One can also argue that, exactly because there is the right to self-determination, there is a huge need for a inter-national and super-national organism to ensure that a right of some country doesn't jeopardise the rights of others.
Is the ICC the right organism? Maybe, maybe not; we can argue about that.
Which is a long way of saying, there’s a consensus that there are standards higher than national law we may want to uphold.
I know ICC is later, and also US never joined, in a somewhat hypocritical compromise. But at least the purpose and motivation, IMO, are clean and noble.
That being said, sanctioning them feels a bit odd. Might be some latent jingoism but I don't see a threat from the ICC being substantial to US citizens.
The Elephant in The Room is that this is announced at the Nobel Peace Prize Winner with a relationship with the ICC studied the horrific conditions in Gaza.
That is what is happening here.
This is not a subtle ideological argument about 'international law'.
That is not the Elephant, it's a 'helpful reminder'.
The Elephant is the UN / Peace Prize / Gaza / Vengeance Politics / AIPAC directed foreign policy.
You'd be surprised. People aware of such nuances are usually a very small minority in any room.
Complain about the geopolitics, call out humans for where we have gotten, maybe even take some responsibility for it. But calling out one player for the sake of self gratification will either replace that player with a different one, not change the way we have decided to govern.
The world as we know it, chose them because they were a model for democracy and freedom from religion; Obviously not model without massive flaws though. The world had accepted that as long as their model would improve over time but not when they decide to become more corrupt, run religious wars and try to overtly use and abuse other nations for their own gain. Abusive models are not one that should attract alliances.
As for Arab / Israeli conflict, it has many causes and one is a proxy war between two major religions using a third one as their proxy goat in our timeline but it has been ongoing for centuries now. A second cause is a proxy war between socialists and non-socialists that is ongoing and guess which side religiosity takes; both side of conflict religions are involved. So you have a world court that is product of that.
The solution may not be simple but it is obvious, accepting socialism as a valid form of governance and stop running conflicts against it and condemning religious dogma and improving the models for democracy that work on reduction of corruption and conflict and working for interest of all the population.
If you ask me , what would take to stop Arab/ Israeli conflict forever, I would say that the solution would be for Egypt to accept Gaza a province and allow for human movements within it but they wont because this is a religious conflict and both major religions have pawns. The world court can not rule on solutions.
Not sure it's logical but I would say there are millenia of history to show the trend, and more so there is no logic or evidence to show American freedom has been in good faith (many were slaughtered satisfying manifest destiny).
FWIW I'm not anti-America. But I am anti-idealist (and as above, I see no reason to believe America idealist) since there is nothing to show ideals actually hold up. For humans to live together, it's better to acknowledge this and create "logical" frameworks rather than rely on idealism.
That’s a bit of a americacentric view
It's normal for times to change and finally cracks are showing in American hegemony (AI dominance will either make or break it). But ignoring that is just ignoring reality.
Now, as it happens, the US is one of the most economically and militarily powerful states out there, so they're the closest we have to an actual world police - but again, that police doesn't follow "international law", they act in what they think is the best interest of the West (or the US specifically). That's how all regional powers roll, albeit on a smaller scale. Russia and China make claims to neighboring states, Germany unceremoniously protects its economic interests in the EU, Iran bankrolls terrorists in neighboring states who in turn bomb Iran, and so on.
The ICC is a bit unusual in that it's an initiative of some Western states trying to get the most powerful state to play by their rules. It's a nice try, but also... obviously doomed? And it's not something the US can ignore, because the court does assert the authority to arrest and try US servicemen and politicians. So this was kinda inevitable, and if you think the sanctions are bad, consider the bipartisan Hague Invasion Act of 2002: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Service-Members%27_Pr...