News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by Melatonic on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:11PM (#50036101)
True but imagine you're in the same home for 30 years. That home with somewhat affordable property taxes could double in value and now you owe double the tax. With no real increase in useable income unless you sell
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by saxonww on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:47PM (#50036469)
That's just property taxes in a nutshell, though. We periodically see discussions about land value taxes and it's a feature of those as well; proponents shrug and point out that you didn't do anything to earn that extra value so it doesn't belong to you anyway.

I'm not taking a position here other than to say I don't believe there is a universally acceptable tax. Every tax I've ever read about or experienced personally, someone has made a valid argument for why it leads to a bad outcome or is otherwise unfair. You have to decide what gets priority, pick the system that matches that, and then be honest about where you're making tradeoffs and why.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by hirako2000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:22PM (#50037322)
But property tax is just absurd.

The property was purchased with "after tax" money. So at purchase date the value was already taxed.

If one sells, and make a profit, we tax that profit. Why ask for a tax on the value of the property, each year.

There should be local taxes, and there are. To fund services and whatnot of course. But taxing a percent of the current value of a property is unfair as the owner may live in there with no intention to sell and potentially no revenue whatsoever.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by pengstrom on Saturday October 10, 2026 @06:40PM (#50037896)
Isn't all money "after tax" though? It all goes around. The exception would maybe be the treasury minting loans.

Everything is unfair. The housing crisis is unfair. Young families struggling to afford a family home is unfair. Having to pay into a pension system you'll never get to use is unfair. Land and housing is different from personal property. There's only so much to go around and we'll have to share. A property tax is one tool to incentivize efficient allocation, and to drive prices down.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by hirako2000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @08:18PM (#50038449)
The idea is to tax on income..income gets spent. You earn more and get taxed on "new income".

The concept of taxing what's already taxed has some perverse effects.

I concede though that property tax in the U.S is just a way for local authorities to be able to fund schools, and other municipal infrastructure. It remains odd though that most countries do have local taxes, but summing to a fraction of what a ~1% tax every year may represent. As it's a small percentage but on the most valuable and critical asset one may have sacrificed during his life, to own a roof as primary residence.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by blks on Sunday October 11, 2026 @04:22AM (#50040814)
The earned income/purchase paid tax only once, while the housing needs infrastructure to be maintained all the time. So some way to collect these (rising) fees is needed.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by larkost on Saturday October 10, 2026 @06:54PM (#50037981)
Why is it unfair to tax a property that is receiving services at a rate proportional to its value? One part of the value of the police service this is paying for is for protecting your property, and certainly that is more valuable the more valuable your property is.

And one value of property taxes (one that is dysfunctional on empty lots) is that it encourages "maximum" use of high value property (lots of bad particulars here, but the overall direction is about right). While we may dislike an elderly person being effectively forced out of the home they have lived in for decades, it is usually for more "productive" uses (for the market definition of productive).

As an example my in-laws have three properties in Hungary that are empty, and have been for quite a few years. Cumulatively they get something like ten weeks of use in a year. But since Hungary does not have property taxes there is almost no incentive to make better use of these properties (yes, they could rent them out for an advantage, but there is no disadvantage pushing them to sell).

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by hirako2000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @08:26PM (#50038495)
The argument of empty lots imo doesn't hold. See NYC and other cities where all homeless could be housed in currently sitting empty properties.

It is a problem though, I doubt a property tax is a solution, the proof is, it doesn't solve it.

I wouldn't be against taxing owners on their income, including dividends. To fund municipalities.

My argument isn't that taxes are bad. Public services need funding. Rather, that certain taxes are absurd.

If anything, this particular tax serves one thing that the working class on rental denounces: prime real estate neighborhoods typically are better policed, have better schools, and better infrastructure than what we call "poorer" area.

Edit: I don't imply it is due solely to this tax, but the concept of taxing properties imo makes redistributions naturally or cynically more localized to areas where more gets collected.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by matwood on Sunday October 11, 2026 @03:47AM (#50040597)
> But property tax is just absurd.

The value of that land relies on all of the ongoing services provided around the land. Go look at the value and taxes on land that has zero services (no road, power, water, sewage, maintenance, etc...) and you'll understand the difference.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by jjav on Sunday October 11, 2026 @12:30PM (#50044979)
> Why ask for a tax on the value of the property, each year.

A fair system is to allow an exemption up to the value of a modest home in the area. So anyone owning a modest home (or less) pays no property tax, which is far to the poor. And those who can afford homes many multiples higher in cost, pay increasing taxes on the difference.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by eks391 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:45PM (#50036451)
I haven't researched national stats, but from the experience of having lived in two states, one blue and one red in case that's important to a counter-argument, both limited property tax to 3% annual growth, even if the valuation is higher, preventing that exact scenario. It only jumped to tax on the correct valuation when the property exchanges owners.

Sure this doesn't prevent issues if someone is stuck on savings/Social Security, etc., but it prevent surprises, such as a boom in your area causing sudden explosion of equity and taxes due.

The cap required it be your residency, i.e. you aren't renting it out and you are a citizen.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by hirako2000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:18PM (#50037293)
3% yearly compounds to doubling the value in 24 years.

So even with the cap, it's more than likely the property tax costs a typical owner more than double what it did 30y ago.

Not a big deal if you bought at age 20 (unlikely) and still receive some work income. But if you are retired, it stings harder each year.

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by eks391 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:53PM (#50037565)
Again I can't speak for every principality across the board, but for the places I have lived, it seemed very fair. Regarding your concern, I might have been unclear, but when I said "limited property tax to 3% annual growth", I meant it can be lower, but doesn't exceed 3%. It adjusts with inflation unless inflation is over 3%, so no matter what, the owner is winning if it is their primary residence, with the caveats I previously mentioned.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by hirako2000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @08:28PM (#50038508)
I agree. I forgot inflation.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by bluecheese452 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:42PM (#50037480)
Inflation adjusted though it is like a 10% increase.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by hirako2000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @08:28PM (#50038505)
Good point, I admit. The cap does keep the rate close, or even lower in times like the recent years.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by lazyasciiart on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:46PM (#50036458)
Property taxes are not that simple, usually. E.g caps on growth of total property tax receipts or on increase per year, rebates, other schemes.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by wat10000 on Saturday October 10, 2026 @05:51PM (#50037552)
The typical way property taxes are done in the US is that the local government first sets a revenue amount, then a tax rate is determined which produces that much revenue. You don’t have a situation where property values double and the local government automatically ends up with double the tax revenue.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by nasmorn on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:44PM (#50036440)
The government should need to accept its 2% in kind. I guess by the time people cannot pay these taxes any more they are much closer than 50 years to their eventual death. Thus it only reduces eventual inheritance. Problem solved
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by lazyasciiart on Saturday October 10, 2026 @03:50PM (#50036495)
Most of the problem solved, but does mean that generational wealth transfer stops being a way to climb out of instability. Just another chip in American class mobility.
Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by 8note on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:36PM (#50036907)
you could rent out a room though?

but you also have a much improved quality of life as a result of that property value going up, because theres more desirable stuff around

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by majormajor on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:38PM (#50036925)
Being stressed about finding the money to make your payments is probably not a much improved quality of life. And they probably picked the place cause they liked it as it was, so don't be so sure about appreciation of those new developments anyway...

Why should I get to have that sort of externality on others just because I have more money than them?

Re:I would like the value of my home to rise, while my prope... by sagarm on Saturday October 10, 2026 @04:52PM (#50037054)
People refinance all the time.