of my strict control (I don't even take pictures of those things and keep pictures IN my control). So while it's not the same as publishing to facebook, if they are ever hacked, we'll, that's a total loss of control of a serious aspect of my families financial life.
Morality clauses in company rulebooks alone can make nude pictures = fired. Even if they didn't they could be humiliating to have co workers/ex associates pass them around, or new employers finding them before a job search occurs.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0364343/
It wouldn't take pictures like the Memoto but rather keep track of the places I've been (restaurants, museums, bars, cities) and the stuff I've read, listened to, or watched. I love lists, just plain lists. I already manage lists of books, articles, albums, tracks and films, but I use a Google Document for that and it something is hard to remember everything.
I don't know how such a device would work but I think there'd be a market for that.