News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by tednoob on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:19AM (#49975674)
If they are intelligent and curious, imagine if they let us come tell them tales of the world, works of fiction, musings of space, what if they swim around just letting us tell them of all the fascinating things we find out. Humanity may travel the cosmos, only to come home to tell our whale friends everything we learned. I wonder if there will be a whale someday with the dream of going to space.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by acidhousemcnab on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @07:13AM (#49976840)
They will say "no no, there's no problems we're having with pollution, and we think AI Godtech supremacy is a wonderful idea, and you should definitely pour all of humanities resources into going into space, and liquidate anyone who defies you".
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by Bluestein on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @07:37AM (#49977008)
There's some sort of almost obligatory Star Trek reference lurking here :)
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by elgertam on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:42AM (#49977560)
"The sounds, but not the language. We'd be responding in gibberish."

Granted those were humpbacks (whales, not people).

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by sehugg on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:16AM (#49977989)
It'd be funny if Kirk just sent the gibberish and it worked and they could have skipped the time travel
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by Bluestein on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:18AM (#49978009)
"Gibberish ... gibberish is our business!" - said Kirk vehemently ...
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:31AM (#49978179)
That wasn't until the late 24th century, after they adopted technobabble and then held on to it while letting go of the consultants keeping it coherent and plausible. In Kirk's time, they just put "Space" in front of everything. "Space madness", "Space baby", ...
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by Derberino on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:58AM (#49976330)
Well I hope not, the might finally transform to a petunia plant, which will end bad as we all know
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @04:48AM (#49975917)
That is not going to happen. I don't know how people entertain these absurd ideas about animal communication.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by dannyw on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:57AM (#49976316)
Crows can remember a human face for 17 years, and pass this knowledge through their murder (group).

We know animals communicate with each other, and the trend is we generally discover more and have underestimated what many animal species practice and can do.

Everyone agrees that homo sapiens and homo neanderthalensis have talked together and lived (and bred) together; what makes inter-species communication (assuming a translator or device) impossible?

No, I don’t think “universal translators” are outside the domain of science fiction; but I think us building a device that enables two-way communication between one species and us, is probably more likely than not.

[1]: https://urban.uw.edu/news/crows-hold-grudges-against-individ...

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by k7peak on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:32AM (#49976576)
I pissed off a crow once, not a good idea. It got its revenge and it was crazy how its murder group would destroy my property. Luckily they have moved on but I make friends with them now and understand them much better.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by Bluestein on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @07:39AM (#49977030)
There's a classic "This American Life" episode along those lines. Poor sap ended up wearing a fake beard and glasses on the back of his head just be be able to leave the house. Bonkers.-
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by rightbyte on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:53AM (#49977685)
I miss the specifics of what you did to deserve your fate in the story :)
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:25AM (#49976532)
I think you are very naïve about how complicated language is. I'm not saying animals lack any intelligence whatsoever, but I don't see how remembering faces means you'll be able to talk. The crows could just have acted hostile to the masked people in front of each other. Communicating is not the same thing as language which is vastly more expressive than any non-human animal is capable of.

Not everyone agrees that Neanderthals possessed language like us either, although evidently they are much, much closer evolutionarily to us than crows or whales, and it is vastly more plausible that they talked. Having Neanderthal DNA doesn't mean that we talked with them though, it needn't have been even consensual, unfortunately.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by reverius42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @07:00AM (#49976752)
Lots of animals communicate with each other, I think we agree. If we can automatically translate their communicative utterances into English (or any other utterances that we understand), in general, that would be remarkable, and useful! Who cares whether those utterances qualify as "language".
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @07:43AM (#49977055)
My whole point is what we could communicate would be profoundly limited. It's like how we can communicate with dogs to a certain extent, but we're not telling them bedtime stories. The comment I responded to originally is fantasising an absurd degree of complexity in communication which is profoundly unrealistic.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:33AM (#49978215)
Communication is a two-way street, with both parties negotiating and evolving some "communication protocol" over time. We won't know how far we'll be able to go until we're able to try.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:09AM (#49978762)
There are people doing experiments with pet buttons - one-sound samplers that play a voice recording when the pet paws the button.

They're pretty damn interesting. Cats sometimes think hard about their responses. And they use metaphors. And express emotions.

There's always the suspicion this is a fake marketing exercise. But if it is, it's a very ornate and extended one.

I have no idea how we're supposed to communicate with aliens if we can't communicate with other mammals.

"They're really stupid and can't do calculus or invent FTL travel" isn't much of an excuse.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:44AM (#49979295)
Have you ever heard of Clever Hans?
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by reverius42 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:00PM (#49984733)
I think we learned the wrong lesson from Clever Hans, which is that animals don't communicate and it's always the human handler doing it.

The real lesson we should have learned is that horses are stupid and we should have been testing a Border Collie.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @03:32PM (#49982928)
I think we rarely even try.

Except when we do, but it doesn't make for flashy press releases. Pet owners, vets, farmers throughout history - anyone who lives alongside animals, cares for them, and is open to developing an emotional relationship with them, knows animals are more than just small finite state machines made of meat. But it takes time to spot and learn the patterns of behavior, and as I said, it's a two-way street; the animal has to "open up" and learn you as much as you have to learn them.

It is a kind of thing that's difficult to cleanly verify and reproduce, and it's also kinda mundane. The cases that made headlines look like Clever Hans the other commenter mentioned.

I imagine that a better classifier, some general AI system that gets to learn and observe the animals, would be able to tease out the patterns and then translate them to English, and then that would be reproducable and make for flashy headlines.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by wrsh07 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:26AM (#49979045)
Language and written language are themselves technologies that change what individuals can do (and thus impact their societies)

There is a well-known story about this discussed in Radiolab [2010] https://radiolab.org/podcast/91725-words/transcript

Here's ChatGPT summarizing one section:

> Younger signers had developed a richer vocabulary for mental states—concepts like believe, remember, forget, understand. They were much better than the original older signers at tasks requiring them to reason about what another person thinks or knows. Later, as the older signers picked up those mental-state terms from younger people, some of them improved on the same tests. Senghas describes it as language giving them new insight into other people’s thinking and motivations.

I see several likely stories:

* Much animal communication is practical, descriptive of the present (nothing abstract, or very few abstract concepts)

* If a species could expand its communication, it would give it more powerful tools and allow for more meaningful conversation with humans

* If such a thing is possible, it will be extremely disruptive to that species

I think if you could communicate about abstract ideas with your dog, you could exchange bedtime stories. However, I don't think such a thing is possible today, and it's not clear what species (if any, besides humans) will, in fact, be able to learn such things

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:43AM (#49979283)
Nicaraguan sign language is evidence for an innate language capacity, not that it is an invented technology and certainly not evidence for Sapir Whorf.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by wrsh07 on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:16PM (#49981399)
Evidence for vs compatible with are different things, and agreed!

I don't think it's particularly controversial to say "written language is a meaningful technology advancement for a civilization", though!

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by kakacik on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:42AM (#49976230)
Very confident statements when know practically nothing substantial in this topic
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:19AM (#49978017)
Which ideas, specifically, are absurd by your reckoning?
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by netsharc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:13PM (#49980606)
In this scene from The Fifth Element, she's an alien: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JVaXZ9Jl1g
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:21PM (#49980687)
I am not sure what a fictional film has to do with the discussion here.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by netsharc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:11PM (#49984856)
Imagine trying to explain to animals the story behind those images. You'd have to explain human concepts like ego, greed, brutality (the ability to dehumanize others), technological development of weapons, up to nuclear weapons...

And the main comment thinks the whales will have the brains to understand something like space travel or why we desire it?

Then again, you give me an inkling what humans trying to talk to whales will be faced with.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @09:25AM (#49992510)
>Then again, you give me an inkling what humans trying to talk to whales will be faced with.

Because I think your analogy is piss poor? Sorry to have contradicted you, Omniscient One! Get the fuck off your high horse, you're nothing special and that was downright offensive and absolutely uncalled for.

If a species has the cognitive capacity that would be required for a language akin to ours (or even more complex than it?) then why do you assume that they wouldn't have concepts like ego, greed, brutality? We already know that animals use tools; what is a weapon but a tool for the purpose of brutality?

Your example of teaching an alien all of humanity in 5 minutes, though: it's silly, and I don't think anyone in the debate here (except, you, apparently) expects that we are going to meld minds with whales in that short a time.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:00PM (#49980443)
The entire comment? Do you think it's plausible that we will be able to explain space travel to whales?
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:18PM (#49980658)
I don't speak whale, so it is hard to make a claim. I am sure linguists can estimate the complexity of an animal's utterances with the help of machine learning, using quantitative tools like Zipf's Law, Menzerath's Law, Conditional Shannon Enropy, and Repertoire Size.

Whale and Dolphin "languages" (or substitute "utterances" if the hypothesis is so antithetical to you) score remarkably complexly, close to Human "utterances" (again, if animal language is so offensive a notion) on some of these measures. Dog utterances do not:

Zipf's Law (Data Efficiency) • Humans: -1.0 slope showing an optimal balance of information and physical effort. • Whales & Dolphins: -1.0 slope matching the exact mathematical curve of human speech. • Dogs: No -1.0 slope, heavily skewed toward isolated, repetitive alert spikes.

Menzerath's Law (Physical Pacing) • Humans: Present; internal sounds get shorter as the total sequence grows longer. • Whales & Dolphins: Present; highly efficient pacing across multiple species. • Dogs: Absent; vocalizations lack the structured phrase sequences required for this law.

Shannon Entropy (Predictability) • Humans: High; complex grammatical dependencies stretch across long sentences. • Whales & Dolphins: Moderate-High; governed by structural rules and click patterns. • Dogs: Very Low; individual sounds are isolated events with no grammatical rules.

Repertoire Size (Signal Diversity) • Humans: Infinite vocabulary built from tens of thousands of words. • Whales & Dolphins: High diversity with hundreds of whistles and thousands of clicks. • Dogs: Very small vocal pool limited to roughly 10 distinct sounds.

I'd say, it's difficult to say, but calling the hypothesis of whale language "absurd" sounds like something someone might have said (and still might say, incorrectly) about the concept of evolution by natural selection. I think you are overselling your argument.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by famouswaffles on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:47PM (#49981775)
Maybe ? I know you're trying to make a distinction between communication and language which is fair but all signs we have point to there being a distinct possibility that one of our ocean friends, in the whale and/or cetacean class do have language. It's nowhere near as absurd as you're making out.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by sebastianconcpt on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:29AM (#49977419)
The adventures they must be having and things they observed would feel unreal to us.

And of course I can't wait to have the cat translator. That's a big startup idea BTW, just a bit too early still.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by luxcem on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:41AM (#49977554)
If they are intelligent they should fear and avoid humans as we killed so many of them and other species in the oceans.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by nkoren on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:00AM (#49977768)
I suspect they're more intelligent than that. By, like, a lot.

When I was a teenager, I took a rowboat out onto what was then called Scammon's Lagoon, in Baja California, where the Grey whales raise their young. A mother whale -- several times the size of our boat -- and her calf approached. The calf was curious but cautious, so the mother nudged it into approaching the boat, close enough that we could reach over and rub its nose, which everyone on the boat did in turns.

What did the whales get out of this? Certainly nothing tangible -- nobody was feeding them or anything like that. But if you've ever rubbed a wild baby whale's nose while looking at it in the eyes -- and experienced the emotional connection which results -- then you will be forever incapable of hostility, apathy, or utilitarian thinking about whales.

I'm certain the mother whale knew what she was doing. She was recruiting us to her side. MUCH more effective, in the long term, than merely running away.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by johnkozak on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @11:36AM (#49980090)
How does a whale read a group of humans in a boat? A normal-shaped body underneath and a wild mess of heads and flappy things above? We are the shoggoths...
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by busssard on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:33AM (#49978217)
... this is sadly not true.

I know the story of a farmer whose wife trained one of their pigs to be living inside the house like a dog. part of everyday activity. But the farmer still killed the pig at the end of the season, because it was the thing to do.

So i think the japanese might not have the same cultural appreciation for the emotional connection with "food"

its a wall many vegan and animal activists are struggling often

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by dudefeliciano on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @10:20AM (#49978925)
i am trying hard and failing to understand how your comment relates to the one you are replying to
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by black_rabbit_ on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @05:49PM (#49984608)
This sentence:

> But if you've ever rubbed a wild baby whale's nose while looking at it in the eyes -- and experienced the emotional connection which results -- then you will be forever incapable of hostility, apathy, or utilitarian thinking about whales.

Comment you're replying to is saying that this is optimistic; most people are capable of doublethink, and will quite happily "love" one individual of a species while being completely indifferent to the death and suffering of the rest of that species. I've observed the same phenomenon.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by dudefeliciano on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:52AM (#49990025)
In that comment it was the farmers wife who trained the pig to live in the house like a dog, and then the farmer himself who killed the pig.

I do agree that doublethink is widespread (just look at how we treat other humans, no need to go across species) but I think these are choices that happen on a personal level and can hardly be generalized. I know people who stopped eating octopus after seeing My Octopus Teacher, and I've seen Chinese restaurants serving dog meat. We live in a world full of contraddictions.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by busssard on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @11:32AM (#49994277)
The farmer still lived together with the pig, engaged with it etc. I dont know the exactl level of engagement, but i doubt that he simply never saw the pig as a pet. It was just so engrained that its a agricultural product at the end of the season, and that it was in its nature to be slaughtered that he didnt even question it.

I was not saying it isnt possible to be changed by such an experience, just that other drivers might override that. There is Vegan Hunters that kill deer for the stability of the ecosystem as an exotic example.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by archonis on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @08:42AM (#49991958)
>> and will quite happily "love" one individual of a species while being completely indifferent to the death and suffering of the rest of that species.

Similar to how a significant subset of the human population responds to other humans.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by nkoren on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @04:50AM (#49990009)
Idealistically, I really wish I could disagree with you.

Living in this reality, unfortunately I cannot.

So I should restate the whale story: that's the effect it had on me, and I still strongly suspect that this was intentional on the whale's part. But YMMV.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by EvanAnderson on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @02:34AM (#49989120)
I don't have a whale moment, but my manatee moment gave me feelings that are probably similar to yours re: being incapable of feeling anything but respect and awe for the aquatic mammals we share the planet with.

In the late 80s my father took me snorkeling at the Crystal River Manatee Sanctuary[0]. We rowed our boat out into the river and anchored. I jumped in and immediately spotted an adult manatee and a calf. I've always assumed it was a mother and her calf.

Judging distance under water is difficult, but I'd put them at least 40 feet away in water that might have been 12 feet deep.

The mother put herself between me and the calf surprisingly quickly. Knowing the rules I didn't approach them. I just floated there watching.

After a few moments the calf poked its head around its mother and looked at me. It felt just like a curious child peeking from behind a parent's legs. I stayed still and just watched them (thankful my father made me wear the yellow Navy surplus horseshoe collar BC that had just enough air in it to keep me afloat without the need to tread water).

My father was still getting his SCUBA gear together and hadn't jumped in yet. I think I stuck my head up and told him they were there-- I can't remember for sure-- but I know he stayed in the boat for awhile leaving me alone with the two manatees.

As I watched over the next couple of minutes both mother and calf went up for air and moved closer to me. It seemed like they were grazing along the bottom in the plants. I didn't see them eat any of the plants, but it seemed like they were nosing around in them. I definitely got the "sea cow" comparison.

The mother got close enough for me to see ugly gashes in her back from being stuck by boat motors. They weren't bloody or raw-looking, but they did look deep and painful to have acquired. Her calf's back was smooth and a lighter color.

As they proceeded past me the calf turned, swam over its mother, and approached me. I was shocked at how fast it could reorient itself and move. Again, having been told the rules, I kept my hands close to my body and didn't move. The calf bumped into my legs and rubbed against my back as it swam past. It descended and circled back around under me and rejoined its mother. They continued swimming away from me, into the murkier deeper water and down into the sanctuary where we weren't permitted to follow.

The whole thing might have lasted 5 minutes, but it really stuck with me. The memory is surely tarnished and altered, having been recalled so many times, but I definitely got bumped by a curious manatee calf whose mother was wary but didn't flee.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystal_River_National_Wildlif...

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by EvanAnderson on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @01:20PM (#49995857)
Recalling more about this experience today.

There's a monument located near the outlet of a spring on the river bottom. A photo of the monument: https://www.ardeaprints.com/manatee-monument-king-spring-182...

I couldn't visit the monument-- I hadn't learned to SCUBA dive yet. My father, who was an underwater photography enthusiast, took photos of it. The next year we transferred the photos and 8mm movie footage he shot onto VHS for me to show to my 6th grade class. I can remember him reading the inscription for the tape in a very somber voice.

> "Life must become more than the wants and needs of humans. We are not on this earth alone. If the manatee goes into extinction because the needs of humans became more important then we will have taken another step backward toward our own demise. Extinction is forever and for all." - Dr. Harvey Barnett

I'd love to find that VHS. His picture is somewhere in the mess of slides I need to eventually scan.

I'd also love to back and swim with the manatees again. Apparently their populations are doing better, though they're still at risk.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by K0balt on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @06:15AM (#49990689)
Had a similar but less intimate experience with orcas when I was working as an engineer on a fishing tender.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by embedding-shape on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @08:46AM (#49977596)
So are we (supposedly), yet we collaborate and hang out with other people.