News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by margalabargala on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:35AM (#49755924)
Could this be considered a good thing?

The energy being released in these many tiny earthquakes was always going to exist in this location. Much better to release it slowly via thousands of tiny earthquakes than all at once. Better to have 10k magnitude 3 quakes than one magnitude 7.

Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by booi on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:48AM (#49756133)
It's logarithmic so you'd need more like 30,000 magnitude 3 earthquakes to equal the energy of a magnitude 7. I don't think it's clear this is better. You can also make the argument that this may trigger the large earthquake that might not have happened for a long time.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by MBCook on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:43PM (#49756910)
So even if this does release pressure with no negative side effects anywhere it isn’t actually useful for preventing “the big one”.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by sokoloff on Friday September 18, 2026 @01:07PM (#49757239)
Energy is logarithmic with magnitude, but if the underlying model is analogous to springs being loaded and suddenly released, that model is quadratic in energy with distance.

The article cites 1399 detectable follow-on earthquakes. If each of them represented a movement of earth an equal distance as compared to a single event, each of those movements would be 1/1399th in scale and therefore ~5x10^-7 in energy per event. (One two-millionth.)

I think that's clearly better.

Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by sbuttgereit on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:13PM (#49756510)
Geologic systems are more complex than this. Analyzing something like this as though it were a single system is wrought with the dangers of miscalculation.

You could locally release stresses on an incremental, short term basis this way in a local system, while at the same time increasing stresses on nearby systems which could fail even more spectacularly, especially if the increasing stresses are being moved from a less dangerous system to a more dangerous system.

I'm not suggesting the above is true in this case, but that you need to cast a pretty wide net with increasingly unknown (and perhaps unknowable) variables as you start to inject real changes into a local system and try to predict what those changes will actually do.

Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by andy_ppp on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:38AM (#49755978)
It can go either way, you might get a relief of pressure or you might get an increased destabilisation in the region.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by skeptic_ai on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:43AM (#49756072)
There isA study about fire fighting. If you shit down every fire quickly then eventually you’ll have a major black swan. If you let fires burn a bit more then you’ll avoid black swan effect that burns down everything
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by ImJamal on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:58AM (#49756291)
Are fires and earthquakes the same?
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by RugnirViking on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:42PM (#49756892)
it would appear nobody here knows. We probably ought to shut up until a seismologist decides to chime in
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by monster_truck on Friday September 18, 2026 @02:20PM (#49758171)
What would a size scientist know about fires or earthquakes anyways
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by InsideOutSanta on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:50PM (#49763145)
They'd know how big they are, obviously.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by dataflow on Friday September 18, 2026 @11:52AM (#49756199)
Have you considered logarithms?
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by taneq on Friday September 18, 2026 @03:00PM (#49758695)
I’m not sure if “let fires burn a bit more” is exactly what we’re after but hazard reduction burns are absolutely a thing and are an essential part of fire risk management. I don’t think your post deserved to get slammed like that.

The region can build up resistance to big fires by having small fires.

Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by skeptic_ai on Saturday September 19, 2026 @10:15PM (#49771941)
Yeah that’s what I’m talking about
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by wyan on Saturday September 19, 2026 @04:16AM (#49764473)
By definition, a black swan event cannot be predicted. It doesn't just mean "a larger fire" or "the event of a lifetime".
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by micromacrofoot on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:12PM (#49756509)
We are not even remotely close to being able to predict this in a way to apply it reliably. Plate tectonics and volcanology are incredibly difficult to forecast anything short-term in.
[dead]
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by genxy on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:00PM (#49756330)
Good opportunity to make a killing as all that new beachfront property opens up.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by tacomagick on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:10PM (#49756477)
Before Blackrock buys and sells them at 50000% markup
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by bob1029 on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:24PM (#49756654)
We set off explosives to control avalanche risk.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by jjk166 on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:35PM (#49756802)
If you have an anvil hanging over your head, the potential energy that would kill you already exists. Slowly lowering the anvil makes sense. Damaging the rope holding the anvil doesn't.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by ryanisnan on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:37PM (#49756834)
I don’t think this is a good analogy.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by andrewflnr on Friday September 18, 2026 @03:59PM (#49759425)
I think the real problem is that you don't know whether it's a good analogy in your situation. You don't know whether you're lowering the anvil or just fraying the rope. It depends on a lot of hard-to-measure things about your whole geologic situation.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by Terr_ on Friday September 18, 2026 @02:17PM (#49758132)
It makes sense to me, if you consider that a "damaged rope" is a bit more elastic, so it stretches more, and allows the anvil to come to rest at a marginally lower position above your head. But only marginally.

In other words, it'd probably a terrible tradeoff to reduce the impact of some disaster by 0.0001% at the expense of making it 0.1% more likely/frequent to occur.

Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by jjk166 on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:47PM (#49756962)
If you have an ~~anvil hanging over your head~~ ton of compressed rock under you, the potential energy that would kill you already exists. Slowly lowering the ~~anvil~~ potential energy of the rock makes sense. Damaging the ~~rope holding the anvil~~ rock containing the energy doesn't.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by ryanisnan on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:57PM (#49757092)
Yeah, I mean, I understand the words you wrote. I don't think it's a good analogy.

It is entirely feasible that the same amount of potential energy, delivered either in small, successive amounts, but spaced out, proves to be tolerable, while a single large amount would be fatal.

Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by vasco on Friday September 18, 2026 @02:21PM (#49758189)
That's what they said about slowly lowering potential energy.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by wongarsu on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:56PM (#49757079)
But setting off small earthquakes doesn't just damage the rope, it also lowers the anvil. Also the anvil in our analogy is constantly getting heavier, so the chances of our rope holding forever are very low
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by moffkalast on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:46PM (#49756940)
I think this is analogus to lowering it bit by bit in small but manageable head bonks.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by jjk166 on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:51PM (#49757016)
The issue is the mechanism of "lowering" it. You're not giving it more slack.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by brightball on Friday September 18, 2026 @12:43PM (#49756903)
How does the energy for the nuke itself factor into the equation though?
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by margalabargala on Friday September 18, 2026 @03:10PM (#49758835)
A 150kt nuke has like 500,000x the energy release of a mag 3.0 earthquake, but as the article mentions that energy went into the original magnitude 6.3 event.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by samudrijan on Friday September 18, 2026 @01:05PM (#49757208)
Yeah, no.
Re:North Korean nuclear test sets off years of earthquakes by xvedejas on Friday September 18, 2026 @01:29PM (#49757537)
At least naturally, faults release almost all their energy in the few largest events. You never see enough small earthquakes that you would "release slowly" that amount of energy. It would really need to be several orders of magnitude of more energy being released slowly.