News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @01:42AM (#49669238)
The Lean proof is published, you can download it. The clock definitely is ticking.

Edit: Oh, didn't see the "qualifying outlet" condition. But Poincare was ever just put on arXiv, so arXiv must count as well.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by adastra22 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:26AM (#49669476)
Publish in academic language means accepted peer-reviewed paper.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by fc417fc802 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:52AM (#49670022)
I run this journal that you've never heard of that might interest you. I'd also like to invite you to be an editor, you can put it on your CV of course ...
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:57AM (#49669655)
Accepted by whom? Peer-reviewed by whom?

I guess these little questions are what this article is really about.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by d0mine on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:20AM (#49669816)
> “The ultimate decision as to whether a publication qualifies as a “Qualifying Outlet” shall reside in the sole and unfettered discretion of CMI.”
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:32AM (#49669904)
Hehehe.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by athrowaway3z on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:56AM (#49670047)
By peers.

Peer in peer-reviewed is a logical coherent and functional definition with answers.

The logical issue with 'peers' is how to bootstrap it. At that bootstrap moment you can ask "by whom?". We are several centuries past that moment.

The cultural/social question you might ask today is "why (keep) them?".

At which point people will naturally ask you to make a strong case for "why not them?".

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:10AM (#49670137)
> Peer in peer-reviewed is a logical coherent and functional definition with answers.

What is the definition? If you tell me that, then I might be able to tell you if it is logical coherent and functional, I have a PhD in computational logic.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by da_chicken on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:46AM (#49670361)
Amongst all this rhetorical brush-beating, what were you trying to teach the snakes?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by wokwokwok on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:14AM (#49670523)
Your (many) replies on this topic are being down voted for a reason; please either post substantive comments or stop.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:26AM (#49670594)
Yes, for a reason, but not a reasonable reason, but the same reason you have for your comment: you just don’t know any better.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by raverbashing on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:41AM (#49670997)
> I have a PhD in computational logic.

And you don't know how the peer-review system works?

Just a hunch but Claude saying your work is "PhD level" does not count

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @01:46PM (#49675006)
I know that it doesn't work.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by athrowaway3z on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:05AM (#49671953)
Something like this sketch work for you?

peer(X, 0) :- founding_peer(X).

electorate(T, count<Y>) :- peer(Y, T).

support(X, T, count<Y>) :- candidate(X), peer(Y, T), recognizes(Y, X, T+1).

peer(X, T+1) :- support(X, T, Votes), electorate(T, Total), 2 * Votes > Total.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @01:49PM (#49675052)
Still waiting for a definition. People giving nonsense reviews is a feature of the peer review system though, yes.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by athrowaway3z on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:14PM (#49677277)
I want to ensure your PhD is actually from somebody who is acknowledged in the system of peers I bought into, before I want to risk wasting more of my time defining and explain while guessing at your ability to parse and understand them.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by auggierose on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:14PM (#49677778)
Or you could just give me a sensible definition.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:06AM (#49670111)
> The logical issue with 'peers' is how to bootstrap it. At that bootstrap moment you can ask "by whom?". We are several centuries past that moment.

Huh? We're about six decades past that moment.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by syncsynchalt on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:43PM (#49676989)
Presumably the organization giving away the million dollars is the arbiter of that question.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by Razengan on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:54AM (#49671071)
Seems like artificial and maybe bitter gatekeeping
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by AnimalMuppet on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:29AM (#49672128)
For giving away a million bucks, you get to gatekeep however you choose.

But no, peer reviewed and published in a reputable journal is a fairly normal standard.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by pred_ on Saturday September 12, 2026 @10:46AM (#49672858)
And just to spell it out, since it looks like HackerNews is flooded by people who are new to science these days: even if a result doesn't come with a price, scholarly peer review is the norm across all of science: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scholarly_peer_review
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by karmakurtisaani on Saturday September 12, 2026 @12:12PM (#49673879)
This is a good reminder for the generation grown up in the era of trust-me-bro benchmarks.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by limagnolia on Saturday September 12, 2026 @11:07AM (#49673085)
Being normal doesn't necessarily mean it isn't gatekeeping- gatekeeping is also quite "normal" in many cases.

That being said, I think there needs to be some standard, and peer review seems like the best we have come up with. But is the current status quo for scientific publication the best we can do? I think that is an open question and we should be able to openly discuss alternatives.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by AnimalMuppet on Saturday September 12, 2026 @11:50AM (#49673583)
"Is it the best we can do?" is a completely different question from "given that it's the current standard, should it be applied to this new claim that is happening now?"
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by Razengan on Saturday September 12, 2026 @11:08AM (#49673095)
The whole "reputable" marker is where it gets into "True Scotsman" territory

and the whole "publishing papers" thing gets called out as a racket even on HN now and then

with many videos against it by former "academia" on YouTube.

The sooner AI brings down such archaic customs into a gibbering pile of protesting rubble, the better innit?

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by AnimalMuppet on Saturday September 12, 2026 @11:48AM (#49673558)
Depends. What replaces it? Does that replacement do better at keeping false claims out, or worse? Does it do better at letting true claims through, or worse?
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by Razengan on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:10PM (#49676020)
One thing's for certain: True and false should not depend on convincing people.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by qlte on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:08PM (#49676668)
Instead of a committee of subject matter experts they should use a more rigorous and trustworthy standard, like passing the solution to ChatGPT with the prompt "did this win?"
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by AnimalMuppet on Saturday September 12, 2026 @08:25PM (#49678655)
Real true or false - which I define as correspondence (or lack thereof) with reality - does not depend on convincing people. Reality does not change when people become convinced; ideas correspond to reality whether people are convinced or not.

But perceived truth and falsehood depend on convincing people - either convincing them one by one, or else convincing some gatekeeper, whose word will convince those who accept the gatekeeper.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by Razengan on Sunday September 13, 2026 @02:51AM (#49680791)
So if an AI proves something but ""rEpUtAbLe"" papers refuse to publish it just on grounds of it being AI, does that make it not true?

You know in the past women (and other marginalized people) weren't allowed to publish scientific papers for the majority of human history?

Is this how you want your "truth" to be?

If so then man, no sympathy; these institutions deserve to be broken down. Let them spaz on the floor and throw tantrums all they want.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by YeGoblynQueenne on Sunday September 13, 2026 @03:55PM (#49688004)
... marginalized people ...

... spaz on the floor ...

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by fasterik on Saturday September 12, 2026 @07:58AM (#49671424)
I find it hard to believe that if someone published a preprint on arXiv for one of the Millennium problems and it was accepted by the mathematical community, that Clay would withhold the prize.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by CGMthrowaway on Saturday September 12, 2026 @11:02AM (#49673008)
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by adastra22 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @03:38PM (#49676357)
Not sure what your point is? When they say published they mean peer review. Regardless of what you think about publication, that's what it means.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by qlte on Saturday September 12, 2026 @04:04PM (#49676639)
Unless you're suggesting they should change the existing qualification criteria to accommodate a group unwilling to play by the same rules as everyone else, I'm not sure why that's relevant.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by raegis on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:23AM (#49669463)
If I recall (too lazy to check) folks made slight improvements to Perelman's work and published it in mainstream journals, satisfying the "qualifying outlet" requirement.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by mr_mitm on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:02AM (#49671924)
I checked, you're right, but I think it's important to note that the prize did go to Perelman and he declined to accept.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by moffkalast on Saturday September 12, 2026 @05:24AM (#49670580)
Anyone can put anything on arxiv, it counts the same as printing it on tissue paper.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by setopt on Saturday September 12, 2026 @06:31AM (#49670932)
Not really. It's not peer reviewed, but it's also not a free-for-all repository.

If you make a new account, you either have to get someone to vouch for you, or you have to wait arXiv mods to look carefully through your first few preprints. If you are found to post pseudoscience, overly fringe theories, etc., you'll get banned from arXiv; that's why alternative repositories like vixRa.org popped up.

But I know why you think this; when I first joined arXiv many years, there were no such checks in place, at least not that I can remember.

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by mr_mitm on Saturday September 12, 2026 @09:03AM (#49671942)
I also don't remember checks, but I believe that having an email address of an approved organization was enough to pass.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by whateverboat on Saturday September 12, 2026 @02:31PM (#49675552)
No. You do have checks, it's just that once you publish 4-5 papers, 99% of your field is open to you so you never have to do the checks again.
Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by aeve890 on Saturday September 12, 2026 @10:40AM (#49672796)
>Anyone

Strangely enough, the crackpots seems to prefer vixra.org to publish their work. I've never seen something like "4D wormholes can cure cancer" in ArXiv

Re:Clay Mathematics Institute on the Navier-Stokes Problem by fasterik on Saturday September 12, 2026 @08:58AM (#49671897)
I think the rules technically exclude the arXiv as a qualifying outlet.

Without limiting any other provision in this Section, a publication lacking any of the following characteristics will be deemed not to be a Qualifying Outlet:

i. an editorial board whose members are named and available for contact;

ii. an editor or editorial board member whose professional knowledge of the global mathematics community would enable him or her to identify an appropriate referee to review a submitted paper;

iii. a published refereeing process that, in the opinion of CMI, ensures that a submitted paper is reviewed and verified by appropriate experts in the field of the Problem; or

iv. inclusion in the list of publications maintained by MathSciNet.

The solution to the Poincaré conjecture was only accepted after an exposition of Perelman's proof was published in a refereed journal. His papers didn't qualify, but of course he got the credit for the result.