News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by inputmice on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:09AM (#49856185)
Author here: Indeed, 15% is fine. They do provide some services. They provide the CDN for downloading the APK. They handle sales taxes in the various countries, which would be a PITA to handle yourself. Similar-ish services like Patreon charge a fee too. The 30% they charged a couple of years back was bad. But I could live with 15% if the support were anything other than zero.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by rkangel on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:14AM (#49856231)
The problem is that it ISN'T a fee for services as it should be. Their platform power means that they can levy a tax, and they don't feel the need to do anything on exchange for that.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by lemagedurage on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:21AM (#49856284)
Yep, I'd hypothetically economically gladly build an alternative app store charging "only" 5% on app revenue. The blocker would be that Google has a hold on what store is installed by default on Android. Apple even more so. This is hardly a fair market.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by brainwad on Saturday September 26, 2026 @11:51AM (#49857674)
There are other app stores on Android, e.g. OEM ones like the Galaxy store. The latter doesn't really compete on price though - 20% cut of one time payments and 15% of subscriptions. I think the Android app stores anchor to the iOS app store prices to piggy back on Apple's monopoly power - devs are used to having to pay Apple that much, so they will not resist if you charge the same.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by xethos on Saturday September 26, 2026 @03:10PM (#49859571)
> they will not resist if you charge the same.

Sure, but they also won't generally bother if the fees are the same as the installed-on-every-device Play Store

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by brainwad on Sunday September 27, 2026 @02:22PM (#49869358)
Yeah, but they probably also won't bother even if it's free, so it's optimal for the OEMs to rent seek rather than compete.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by schubidubiduba on Saturday September 26, 2026 @05:25PM (#49860685)
All of the alternative stores are systematically disadvantaged time and time again due to Google's and Apple's near-absokute control over their respective OS. They are as anti-competitive as they are allowed to be. And the US seems incapable or unwilling to rein them in.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by philipallstar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:24AM (#49856318)
That would work because someone else "Google" is doing all the development of Android etc etc. Of course you can create a parasitic service for less.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by benoau on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:41AM (#49856461)
Google is not developing Android for the IAP fees, they're doing it to sell phones loaded with their search, advertising, browser and services. They take hundreds of billions in revenue annually from this, they are being paid several times over for that work even if they get no IAP fees.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by izacus on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:09PM (#49857861)
Google is funding Android fully from Play Store, since previous CFO the ad revenue isn't shared between parts.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by benoau on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:14PM (#49857920)
They also say they generate $57 billion ad revenue from being default search engine on iPhone, so obviously there is a cash value to being the default search (and everything else) on Android too even if their accountants can finagle reasons that doesn't contribute to Android's development costs.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by izacus on Saturday September 26, 2026 @01:07PM (#49858483)
That would then go against the wishes of people here for Google to be broken up and Android to self-fund, no? ;)
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by benoau on Saturday September 26, 2026 @01:30PM (#49858704)
If Android did belong to someone else then there could be an argument that IAP fees are funding it and subsequently required, perhaps even under less-than-competitive circumstances.

But if the court allowed, Google would be paying that company $10s of billions for the prime real estate their software, search and services enjoy and it would then be a very weak argument that only IAP funds its development. Just like it is when Google earns $100s of billions in revenue from Android now.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by b112 on Saturday September 26, 2026 @10:06AM (#49856697)
It's sad that Google has absolutely no foresight.

The speed of government is slow, incredibly slow. It's measured in election cycles. It takes government eight, twelve years to simply turn around and notice. But once it does, it's a juggernaut.

Nothing can stop it. Nothing can avert it. Nothing can prevent it. And as everybody from Facebook to Microsoft knows, once it starts moving, you're screwed.

In the US, the oil companies thought they were too big. Then the telco companies thought they were too big. What really happens is eventually people just get pissed off, and then it's too late.

Google is fast approaching that. They almost had chrome and other things ripped away from them, and now they've got requirements to have alternate play stores. If they don't turn course, and turn course blazingly fast, they're going to have their entire empire wrenched away from them.

Oh well.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by philipallstar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:03PM (#49857816)
You can already stand up an alternate store.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by mrandish on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:49PM (#49858294)
> If they don't turn course, and turn course blazingly fast, they're going to have their entire empire wrenched away from them.

Unfortunately, that's no longer the case with the app store monopolies. While Apple is under some partial enforcement on parts of their app store policies, Google managed to play the game of regulatory brinksmanship better and largely avoided that for their app store. So the regulatory powers (such as they are) have already taken their best shot and this is where we are.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by b112 on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:57PM (#49858384)
Once this starts it never ends. Regulatory action has been steadily increasing around the world, and it will continue to do so.

Juggernauts do not have to be fast. And the judge has seen Google being intractable and sneaky with alternate app stores too:

https://www.theverge.com/policy/979852/that-is-not-acceptabl...

There is now a record of this. The next action against Google, will see people pointing out each step they took to avoid compliance.

A case a year down the road about AI, will see stubborn attempts to comply like the above cited.

Google, with the gold plated shovel, digging a hole for itself. Put another way, breaking up a company typically comes after other methods don't work. Such as being sneaky and making them not work.

Or even because the required competition didn't occur, regardless of fault.

It's not over. It's a step taken, with a positive outcome, and a judge who is making sure there's follow through. Next step will be more stark.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by Brian_K_White on Saturday September 26, 2026 @05:48PM (#49860847)
I think it's best that government has a lot of inertia in general, but maybe that doesn't preclude government having sub components that can act fast within defined domains.

Like you don't want to have fundamentals and pronciples change hardly ever. So you might take a long time to create or destroy say the FDA, but the FDA could be responsible for being on top of time-sensitive FDA things.

Maybe there could even be a body whos job is only to decide if something is time -sensitive or not, allowing other bodies to move as they need to, yet not just have no limits or accountability at all even within their own domains. So a rapid action can be done, then shortly after determined it was a bad idea and undone, or partly wrong and needs adjustment, and have that all be justified by a seperate independant process that judged or agreed "this is something that needed rapid action".

I don't think we have anything so organized yet. We do have some things where a body is responsible for a domain and can act more quickly within their scope, but we also have a lot of things where we get both forms of bad, making big changes on immediate whims, and being unable to make clearly needed even small changes simply because "government is slow".

We do have some examples of a reasonable organization and heirarchy and layers, and a whole lot of not, all together at the same time.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by rpdillon on Saturday September 26, 2026 @11:15AM (#49857359)
Parasitic? Writing software for folks' devices and selling it isn't parasitic...it's just participating in the market. Weird that the overton window has moved so far that anything not built by the trillion-dollar duopoly is considered some kind of free-rider.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by philipallstar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:06PM (#49857836)
It's not weird - you've just completely misunderstood the situation. This is about the OS, which the software in question (the alternate app store) relies on, but generates no revenue for. The devices are still being sold, because their manufacturers are allowed to make money, the alternate store is allowed to make money. Only the OS maker will make no money, because that would be bad.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by arrosenberg on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:39PM (#49858182)
Ah yes, Microsoft famously never made money off of Windows.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by philipallstar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @04:03PM (#49860030)
Are you not following? The OS maker in this case is Google.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by happymellon on Sunday September 27, 2026 @04:45AM (#49864652)
Ah yes, Google historically lost money from Android.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by necovek on Saturday September 26, 2026 @01:17PM (#49858596)
You seem to imply Google was forced to open source Android or even to give it for free: sounded like it was a purely business decision to capture more of the market.

Now that they have, they are also turning around on bits of that too.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by zem on Saturday September 26, 2026 @02:47PM (#49859345)
what you are arguing for is objectively extremely bizarre. if you take a step back, this is what is playing out: company C makes a device. it needs an operating system to run software, so they add it. if there was no operating system the device would be useless and no one would buy it. now person A buys said device. it's theirs, they have paid money for it, they own it. person B writes some software. it runs on the device's operating system. they want to sell it to person A. person A wants to buy it from them. why should company C be involved at all? I found this super weird and distasteful when game consoles were allowed to use this business model, and am even more taken aback that general purpose computers get away with it.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by catlifeonmars on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:00PM (#49857776)
That trillion dollar duopoly is probably the worst case of free riders. It’s an enabler/vehicle for all the other billion dollar free riders to steal from the population.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by agsnu on Saturday September 26, 2026 @11:08AM (#49857298)
Would it be OK for Microsoft to prevent Steam from running on Windows because Valve doesn't contribute enough to funding the Experiences and Devices org? I've never really understood why mobile platforms should be different from how we think about desktop ones.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by philipallstar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:10PM (#49857878)
Only Apple is. Android supports alternate app stores, and has done since 2008. Samsung's app store for Android has been running since 2009.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by pydry on Saturday September 26, 2026 @10:03AM (#49856663)
theres nothing parasitic about a competing app store.

it is parasitic to try and prohibit competing app stores and then leverage your monopoly by charging monopoly prices.

everything google is trying to do to discourage graphene, newpipe, competing app stores, etc. is parasitic and it's right that they are being fined by the EU for this behavior.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by philipallstar on Saturday September 26, 2026 @12:12PM (#49857898)
> theres nothing parasitic about a competing app store.

I think a more honest way to say this might be: Android OS development is massively funded by Google, and the Play Store feeds into this hugely. No other store does this, so it shouldn't be surprising that they can charge a lower fee. They're just doing the easy bit.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by ajkjk on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:19AM (#49856278)
It is rent extraction which always feels like bullshit because it is. Competition is supposed to be the counterbalancing force but it barely exists here.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by Loquebantur on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:26AM (#49856343)
It doesn't exist because it can't:

The basic services Google provides can effectively only be consumed by humans individually, creating an inevitable bottleneck.

Such bottlenecks impede interchangeability of goods, as you can't reasonably entertain multiple suppliers simultaneously there. And that means, you cannot have a free market, because you can't really have meaningful competition.

Google has captured services that really are public utilities. Them being "new" doesn't play a role.

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by basch on Saturday September 26, 2026 @11:58AM (#49857751)
They also develop the OS and development platforms that the apps are built upon. The apps don’t exist on islands.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by benoau on Saturday September 26, 2026 @09:38AM (#49856440)
Apple recently submitted in court filings that you'd have to pay ~8% for off-the-shelf solutions like Stripe or Paddle to be Merchant of Record anyway so 15% isn't really bad except for the high-earning apps, but Google should be doing something for that extra 7%.
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by jeltz on Saturday September 26, 2026 @11:16AM (#49857370)
8% for Stripe? Why would anyone have to pay that when my tiny company pays 1.5%?
Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by benoau on Saturday September 26, 2026 @11:36AM (#49857537)
It's a level of service above their payment processing, where they also collect and remit certain taxes which I believe is built-in to that ~8%. This is the same service that Google and Apple provide for in-app payments.

https://stripe.com/managed-payments

This is what Apple said about it:

> Stripe and Paddle are leading full-service, turnkey payment processing, and merchant-of-record providers handling all the services necessary for link-out, including payment processing, tax compliance, fraud detection, and customer service. Across the top apps, the mean implied processing and merchant-of-record fee based on Stripe’s and Paddle’s rack rates (which few, if any, large developers actually pay because they negotiate discounts or provision in-house) is 8.1% using Stripe rates, or 7.8% using Paddle rates.

https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.36...

Re:Breaking Up with Google Play: Why Conversations Is Now Free by pbhjpbhj on Saturday September 26, 2026 @07:05PM (#49861444)
So, Google take 10x what payment providers charge to take the payments because some companies will charge you 5x what it costs and handle your taxes and accounting?