When I'm sitting in my home and I want to turn off the AC unit in the other room or close my garage door, there's no reason I should have to do an IP roundtrip to the manufacturer's server. Both devices are on my LAN. They should just talk to each other. This has been a solved problem for decades.
(I know this doesn't change what Vizio did, but it might get your perfect device back)
If you can firewall your LAN - you can also firewall your WiFi.
IMO, the moment a device starts doing that, I’m setting it on fire.
Huh? Your WiFi is (part of) your LAN.
I’m pointing out safe or not has nothing to do with it being on a LAN or not.
Notably, a device can even route all command and control through a cloud service, including sending copies/hashes of all accessed content AND serve just local (as in physically connected) media/content even, if it has a network connection.
This has been an issue since BluRAY at least, where players have the capability to check physical media licensing and deny/brick BluRAY media based on network updates of the keys, and could run Java apps which had network access. So at least 20 years?
The only way to prevent that is to firewall off or physically disconnect any network access.
In this example, for instance, I bet these LG TV’s will happily send all this info even if no one is using any network or app based media streaming at all.
I'm not really sure what the disconnect is here. This seems like the obvious meaning of "works over the LAN" and it means, by definition, that you can control the device without letting it access the manufacturer's servers.
A LAN (or WiFi) typically has routability to the Internet (though doesn’t have to, of course!) which is why what you are saying is confusing. It has for at least 20 years, and is especially true in residential, but also true even in commercial.
Those some IP addresses could also be NAT’d, and often are.
Most modern products have also spent significant R&D figuring out how to bypass NAT and firewalls and even hide from packet inspection (tunneling DNS and command and control over HTTPS, for one example).
Very few people are able to handle or setup actual air gapped LANs now (or isolated VLANs), but anything besides that is risky in these scenarios.
Are you real?
Something you can just scan a QR code with your phone and it hooks it into your backups so your "cloud backup" is sitting in your utility room at home instead of being "someone elses computer"
Obviously this is all achievable by a savvy techie, but I'm thinking along the lines of a black box any idiot can use.
The idea is very appealing to me, I would love to decentralize "the cloud" for your average person.
And if it were possible to get one of these in every house and apartment, then the idea of a "smart home" starts to really click in ways it doesn't right now. Your smart home would have a "home cloud" box that acts as the brain
Idk. I think there's a product idea here somewhere but ultimately it's just something I'm kicking around now and then.
Your average ‘idiot’ can barely get a managed App to work, and that typically requires some kind of cloud endpoint to co-ordinate.
Other stuff is the land of prosumer.
Remote access without the central server seems to make direct attack easier?
1) multiple wifi networks 2) ‘guest mode’ wifi networks (you can’t communicate to other devices on the same network) 3) various airplane mode type scenarios where they have cellular but not wifi connections semi-randomly, even on the same property/area.
these all happen with out of the box ISP setups pretty regularly, btw.
and they’ll just blame you for the flakiness.
also, for most of them, they love remote access anyway and don’t want to consider the security implications.
Truly though, smart-home stuff runs the whole gamut of privacy and device manufacturer relationships. eg: I have used three different smart/room AC units:
- one requires its own cloud-enabled app for any remote connectivity, no HomeKit integration - one integrates with HomeKit but then leaves an upgrade hint that can only be done through an app with a login - one integrates with HomeKit and pretty much just works
HomeKit then allows me to remotely control via HomePod/AppleTV acting as a router ... of course this is just a different cloud connectivity but with on-premises devices controlling other on-premises devices.
For each manufacturer of smart devices, there is potentially a separate cloud where data is being funneled through. Some devices support multiple upstreams.
I get that Matter should be a way to fix it but the reality feels more like https://xkcd.com/927/
Part of me just wants dumb devices back. Get rid of buttons on a microwave (just give me a knob for time and maybe another knob for power setting.) Remove touchscreens from cars (mine glares at me with certain sun-angles.) Bring back the desktop/computer hutch and phones that don't live in your pocket. However, having the ability to start cooling my bedroom 45 minutes before I arrive home is ... pretty compelling too.