News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @09:19AM (#49978017)
Which ideas, specifically, are absurd by your reckoning?
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by netsharc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:13PM (#49980606)
In this scene from The Fifth Element, she's an alien: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JVaXZ9Jl1g
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:21PM (#49980687)
I am not sure what a fictional film has to do with the discussion here.
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by netsharc on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @06:11PM (#49984856)
Imagine trying to explain to animals the story behind those images. You'd have to explain human concepts like ego, greed, brutality (the ability to dehumanize others), technological development of weapons, up to nuclear weapons...

And the main comment thinks the whales will have the brains to understand something like space travel or why we desire it?

Then again, you give me an inkling what humans trying to talk to whales will be faced with.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Wednesday October 07, 2026 @09:25AM (#49992510)
>Then again, you give me an inkling what humans trying to talk to whales will be faced with.

Because I think your analogy is piss poor? Sorry to have contradicted you, Omniscient One! Get the fuck off your high horse, you're nothing special and that was downright offensive and absolutely uncalled for.

If a species has the cognitive capacity that would be required for a language akin to ours (or even more complex than it?) then why do you assume that they wouldn't have concepts like ego, greed, brutality? We already know that animals use tools; what is a weapon but a tool for the purpose of brutality?

Your example of teaching an alien all of humanity in 5 minutes, though: it's silly, and I don't think anyone in the debate here (except, you, apparently) expects that we are going to meld minds with whales in that short a time.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by suddenlybananas on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:00PM (#49980443)
The entire comment? Do you think it's plausible that we will be able to explain space travel to whales?
Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by buellerbueller on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @12:18PM (#49980658)
I don't speak whale, so it is hard to make a claim. I am sure linguists can estimate the complexity of an animal's utterances with the help of machine learning, using quantitative tools like Zipf's Law, Menzerath's Law, Conditional Shannon Enropy, and Repertoire Size.

Whale and Dolphin "languages" (or substitute "utterances" if the hypothesis is so antithetical to you) score remarkably complexly, close to Human "utterances" (again, if animal language is so offensive a notion) on some of these measures. Dog utterances do not:

Zipf's Law (Data Efficiency) • Humans: -1.0 slope showing an optimal balance of information and physical effort. • Whales & Dolphins: -1.0 slope matching the exact mathematical curve of human speech. • Dogs: No -1.0 slope, heavily skewed toward isolated, repetitive alert spikes.

Menzerath's Law (Physical Pacing) • Humans: Present; internal sounds get shorter as the total sequence grows longer. • Whales & Dolphins: Present; highly efficient pacing across multiple species. • Dogs: Absent; vocalizations lack the structured phrase sequences required for this law.

Shannon Entropy (Predictability) • Humans: High; complex grammatical dependencies stretch across long sentences. • Whales & Dolphins: Moderate-High; governed by structural rules and click patterns. • Dogs: Very Low; individual sounds are isolated events with no grammatical rules.

Repertoire Size (Signal Diversity) • Humans: Infinite vocabulary built from tens of thousands of words. • Whales & Dolphins: High diversity with hundreds of whistles and thousands of clicks. • Dogs: Very small vocal pool limited to roughly 10 distinct sounds.

I'd say, it's difficult to say, but calling the hypothesis of whale language "absurd" sounds like something someone might have said (and still might say, incorrectly) about the concept of evolution by natural selection. I think you are overselling your argument.

Re:Ocean the Man Who Listens to Whales by famouswaffles on Tuesday October 06, 2026 @01:47PM (#49981775)
Maybe ? I know you're trying to make a distinction between communication and language which is fair but all signs we have point to there being a distinct possibility that one of our ocean friends, in the whale and/or cetacean class do have language. It's nowhere near as absurd as you're making out.