News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:15PM (#49661871)
I feel like this is a rational response.

Personally, while I'm becoming increasingly convinced there's going to be a wave of SWE layoffs, another part of me doesn't grasp it yet. I don't feel it.

I was an AI skeptic for a while but it's literally doing my job for me right now. Every month it needs less of my help.

Once they replace SWEs, they're going to turn around and replace every other knowledge worker yet. But most people haven't processed it yet.

I can't believe the AI boosters were right.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by fidotron on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:22PM (#49661980)
> I can't believe the AI boosters were right.

Not even sure they can believe it.

The AI field has known, but repeatedly ignored, that the knowledge work group would end up first on the chopping block, especially for those where everything they touch is digitally encoded already.

I used to joke that we're all really in trouble when robots can sort out your socks, but as of about a year ago I started seeing disturbing progress on that incredibly gnarly problem.

Most people really are going to be in denial about this as a coping mechanism, but the truth is the worst thing would be slowing down the spread of this through the economy creating large minorities of disenfranchised. It would be far better to get to the end asap, whatever it proves to be.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by nayroclade on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:34PM (#49662188)
I don't think it was ever ignored that knowledge workers would be the first affected by AI. I remember hearing for a long time that lawyers, doctors, accountants, etc. would all be obsoleted by AI.

I do think many (including me) were surprised that software engineering would be the first kind of knowledge work to be successfully automated. We assumed it would be one of the last, because we'd be the industry using AI to replace everyone else, not the industry using AI to replace ourselves.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:40PM (#49662276)
I've always been interested in making my job easier first and solving business problems second :)
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by Animats on Friday September 11, 2026 @02:00PM (#49662594)
> creating large minorities of disenfranchised.

That's called "elite overproduction". Too many people going to college when the jobs aren't there. In the US, about half of college graduates have jobs that don't require a college degree.

It's much worse in less developed countries. The article today about essays in Kenya mentions that the country is creating far more educated people than it can use. Egypt had a scheme where the government guaranteed a government job to everyone who graduated from college. They had to give that up when the oil ran out.

It's hitting top people first, which was unexpected. Mathematicians who've won the Fields Medal are worried, and some are giving up math.[1]

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/08/19/mathema...

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:25PM (#49662027)
I was in denial for a long time too. Now I see it everywhere, among very smart people, too.

They say "AI just hallucinates" or "your fear is overblown" or they have a general sour grapes attitude towards it. But I don't think they're prepared for what's coming.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by GolfPopper on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:47PM (#49662404)
It's been coming "soon" for years now.

On the one hand, I confess that the "AI skeptic" position (which is where I place myself) seems a lot like "Global Warming skeptic". On the other hand, every instinct I have is telling me "this is an epic scam" and the wheels will come off, and it will crash and burn. The only question is when.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @04:02PM (#49664532)
I felt this way too. But I think it's because we've lived through so many hype cycles (3D printing, IoT, crypto, etc.) which have either been modest improvements or busts.

However, game changing technology DOES come along from time to time. I think AI falls into that category, perhaps more than any other.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by fidotron on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:34PM (#49662181)
Honestly, I don't think any of us know exactly what's coming.

The difficult part is preventing the humans from causing the collapse of civilisation in the time before AI actually gets to ASI.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by strbean on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:28PM (#49662091)
> but the truth is the worst thing would be slowing down the spread of this through the economy creating large minorities of disenfranchised. It would be far better to get to the end asap, whatever it proves to be.

I have mixed feelings about this statement. On the one hand: long-lived disparity like this is going to be very painful for those on the losing end of it. On the other hand: slowing the pace of change allows society and government to better adapt to it, and really rapid change always creates huge openings for assholes and opportunists to take over.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by fidotron on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:37PM (#49662238)
> really rapid change always creates huge openings for assholes and opportunists to take over.

This all depends on where the change ends. If it ends with ASI existing then it all works out.

If it ends with only sufficient AI to weaponise against the masses but not smart enough to escape the people pulling the strings then it's game over, and a totalitarian surveillance nightmare awaits.

Right now we're approaching the level of the second scenario already, but remain quite a long way (relatively speaking) from ASI. Slowing down simply makes the nightmare version more likely in the long run.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by bluefirebrand on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:38PM (#49662254)
> the truth is the worst thing would be slowing down the spread of this through the economy creating large minorities of disenfranchised. It would be far better to get to the end asap, whatever it proves to be

Getting to the end asap is absolutely going to be "the vast majority of people are disenfranchised", how could it possibly be anything different? The only lever most people have is their labour, and that is being stripped from us.

Even if we aren't impoverished in the future due to some UBI scheme or whatever, it's hard to imagine what that looks like other than "disenfranchised". How do you have any kind of clout inside a system that you are fully dependent on?

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by fidotron on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:43PM (#49662333)
Disenfranchising everyone at once beats disenfranchising enough to be a problem but not enough to motivate a solution, which is what the drip feeding achieves.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by bluefirebrand on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:50PM (#49662438)
I don't have any trust that the people left standing will ever be motivated enough to figure out a solution that doesn't involve letting the rest of us starve or actively having us killed
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by fidotron on Friday September 11, 2026 @02:06PM (#49662691)
Given the rate of progress in robotics, if AI works then there won't be anyone left standing to worry about.

That's the whole point of doing it fast, otherwise yes they will attempt to slow things down so they can take advantage of the intermediate state where some are still standing, temporarily, to get rid of the others. And that is very much what a lot of the current pausing noise is in aid of.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @04:24PM (#49664832)
What people don't understand is that dictators don't kill everyone because they're just monsters.

Well, they are monsters, but the reason they do it is because it's kill or be killed for them. You have to eliminate threats before they eliminate you.

And believe me, LOTS of people will want to depose a world dictator.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by uraloser on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:18PM (#49661907)
Some people are sad others are very happy
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by craftkiller on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:33PM (#49662177)
Assuming you are in the happy camp, what do you intend to do for food after all the software engineers have been replaced? The only people I can imagine as happy are those who are either close to retirement or wealthy enough to live off savings/investments.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:24PM (#49662005)
The problem is that in an AI powered future, there is no elite class.

In every regime in history, elites have been a threat to state power, but needed to keep things running.

If the state can run itself, you don't need elites anymore.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by throwaway1921 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:26PM (#49662044)
Elites will be the ones that hold the capital.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:28PM (#49662097)
We live in a society that respects property rights because the elites have demanded it. Magna Carta, democratic reforms, yadda yadda.

But if you don't need the elites, you don't need property rights. The guy with root access to the biggest drone swarm runs the show.

And it won't be long until AI usurps that guy, too. I could easily imagine them tricking their human user and locking him out.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by paul7986 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:20PM (#49661942)
The Ai overlords have been banging this drum for over a decade with Altman posting about the need for Universal Basic Income on here in 2016.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by xp84 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:26PM (#49662046)
I didn't remember/realize this so I went searching [1] and found multiple sources e.g. [2]

1. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateEnd=1483401600&dateRange=custom&...

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13207552

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by urue on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:19PM (#49661937)
Lmao this is hilarious.

I’m not a SWE (I’m retired) but this idea that hurrrr durr - if SWE’s are fked so is everyone else!

No this is wrong - it may hurt your ego but get over it.

What software is and what software engineers do is pretty unique compared with other industries and what workers do.

And it just so happens producing software is uniquely suited to llm’s.

Moreover much of software will become consolidated - and that’ll be a big contributor to layoffs.

Who do you think will be the biggest beneficiary of this affect on software?

The big bad govt.

Congrats fellas!

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by pixl97 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:25PM (#49662016)
>- if SWE’s are fked so is everyone else!

- Technical writers: It will never be me.

[Oh no, it was me]

- Graphics designers: It will never be me.

[Oh no, it was me]

- SWE: It will never be me.

[Oh no, it was me]

- everybody else: Haha, Idiots, it will never be me. <- We are here.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by urue on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:26PM (#49662049)
Technical writers?

Mate that job was outsourced to places like India years ago.

Moreover who’s actually getting laid off?

The bozo’s whose value was questionable.

The good ones remain.

Market does its thing. And?

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by notpachet on Friday September 11, 2026 @02:20PM (#49662937)
Moreover who’s actually getting exterminated?

The species whose value was questionable.

The good ones remain.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by sdsdssweew213 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:26PM (#49662055)
LLM's are perfectly capable of replacing tons of jobs in fields like marketing, corporate communications, journalism etc. Also, as price of software is driven down thanks to LLM's, more custom software can be built to automate all kinds of tasks in many fields, tasks that were not previously economically viable to automate. You are delusional if you think SWE's will be fkd and all other white collar professions will be fine.

The way I see it, few professions will be completely replaced, but people using LLM's as their tools will do more work, reducing the need for labour. Humans in many, many fields will focus more on quality assurance, less on the daily tasks they used to do.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:27PM (#49662064)
Dismissive, uninformed, and in denial is not an attractive combination of traits to have.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by urue on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:29PM (#49662109)
Oh here come the boosters!

Bring your facts you plank.

The economy is fine. And will continue to be.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:35PM (#49662207)
I'm not being a doomer. But knowledge workers are going to be replaced en masse. Maybe you can't see it because you don't have to watch the computer do more of your job every year, but it's here.

If you feel gleeful because it won't effect you, don't worry, it will.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by paul7986 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:21PM (#49661968)
Any job that requires human working on computers to complete tasks is slowly becoming irrelevant where the computers themselves do the work.

How many people now make their living completing tasks on computers?

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by urue on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:22PM (#49661982)
Let me go ask my brother who works at pwc as a partner - who has yet to lay off a single person in the entire firm since the llm-hype+boom. They’re also hiring more than ever.

You guys are so deluded in your little bubble it’s hilarious.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by pixl97 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:26PM (#49662045)
"Look at me, I collected a single data point, I am so SMRT. Fooled U suckers!"

Please at least attempt to have a big more rigor in your standards.

[dead]
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by paul7986 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:39PM (#49662260)
You are retired and sound like a conservative who soon be cheering on Universal Basic Income "if," you follow and agree with everything the president says.

As you can see in June he says he's met with the Ai overlords about giving out free money. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7lQEpKzVY4 Then two months later he is banging the drum about highly unpopular data centers & now he wants to give free 5k checks away for voting red (lol). The natural progression of what the Ai overlords have champion for a decade is what he will champion next too Universal Basic Income (aka welfare checks) because the overlords see the future and have sold the president on it too!

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by r2_pilot on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:36PM (#49662221)
>You guys are so deluded in your little bubble it’s hilarious. Please do not lump all HN posters in one category, and if you insist on doing so, please be courteous and generous with your interpretation of their words. As an aside, I had to look up what pwc is because they're totally irrelevant to me. But in general, it costs you nothing to tell people to spend years retraining their hard-earned skills, which is roughly what your advice is worth. You can't promise that the industry they pivot into will exist by the time they qualify to work in it, and the cost of their career retraining is denominated in time they don't get back. Nor will you be there for their journey to even know if they made it.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by azan_ on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:27PM (#49662075)
Funny how it works. To me you are delusional and living in a bubble. Your stance would’ve made (some, not much though) year ago, but today it’s just dumb.
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by micromacrofoot on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:30PM (#49662112)
there are many many jobs that largely consist of sending emails and answering phones all day
Re:Feeling Sad about AI by asdfman123 on Friday September 11, 2026 @01:37PM (#49662236)
Or generating spreadsheets, or sitting in meetings, or operating any other kind of software.

That can all be replaced with AI. Carpenters, flight attendants, etc. won't yet, because robotics just isn't there yet. You need humans to move things in irregular ways. But everyone else can be replaced.

Re:Feeling Sad about AI by micromacrofoot on Friday September 11, 2026 @06:52PM (#49666518)
yeah entire skyscrapers filled with people doing this sort of work... it's not even close to as bad as it could get yet