News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by UltraSane on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:35AM (#49696641)
The neural band could become a standard interface for situations where keyboards and mice are not practical.
Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by eloisant on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:58AM (#49697000)
I'm always worried about the "Midas effect" with something like that. Having to be careful not to trigger actions you don't want to.
Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by utopiah on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:32AM (#49709475)
Yep, and IMHO that's why eye tracking even though is amazing when it does work is still very limited. We do a lot of small things without even realizing and stopping to do movements we are not aware of is very very hard.
Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by fidotron on Monday September 14, 2026 @09:38AM (#49696686)
Does it really have enough fidelity of distinguishing gestures for that today?

I was under the impression the set is pretty limited and maybe not completely robust (like per person setup/calibration etc.)

Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by ileonichwiesz on Monday September 14, 2026 @01:16PM (#49700490)
I think the inertia of familiar input devices is way too high for something like that to gain any sort of traction. For better or for worse, the mainstream user is probably not leaving his QWERTY keyboard and his touchscreen, even in use cases where those are highly suboptimal.
Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by eadwu on Monday September 14, 2026 @02:13PM (#49701359)
Keyboards are wildly suboptimal. Inertia is only an issue when you replace suboptimal with only slightly better suboptimal. The transition period from blackberry (keyboard-based phones) to iphones did not take long at all (relatively speaking of course).
Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by utopiah on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:24AM (#49709410)
suboptimal for which tasks and what's better then?

I spend a LOT of time with different interfaces (eye tracking, 6DoF controllers, pens, touchpad in keyboard, ergonomic mouse, etc) and... basically if there is 1 thing I'm confident about is that input methods are very task dependent. If you want to input text, especially hard to pronounce keywords and symbols, keyboard is great, if you want to move a pointer at arbitrary position in 3D keyboard sucks. It also depends on the context, behind a desk vs on the move is totally different.

So yes quite curious about such a wide statement.

Re:Show HN: Kinesis – Control your Mac with the Meta Neural ... by utopiah on Tuesday September 15, 2026 @04:32AM (#49709467)
IMHO inertia isn't the biggest factor, training requirement is.

I switched recently from mouse to touchpad and ... next day my great ergonomic mouse was basically in a drawer. Meanwhile when I tried to use Tap Strap the first step was to learn combinations with basically no gradient of feedback, it was either success or failure.

Inertia isn't such a big problem if the investment is small but if you have to learn an entirely new way then it's a huge risk.